Posted on 11/04/2026 5:25:12 AM PST by Red Badger
Pieces of the tail of the Learjet that crashed in Florida have been found miles away from the crash site, which suggests that part of the aircraft broke off before it hit the ground, according to the National Transportation Safety Board.
Federal investigators found three pieces of the jet's left elevator between 1.3 and 3.8 miles from the impact site in Palm Beach County, Florida, NTSB member Thomas Champman said Tuesday, the Wall Street Journal reported.
The plane's elevator controls the aircraft's pitch up or down, and without it, an aircraft cannot recover from a nose dive.
Chapman said that the discovery of the pieces suggests that these key parts separated from the aircraft prior to impact.
"What that means exactly in terms of what caused the aircraft to lose control, or whether the loss of this piece was a result of the forces on the aircraft, we don’t know yet," he said.
The Learjet 60 departed from Austin, Texas, and was heading for Eleuthera Island in the Bahamas when it crashed Sunday, killing all nine people on board.
Rather than waving your stupidity around like you were proud of it, the most of you would be better off waiting to see what comes out in the accident report.
But of course you won’t do that because you’re not curious enough to follow up, you just want to post ignorant claptrap for your own aggrandizement and then call it a day.
???
There's nothing that points toward that. They were in an overspeeding condition in a steep dive, descending more than 30,000 feet per minute in an icing condition that would worsen the more they flew through precipitation. The aircraft would flutter, where control-surface oscillations can escalate in seconds. Each oscillation gains energy, so the vibration can grow very quickly into loss of control or structural failure.
Suggests?
The intelligence behind that is astounding.
what an asinine comment... this is a discussion forum where people talk about things.
Who gave you the “I’m a superior intellect award”!??
There is always a loudmouth that wants to talk smack like a midmorning drunk. Red posted an article based on the NTSB statement. Hardly the clap trap you claim.
I believe that you are correct.
Pilots flying in Florida avoid thunderstorms. These two didn't. It was a storm cell so powerful that it reached 35,000 feet.
Add in icing, a dive into overspeeding conditions, and yes, the elevator is coming off.
Aircraft of all types try to avoid thunderstorms, because there is risk of the aircraft being damaged, injuring passengers and even worse.
Now that the NTSB has parts from the tail section, they will be able to determine how it failed and where in the flight path it failed.
OK, OK - as a retired 767 captain and former Line Check Airman in the 737 with over 18,000 flight hours, the keyboard speculators are driving me nuts! How about something factual for a change:
The NTSB says it recovered the aircraft’s left elevator in three pieces between 1.3 and 3.8 miles from the crash site. Most likely, it broke off at FL150-250 due to stress from the overspeed dive. i.e., damaged during the dive, NOT the damage that caused the dive.
“We always fly in ridiculous cold temperatures.”
“Usually you get the bad ice when the temperatures are like 0 to negative 20. Believe it or not, there’s a point where it gets too cold for ice. At negative 40, you pretty much can’t get ice. Besides that, the airplane is equipped with hot wings and hot tail.”
“I flew the Lear 60 for like 15 years. It’s a no joke airplane and probably the most dangerous airplane I’ve ever flown. It has a super critical wing. The airflow has to be perfect. When it gets into rough air and turbulence, it will easily stall. It has stalled on me at 41,000 feet just because we got into some turbulence. (On the way to Palm Beach as a matter of fact.) We recovered and got her flying again around 30,000 ft. Scary.
But here’s the problem. This airplane has a terrible coffin corner. (At high altitudes) What that means is, you fly in a really narrow window where if you lose 20 knots, it stalls. And if you gain 20 knots, it goes into overspeed. The air goes supersonic over the wing and it goes into a high speed stall, or worse, a Mach tuck.
So if you stall, the normal recovery is to push the yoke forward to lower the nose and gain air speed again. At low altitude, you can push really hard and recover quickly. But in the 60... if you push hard, it will gain air speed and go into a high speed stall, it doesn’t take much. It’s very sensitive. The 60 has super short wings that don’t make much lift. So then you high speed stall, and the computer is yelling at you... OVERSPEED! So then you pull back and enter a low speed stall. And you go back and forth trying to keep it in the air speed window.
This whole thing is pretty scary. And you should recover basically by using your finger tips using super small corrections. You can’t over do it. If you try to muscle the recovery, she gets mad and will become unrecoverable. If she enters a mach tuck. You’re done.”
“I taught the Lear 60 to other pilots and mentored them. I told them... this airplane has a soul and it’s trying to kill you. Do not ever try to top the weather. Don’t go over a thunderstorm. Go around it. If it means a half hour longer, then do it. Going over the thunderstorm will go into turbulence that you might not recover from.
These pilots went right over a thunderstorm. I think it stalled which caused them to drop down into the thunderstorm and ended up in mach tuck. They picked up so much speed that it ripped off the horizontal stabilizer. At that point... chuck Yeager can’t fix it.
These same pilots did something similar a couple months ago. ATC got mad at them. They poked the bear one too many times.
This is not a beginner’s airplane.
I have read that the storm cell they flew into was a fast developing one, adjacent to one they were already flying around. I have also read that the Learjet 60 is a fickle design, with slow and fast stall speeds that converge quickly in a fast climb. I’m not a pilot, but I have been in the aerospace business for over 30 years.
At somewhere around 13 minutes he mentions descent of 32,000 feet/minute, unless I'm doing this wrong; 5280 ft = 1 mile, so about 6 miles per minute, X 60 = 364 miles per hour. That's no where close to supersonic, it's about half that speed. It's faster than I'd ever want to fall but, my BIL's Baron can do nearly 300mph straight and level, his F/A 18 would do 1190mph.
And the Learjet 60 max is 536mph, so that 364 is not even close to overspeed.
Add in a 60 to 90 degree bank........
As with all these air disasters we won't know for years, and when they finally spill what they have it may or may not answer and satisfy the curious.
My point is the quoted rate of decent is only scary if you have no way to pull out of the dive. Air shows probably do it every day. But if you're reporting unrecoverable dive speed at near 30,000 feet, you'll be traveling considerably faster on impact.
Heavy ice overloaded the entire tail. It let go when they maneuvered to get above it all. It doesnt descend any way except for straight down after that.
It sounds like the Lear 60 has a razor thin performance envelope at altitude. I don’t believe icing was the problem since the Lear has a comprehensive suite of de-icing equipment. Unless of course when they were fighting turbulence, pilots forgot to activate it.
A professional pilot noted that from the crash video within hours of the crash.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.