Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

I was asked to keep this confidential
YouTube ^ | 2/15/2025 | Sabine Hossenfelder

Posted on 02/26/2025 4:22:53 PM PST by Jeff Chandler

I want to read you an email that I was asked to keep confidential because I think it explains some of my worries about academia.

The Nature Physics comment is here:

https://www.youtube.com/redirect?event=video_description&redir_token=QUFFLUhqbDJsQ0w2TWlKT2lraDVvOWlkaUNJcXk4SUU4Z3xBQ3Jtc0tuRF8xYXN5cjhXMktuWHcwdGZneXJyR3VKYU9PeG9WNnFGWDJCWEFGS2ZTWEtKTk5FdlY4QzN1WWU5dVJ5NGNPOU1fSHdIT1ZjR01sV3FnYW5qZEpQVzBIZkFvNUNwUWNsXzRBMzhvMGVYSWRWc1FsYw&q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.nature.com%2Farticles%2Fnphys4079&v=shFUDPqVmTg

I knew that physicists would go on to argue I should have tried to solve the problem internally (within the community) before drawing public attention to it. The reason I published this comment was so that I could later demonstrate that I did this. This is why it's a paywalled publication that you don't find on the arxiv. But just by accident and totally unrelated here is another link:

https://www.youtube.com/redirect?event=video_description&redir_token=QUFFLUhqbFJZaFlaQTR0RzJJdGxrYnVKZWtlUHJSNElNZ3xBQ3Jtc0tuVXBZUk5MaUlra1NxVlltWVNFTDB1VHE3Q3lCT2lZUzNuU1hVakxtWFl5aUZsdXpYUmJ0VHl0b0RQbmRYbmNKVVY2eUdXLUNqTXNSVDlPUUljWXVZUmpfWXA4OXBOVnBnX1haYklOMGhHbDBlcUE4RQ&q=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.dropbox.com%2Fscl%2Ffi%2F5o31k2jovu4nmyy219tzh%2Fnphys4079-1.pdf%3Frlkey%3Df5y07dj0i6ob29fuq01zgkibs%26st%3Dxtv22uph%26dl%3D0&v=shFUDPqVmTg


TOPICS: Miscellaneous; Science; Weird Stuff
KEYWORDS: academia; nonsense; physics; science
Interesting expose of "follow the science" nonsense and the waste of taxpayer money.

About eight minutes long.

1 posted on 02/26/2025 4:22:53 PM PST by Jeff Chandler
[ Post Reply]

To: Jeff Chandler

Sabine is one of my fav YouTube sites.
She is learning about fake science like we are learning about RINO’s.


2 posted on 02/26/2025 4:42:54 PM PST by Zathras
[ Post Reply]

To: Zathras

Sabine, blowin’ that whistle!


3 posted on 02/26/2025 4:53:38 PM PST by one guy in new jersey
[ Post Reply]

To: Zathras

Yes, I enjoy her site also. She still has not yet escaped the mental bondage of believing in all the tenets of the secular cult of ‘man made climate change’.


4 posted on 02/26/2025 5:04:46 PM PST by House Atreides (I’m now ULTRA-MAGA-PRO-M)
[ Post Reply]

[snip] No group of peers would have approved my building the 72-inch bubble chamber. Even Ernest Lawrence told me he thought I was making a big mistake. He supported me because he knew my track record was good. I believe that U.S. science could recover from the stultifying effects of decades of misguided peer reviewing if we returned to the tried-and-true method of evaluating experimenters rather than experimental proposals. Many people will say that my ideas are elitist, and I certainly agree. The alternative is the egalitarianism that we now practice and that I've seen nearly kill basic science in the USSR and in the People's Republic of China. [/snip]
- Luis Alvarez | Alvarez : adventures of a physicist | Page 201

5 posted on 02/26/2025 6:50:03 PM PST by SunkenCiv (Putin should skip ahead to where he kills himself in the bunker.)
[ Post Reply]

To: Jeff Chandler

Bfl


6 posted on 02/27/2025 1:13:20 AM PST by RoosterRedux ("There's nothing so inert as a closed mind" )
[ Post Reply]

To: Zathras

Yep. Luv Sabine.


7 posted on 02/27/2025 3:39:44 AM PST by RoosterRedux ("There's nothing so inert as a closed mind" )
[ Post Reply]

To: Jeff Chandler
Here's my take on Sabine's message:

She warns that high-energy physics has become a self-sustaining bubble where meaningless research is funded to keep scientists employed rather than advance knowledge. She criticizes taxpayer money being wasted on overhyped projects like DUNE and Brookhaven’s collider, predicting the system will eventually collapse. Her message calls for accountability and integrity in science.

Though not discussed in the video, Sabine's point of view aligns with that of Eric Weinstein—modern theoretical physics is stagnant, self-serving, and detached from empirical progress.

They both argue that the field prioritizes career preservation over discovery, with funding sustaining empty theorizing rather than producing real breakthroughs. Sabine warns that public funding is being wasted on hype-driven projects, while Weinstein critiques academia's gatekeeping and lack of disruptive innovation. Both call for accountability and reform in scientific research.

8 posted on 02/27/2025 3:54:24 AM PST by RoosterRedux ("There's nothing so inert as a closed mind" )
[ Post Reply]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
General/Chat
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson