Posted on 12/26/2023 5:36:09 PM PST by nickcarraway
— Study finds medical Barbie dolls usually treat kids, don't come with PPE accessories
Barbie can be a doctor, but she rarely specializes or works with adults, and she almost never meets clinical safety standards for clothing or personal protective equipment (PPE), a quantitative study found.
Of 80 Barbie medical professional dolls, 53 (66%) worked with children as a pediatrician, pediatric dentist, or even a pediatric ophthalmologist, Katherine Klamer, of Indiana University in Indianapolis, reported in the BMJ's traditional Christmas editionopens in a new tab or window.
Even then, Barbie fell somewhat short: Mattel has a doll named Ellaopens in a new tab or window, who is a cancer survivor, but there is no pediatric oncologist Barbie. "Ella ... has to go to the doctor. So why can't Dr. Barbie do anything to help her?" Klamer told MedPage Today.
While Mattel has been more inclusive with dolls with disabilitiesopens in a new tab or window -- such as Becky, who uses a wheelchair -- none of the medical-career Barbies were shown with a disability, Klamer emphasized.
Only three medical professional Barbies -- including a Civil War-era nurse -- were depicted as working with adult patients. "Besides that, all the other medical professional Barbie dolls were either depicted working with children (for example, if a child doll was included with Barbie) or were not depicted working with anyone," Klamer said.
Among 12 scientist Barbie dolls, none met PPE requirements related to hair and clothing, she reported in the BMJopens in a new tab or window, noting that most Barbie doctors had their legs exposed, wore heels, and had loose hair, all of which pose a workplace hazard, and undoubtedly, a degree of discomfort.
Though almost all had stethoscopes, almost none wore masks. Barbie lab scientists barely wore wrist-length lab coats or slip-resistant shoes, and none had gloves. Many also sported loose hair and jewelry. Comparator female doctors and nurse dolls from Legoopens in a new tab or window, Playmobil, and Beverly Hills Doll Collection were "much more clinically accurate," Klamer wrote.
She wrote that "[a] large focus by children's toy companies on treating children is understandable. Few children long to become geriatricians. Yet, Mattel has marketed Barbie as a trailblazer for decades."
Klamer added that if "Barbie wishes to be an accurate mirror for young girls to reflect their medical and scientific career aspirations on, then she needs to practice many kinds of medicine and science and meet standard hospital and laboratory safety requirements."
With women underrepresented in surgical specialtiesopens in a new tab or window and a number of unseen forcesopens in a new tab or window further discouraging them, maybe "a childhood of playing with neurosurgeon Barbie or trauma surgeon Barbie could inoculate girls against sexist career assumptions and advice," pointed out Sareh Parangi, MD, of Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston, and co-authors.
"Instead, the current cadre of generalist Barbies that treat primarily children simply reinforces outdated concepts of gendered medical specialties," they wrote in an accompanying editorialopens in a new tab or window.
Klamer conducted a Google search for a "visual observation and analysis of Barbie brand and comparison dolls," with data collected and analyzed from July to November 2023, which included the time period that the blockbuster "Barbie" movie hit $1 billion at the global box officeopens in a new tab or window. Klamer noted that dolls were ineligible for the study if they were modeled on a real person, like Florence Nightingale, or if they depicted a science job that didn't involve humans (marine biologist, paleontologist).
Dolls, doll clothing and accessories, and any related packaging were used to determine the doll's career; whether clothing and accessories met clinical and laboratory safety standards; and what patients the dolls were designed to work with. A comparator group of 65 non-Barbie medical professional and laboratory scientist dolls and doll-like toys also was analyzed.
Of 92 Barbie brand dolls, including Ken, 93% were female. Compared with 59% of the non-Barbie group, 26% of the comparator group were depicted as white, though over a quarter were non-human ("Dr. Paddington Bearopens in a new tab or window").
Study limitations included the potential for having missed some medical professional and laboratory scientist dolls, and the heterogeneity of the comparison doll group, which had to be expanded beyond 11-inch fashion dolls to get a similar participant sample size. Exact comparisons could not be made between groups, Klamer said.
This is not the first time Mattel has faced criticism for its use of Barbie in healthcare: A 2023 news analysisopens in a new tab or window in the BMJ took the company to task for its "Barbie School of Friendship" program in which Barbie and Ken dolls were given to British schoolchildren for free as teaching tools on empathy. Mental health professionals told the BMJ that the program seemed "exploitative" and amounted to "stealth marketing."
Sophie Putka is an enterprise and investigative writer for MedPage Today. Her work has appeared in the Wall Street Journal, Discover, Business Insider, Inverse, Cannabis Wire, and more. She joined MedPage Today in August of 2021. Follow
I hope the “journalist” who wrote that looked at her assignment editor and said “You’re kidding right?”
This is a joke.
Right?
Does GI Joe use fake ammo?
Has Paw Patrol falled behind on their rabies and distemper shots?
I wonder if the journalist wanted this assignment after spending years (and money) in journalism school. When will Barbie be a NASCAR driver?
And why do children’s dolls have to meet such “standards”?
Because they will otherwise grow up to question or flout them?
Because little girls might be misled into thinking they do or do not want to choose a career based on the dress code for it?
Obviously the huge majority of Barbies will be females, it’s a females’ toy. Everyone (little girls included) generally prefers playing with toys they can relate to.
And that explains the pediatrician size too: kids want to play with toys that have kids, they can see that as themselves and their friends/siblings much better then trying to relate to Grampa getting an EEK.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.