The best spy film of all time according to spies themselves

Express ^ | Sun, Aug 10, 2025 | Maria Leticia Gomes

[nickcarraway]

Forget the flashy gadgets and high-speed chases. A film praised by intelligence experts reveals the gritty, moral complexities of espionage like never before.

Spy films have long captured the public imagination with their blend of glamour, danger and intrigue. Yet ask anyone with real intelligence experience and you’ll hear a very different story - one filled with ambiguity, ethical dilemmas and painstaking surveillance, far removed from fun gadget-filled action sequences.

That’s why Spyscape, the museum and entertainment brand devoted to espionage, consulted real-life CIA officers to find out which film truly gets it right. They got to pick fifteen films that they thought represented their field the best, but the one which came on top was A Most Wanted Man, directed by Anton Corbijn and based on John le Carré’s acclaimed novel. Released in 2014, A Most Wanted Man stands apart from typical Hollywood fare. Set in post-9/11 Hamburg - a city still haunted by its connection to the September 11 plotters - the film follows Günther Bachmann (Philip Seymour Hoffman), a German intelligence chief tasked with tracking Issa Karpov (Grigoriy Dobrygin), a Chechen-Russian immigrant who may be an innocent refugee or a key financier for international terrorists.

The supporting cast includes Rachel McAdams as Annabel Richter, an idealistic human rights lawyer, Willem Dafoe as Thomas Brue, a conflicted banker, and Robin Wright as Martha Sullivan, a calculating US diplomat.

Director Anton Corbijn leans into the chilly realism that defines le Carré’s work. There are no car chases or innovative technology - just tense stakeouts, coded conversations in smoky bars and the relentless grind of intelligence work, all shown behind the film’s muted colour palette.

What sets A Most Wanted Man apart for intelligence professionals is its treatment of morality. Doug Patteson, a former CIA officer and security expert, told Spyscape: “I think it does a great job of capturing the moral ambiguity of espionage.”

The screenplay stays true to le Carré’s vision. As Bachmann orchestrates his trap for Karpov with clinical precision, he faces pressure not only from foreign agencies but also his own government.

Every character is forced to weigh personal conviction against professional duty - a tension that builds to a climax both devastating and believable.

A Most Wanted Man was widely praised on release. On Rotten Tomatoes it holds an 86% approval rating from critics, who commended its subtlety and intelligence.

Philip Seymour Hoffman’s performance was especially lauded - his last leading role before his death in February 2014. Critics highlighted how Hoffman portrayed Bachmann with a sense of weary determination that anchors the entire film.

A Most Wanted Man is available to watch on Apple TV and Sky Store.

---

TOPICS: TV/Movies
KEYWORDS: amostwantedman; goodmovies; movies; spies; spy; spycraft; spymovies

[bleach]

The Worricker Trilogy.
https://www.milkpublicity.com/projects/the-worricker-trilogy/

[FateAmenableToChange]

Also unfortunately Robert Redford, but really well done, and more modern, “Sneakers” was actually really good too as a quasi-spy movie.

I think it might also be the line of Jason Asano’s belief in “He Who Fights With Monsters” that numbers don’t behave like numbers when they get too large. But that’s a niche of literature geekiness.

[ptsal]

Bkmk

[GingisK]

...and the two of us are Wergans. ;-D

[virgil]

I have this movie in my collection somewhere. Watched it once, but not very memorable. I liked Tinker, Tailor, the movie and both tv series by BBC. I enjoyed The Night Manager too. I didn’t like John Le Carre’s resentment towards Americans though.

[George from New England]

Bump

[E. Pluribus Unum]

One of my favorites as well.

Max Von Sydow was perfect for his role.

[JZelle]

I know a little German.

[dfwgator]

There is sauerkraut in my lederhosen.

[dennisw]

Thanks...will get this.

[dennisw]

Cool and worth doing!

[Carry_Okie]

My fave is The President’s Analyst.

[chud]

I saw an interview with an old British intelligence agent (can't remember his name) and he said that his favorite spy film was The Ipcress File (Michael Caine, 1965).
He said he liked the film because it was the opposite of James Bond.

[nicollo]

I met a retired British spy who was stationed at Instanbul. He said that the best potrayal of CIA agents was in the Bond films’ character Felix Leiter — sticking out like a sore thumb.

[nwrep]

Agreed. What an ending.

[SuperLuminal]

Ditto!

[xp38]

One of the all time great movies.

[dfwgator]

The ending chokes me up everytime. Never has been a movie where you hate a character in the beginning and then feel so much for them at the end.

[DesertRhino]

Probably third place behind the lives of others and the best of all, the spy who came in from the cold. Both show how filthy that business actually is.

[DesertRhino]

You can’t ask spies. They will pick the one that’s most flattering to them, and flattering can mean oh woe is me, and look at the heavy burden we must carry for you. They will always pick self-aggrandizement.