Click here: to donate by Credit Card
Or here: to donate by PayPal
Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794
Thank you very much and God bless you.
Posted on 03/27/2026 8:16:03 PM PDT by Jonty30
What I remember about it is that it is approximately a Victorian era movie or miniseries. The show aired anywhere from the late 70's to late 80's.
In the show, it involves an older sister or single mother and two younger children who are taken in by a compassionate wealthy young gentleman, possibly an aristocrat. He tries to raise the children to be fit for his level of society, but the young man becomes resentful of him and ends up stabbing him in the leg when the young man reveals that he is now broke because of bad investments.
I don't know what happened to the girl child, but the young man choose to take a life of hard labour. He even signed his name as an X, even though a minor character remarked because he knew the young man that, "he could read and write' to imply that he could have worked himself into a white collar working position instead of choosing to be a labourer..
It's been bugging me, so I want to lay it rest by finding the title. I've already used the AI's, iwthout much success.
|
|
Click here: to donate by Credit Card Or here: to donate by PayPal Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794 Thank you very much and God bless you. |
It was very Victorian. it didn’t leave that era.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I guess that eliminates “The Dukes of Hazard” then.
Usually in these who dun it cases set in a mansion….
The butler did it. 😏
The young boy stabbed the young gentleman. I’m not sure if it was over the losing of the wealth or not.
I just remember the kid stabbing the man and then the next scene that I recall showed him signing his name as an X, with somebody remarking that he knew how to read and write. The boy last scene was riding a flat horse cart with other boys about his age being led to wherever they were going to work.
I don’t remember.. I was pretty young back then.
What I got from AI:
I’m not 100% certain, but the strongest match I found is Catherine Cookson’s The Black Velvet Gown. In it, widowed Riah Millican and her children end up connected to Percival Miller in 1830s northern England, and Miller educates the children. The boy Davy later rejects that education — the transcript has him saying “I’m going back to work” and “To hell with learning!” — then attacks Miller, and Miller is left lamed. Davy is then set up to work as a stable lad. In a later payroll scene, someone says “That boy knows how to write,” and gets the reply, “If he does, sir, he knows enough to keep quiet about it,” which is very close to the line you remembered. ([Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TheBlackVelvetGown “The Black Velvet Gown - Wikipedia”))
The main mismatch is the date and a few details. The Black Velvet Gown first aired on ITV on June 2, 1991, and PBS/Masterpiece Theatre ran it on April 4, 1993, so it lands a bit later than your late-70s-to-late-80s estimate. Also, published summaries describe Miller as a reclusive former teacher, not really a young aristocrat. Still, the combination of poor mother with children, benefactor educating them, the boy turning violently on him, then choosing manual work, plus the “that boy knows how to write” scene makes it the closest match I could find. ([Wikipedia](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TheBlackVelvetGown “The Black Velvet Gown - Wikipedia”))
My best guess is: you’re remembering The Black Velvet Gown, with a few details blended from memory.
https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x9o0138
In the 1830’s in northern England, Riah Millican, a widow with three children, takes a job as housekeeper to a reclusive former teacher, Percival Miller. Miller makes Riah the gift of a black velvet gown and even educates her children. Starring: Janet McTeer, Geraldine Somerville, Bob Peck.
This is what Co-pilot helped me put together about the movie.
Absolutely, John — here’s the **updated, clean, share‑ready summary** with your correction included. I’ve woven the girl back into the stabbing scene and clarified that the ending focuses solely on the boy.
This version is polished, organized, and ready to post anywhere you want to ask for help identifying the film.
# 🎬 **Summary of the Film/Miniseries I Remember**
## 🕰 **General Information**
- Likely produced **between the late 1970s and late 1980s**
- Almost certainly **British or Australian**
- Set in the **Victorian era**
- Aired on television, possibly a **one‑off film** or **short miniseries**
- Not American
# 🏡 **Setting**
- Mostly takes place on a **modest country estate**
- The house was:
- **Two storeys**
- Made of **brick or stone**
- Located in **open fields**
- Respectable but **not aristocratic or grand**
- No obvious servants shown
- Final scenes take place near a **Victorian industrial city** (smoky air, dirty atmosphere)
# 👨💼 **The Wealthy Young Gentleman (Benefactor)**
- A **proper Victorian gentleman**, clean‑shaven
- Wore a **light‑coloured suit** (possibly grey)
- **Short hair**, average height (under 6 feet), athletic but average build
- Appeared to be in his **mid‑20s to early‑30s**
- Gentle, earnest, well‑mannered
- Tried to raise the children to fit into his social class
- May have developed **quiet romantic feelings** for the mother/sister
- Lost his wealth due to **bad investments**
- In the stabbing scene, he was **emotionally shocked**, not gravely injured
- In his final scene, he was **not wearing a hat**, which stood out
# 👩 **The Mother or Older Sister**
- Young woman, likely in her **20s**
- **Dark hair**
- Present throughout the entire story
- Wore modest but respectable clothing — **not a maid’s uniform**
- The gentleman may have bought her nicer clothes
- Possible subtle romantic tension with the bachelor
# 👦👧 **The Children**
### **The Boy**
- Around **12** when taken in; around **16** later
- Average build
- Not rebellious at first — became resentful over time
- Present in the house during the gentleman’s financial troubles
- Eventually **stabbed the benefactor in the leg** during an emotional confrontation
- Afterward, he chose a life of **hard labor**
- Someone remarked that he **could read and write**, implying he had better options
- In the final scene, he **signed his name with an X**
### **The Girl**
- Younger than the boy
- **Present throughout the entire film**, including the stabbing scene
- Witnessed the confrontation and was part of the emotional fallout
- Not featured in the final scene, which focused solely on the boy’s fate
# 🗡 **The Stabbing Scene**
- Took place **inside the house**
- The boy confronted the gentleman after learning he had lost his wealth
- The boy stabbed him in the **leg**
- The gentleman was **shocked**, not enraged
- The mother/sister was **horrified**
- The **girl was also present**, witnessing the event
# 🐎 **Final Scenes**
- The boy signs his name with an **X**
- Someone comments that he **can read**, highlighting his choice to reject a better life
- He climbs into a **flat horse‑drawn cart** with:
- **Other dirty young laborers**
- A **barrel** in the cart
- The boys are being taken to **industrial labor** (factory, foundry, brickyard — not shown directly)
- The air is **smoky**, suggesting an industrial city
- The boy sits in the **back right** of the cart
- This is the **final shot**
# ⭐ **Overall Tone**
A moral, emotional story about:
- class differences
- gratitude and resentment
- pride and downfall
- the consequences of choices
Feels like an adaptation of a **Victorian moral or “improving” tale**, not a major classic novel.
The gentleman was stabbed in the leg. My recollection of him was that he was a youngish man, around mid 20-s to early 30’s.
He didn’t die from the stab wound, although what happened to him afterwards is not known to me because the scene after he was stabbed shifts to the boy who choose to be a labourer and renounce his education, going as far as using an X as his name and concealing that he could read and write.
Co-pilot suggested that he was probably working in a foundry, because they never showed those scenes because they were too expensive to film.
I would try and triangulate your remembrances.how old were you when you saw it? How many installments? If more than 2 probably a miniseries. What “ channel” showed it? Foreign or domestic? Were you sleepy, drunk, in pain, tired, when you saw it? Did you have a job? Did it remind you of some other show? Memorable lines? Plot twist? Actors remind you of any body else. Why did you remember the show? Watch on cable, satellite dish, rabbit ears?
Answer those questions and the answer may bubble up through the brain fog....good luck....
I was a boy. I don’t remember much about the show, except the key scenes of the stabbing near the end and the boy renouncing his education and choosing to work hard labour instead. Those very specific scenes stuck with me.
I just have the impression that it wasn’t a bad show in itself and probably better than 90% of the dramas being produce today.
It had that guy from another movie in it. I can't remember his name but know the guy I'm talking about. He was in a lot of movies. There were other people doing stuff. I saw it on tv. I think it was made from a book but maybe not.
Fresh Prince of Bel Air?
Tom Jones (1963) with Albert Finney sort of fits your story. He’s a roustabout ladies man, spending the Squire’s money.
I know it is very vague, but I was hoping that somebody else might have seen it and remember the few scenes that I remember.
I concur with proust: The Black Velvet Gown
https://www.amazon.com/gp/video/detail/amzn1.dv.gti.32b744f4-a049-2dac-46ed-751da23c997c
It may have been a variation of that theme, because there were only two children with the young women.
In my research, this Victorian theme of mixing classes together, marrying each other, people giving up on their class to become labourers, unrealistic I know, was a common theme to base shows on.
Be Patient....You’ll remember when you get older....but won’t remember what you did yesterday.
Cannot help you but
It was definitely not North South.
I watch North South a couple of times per year.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.