Posted on 03/03/2025 9:12:11 PM PST by ConservativeMind
Researchers found commonly performed interventional procedures for chronic non-cancer spine pain may provide little to no pain relief when compared with sham procedures.
Chronic spine pain, defined as persistent pain along or referred from the spine lasting three months or longer, presents a global health challenge.
While interventional procedures such as epidural steroid injections, nerve blocks, and radiofrequency nerve ablation are frequently used, clinical guidelines have offered conflicting recommendations regarding their effectiveness.
Researchers conducted a comprehensive search.
Eighty-one trials with 7,977 patients were included in meta-analyses out of 132 eligible studies. Patients with chronic axial or radicular spine pain were randomized to receive common interventional procedures or comparators, including sham procedures and usual care.
For chronic axial spine pain, moderate certainty evidence showed that epidural injection of local anesthetic, epidural injection of local anesthetic and steroids, and joint-targeted steroid injection, result in little to no difference in pain relief compared with sham procedures.
Low certainty evidence suggests minimal pain relief differences for intramuscular and joint-targeted injections of local anesthetic, with or without steroids. Intramuscular injection of local anesthetic with steroids signaled that it may actually increase pain.
For chronic radicular spine pain, moderate certainty evidence indicates epidural injection of local anesthetic and steroids and radiofrequency of the dorsal root ganglion are unlikely to result in pain relief. Low certainty evidence suggests epidural injections of local anesthetic or steroids may also yield minimal pain relief.
In physical functioning, moderate certainty evidence shows joint-targeted injections and epidural injections with local anesthetic or steroids probably provide little to no improvement.
Low certainty evidence suggests certain procedures may slightly increase the risk of non-serious adverse events, including joint radiofrequency ablation.
When looking at the substantial cost, inconvenience, and false hope of these common procedures compared to data, it is unclear why they have persisted.
(Excerpt) Read more at medicalxpress.com ...
A friend of mine had an epidural when her son was born. She told the doctors she didn’t want an epidural, they did it anyway. Forty years later she still has back pain where they stuck her.
If I ever have a backache, I’ll take back rubs and Doan’s Pills.
I has two ablations and they did little to nothing to help me. First one seemed to help for about 6 months, then the pain cam back raging. 2nd RF ablation did absolutely nothing. Injections were not much help to no help at all and largely stopped working after about 6 times. What finally got me out of the cycle was seeing a specialist who knew what they hell he was doing and properly diagnosed me. It was my hips/SI joints, not my back causing the bulk of the pain, but because of all the referred pain I couldn’t differentiate where the pain was coming from. I also have stenosis and PSA, getting the PSA diagnosed was helpful, but I’m in a rough cycle trying to get meds straightened out that help and don’t cause the psoriasis plaques to flare out of control.
With nerve ablations, they target the facet nerves (usually), and they can grow back, sometimes in worse locations. It can take up to three ablations to completely kill off the targeted nerves. Depending on how many levels (mine was 3 the first time, 4 the second), you can expect a lot of needles in your spine by the time you’re done. For my insurance I had to go through two diagnostic procedures to get approval for the fist ablation, so by the time I was done, that was 18 needles in my back/spine. Second time was nearly 20 needles all told.
Personal experience here with chronic low back pain. I’m pretty much on a 6 out of 10 pain daily. Started getting the radiated pain down the legs and occasional severe sharp pains..only lasted a 1/2 second but had me flying out of bed or from seated position. Went to a pain management center and I crossed out several pages of paperwork and handed it in. When asked why I did that I said I won’t take any opioids or any other pain medication except ibuprofen which I take 400mg at night to help sleep. I take no prescriptions . Said I was here to get fixed, I’m not looking for a fix. They recommended the epidural and then nerve ablation. I said no.
I went to a chiropractor...a good one not the twist and snap ones. He said I can’t fix that after reading my MRIs and X-ray reports but I should be able to help with the radiated pain issues. 9 months later and that pain is gone. Still have the low back but the other is gone and I’m actually walking better.
Kind of tired of repeating myself - my testimony on my
freeper home page or read some books on chiropractic.
I suggest 2 SIMPLE SHORT BOOKS FOR STARTERS:
Chiropractic, the Superior Alternative
Chicken Soup for the Chiropractic Soul
I agree inversions machines are the cheapest least intrusive
application of chiropractic ideals, get the frame straight
all other optimization of health will follow.
So what exactly did the doctor do?
Had nerve block about 15 years ago. Worked like a charm. Will be having another next week — on a different part of the spine.
For later.
Thanks
I just had an ablation done on my lower back, after the steroid injections and so on provided little relief.
So far I am pain free.
First time in many years.
Its been 2 months.
When I got mine they knocked me out to do it..
Xray guided injections.
There was no pain or discomfort involved.
I was walking around my neighborhood in pain, which a neighbor noticed. He said he had had similar problems and recommended a really good physical therapist. Set of exercises that got me on the mend pretty quickly. Basic underlying issue is strength, stretching and flexibility. When I slack off for too long, I start getting warning signs and have to start up again. So long as I keep up I am pain free. Bummer.
I’ve been the gambit. It doesn’t work.
Yes...pilates . I had been in a car accident and had lingering, but growing back/hip problems. I asked a chiropracter I was seeing if he thought floor pilates would help. He said, it might. So, I began 2x week Pilates. Never saw the chiro for another 2 years. Did eventually have to return. Fast forward 10 years and still have back/hip issues...sooo...did 40 sessions of hyperbaric last year on the advice of another chiropracter. Hip & back pain basically gone.
Yes, as long as you find a good Chiro ...see post 33.
Until you’ve experienced it yourself, most people don’t have any idea what a struggle every day is with back pain. And why it’s easy to get addicted to pain killers.
This kind of thing rarely produces a useful result.
My "thesis" is that many MANY people don't heal correctly EXACTLY BECAUSE we do not know how to deal with/process anger.
Remember, anger is part of the process of healing, as described years ago by Kubler-Ross:
Shock
Denial
ANGER
Bargaining
Acceptance
(and the joke about depression being "anger without enthusiasm" is in the mix too)
...there's about 5-other-kabillion FReepers I wish would do the same ;)
depression being “anger without enthusiasm”.
Never heard that one before but it’s a gem.
we have had pro athletes in our studio; they’re usually in the higher level classes, while I stick to the lower levels, but when the catcher on our baseball team started being vocal about how much he relied on Pilates and how he had a studio installed in his house, we saw an uptick in those guys coming in. No famous people that I’d heard of, but a few baseball and football players.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.