Posted on 05/02/2021 5:30:23 AM PDT by MtnClimber
Maybe you didn’t believe me earlier this month when I issued a warning that the U.S. was “getting ready to go full Venezuela” on economic policy. After Biden’s speech a couple of nights ago, are you starting to get the picture?
All constraints are now lifted. All limits no longer apply. The federal government is now fully unleashed to solve all human problems and bring about perfect fairness and equity in human affairs. And to do so immediately if not sooner. All through the magic of a few trillion additional dollars (per year!) of federal spending. And while we’re at it, we’ll also solve the “climate emergency.” That will cost just another few incremental annual trillion. In the context of our new superpowers, that’s a rounding error.
The flood of proposed new programs and spending is so enormous as to make critiques of any individual items completely pointless. Is there a single one of these proposals that makes sense, or that actually might enhance the well-being of the American people? If so it’s such a small portion as to be insignificant.
Instead, I’ll address what I consider to be the elephant in the room, the obvious thing that somehow never gets mentioned. That is, why haven’t the vast numbers of already-existing federal social service programs and spending already succeeded in solving the problems they were created and funded to solve?
At the end of this post I have included a list of some 83 categories of federal “need based” spending programs. The list comes from a 2018 report by John Early written for the Cato Institute, but he took it from a document put together by the Congressional Research Service in 2013. In other words, I’m sure that there are plenty more of these things since this list was compiled. Note also that this is far, far, far from a complete list of federal income and in-kind distribution and benefit programs, since it specifically only includes those that are “need based.” Thus the list doesn’t even include the single largest federal income distribution program of all, which is Social Security. Aficionados of this subject will also recognize that large numbers of food and nutrition programs and job training programs are also missing, undoubtedly because they are not “need based.” (In this post back in 2014 I found a study that identified some 47 federal job training programs alone.).
Note that the Early list is broken down into two categories, those programs that figure “at least partially in CBO estimates" and those that are “not in CBO estimates.” The “estimates” referred to are estimates of income. The list of what CBO includes in “income” for its purposes differs from what is included by Census. The Census numbers, rather than those of CBO, are the source of things like our statistics on “poverty” and “income inequality.” Unlike CBO, Census does not include 5 of those first 7 categories in “income” in its measures. The excluded 5 are the EITC, SNAP, Medicaid, CHIP and the School Breakfast Program. If you wonder how the spending of a trillion dollars plus per year never seems to improve poverty or income inequality, this is how. The spending is simply excluded when the things we are trying to improve are measured.
But anyway, now that we’re in the Biden era, we’re not so much concerned any more with little problems like poverty. Now that all limits are removed, we can pass out money to everybody indiscriminately (child tax credits for all!), or to people predominantly in the upper half of the income distribution (free college!) or even the upper ten percent (electric car charging stations!).
Our metrics for measuring the effects of all this spending are wholly inadequate to the task. As readers here know, government spending is immediately counted into income and GDP figures, with the destructive effects only showing up later, sometimes many years later. How much of the current surge in reported economic activity is the consequence of the illusionary inclusion of the blowout spending as supposedly representing economic growth? It’s impossible to tell. Never forget that in Venezuela they were using similar measuring conventions to declare an “economic miracle” many years after the economic catastrophe had become clear to everyone on the ground.
Roger Kimball calls the Biden program “MAPA” — Make America Poor Again. I couldn’t say it better,.
Here is Early’s list of federal “need based” programs:
At least partially in CBO estimates:
1. Supplemental Security Income
2. Earned Income Tax Credit (refundable component)
3. SNAP (food stamps)
4. Medicaid
5. CHIP
6. Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) cash aid
7. School Breakfast Program (free/reduced price components)
Not in CBO estimates:
8. Public Housing
9. Section 8 Housing Choice Vouchers
10. Low-Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP)
11. Family Planning
12. Consolidated Health Centers
13. Transitional Cash and Medical Services for Refugees
14. Voluntary Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit—Low-Income Subsidy 15. Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program
16. Breast/Cervical Cancer Early Detection
17. Maternal and Child Health Block Grant
18. Indian Health Service
19. Additional Child Tax Credit
20. National School Lunch Program (free/reduced price components)
21. Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC)
22. Child and Adult Care Food Program (lower-income components)
23. Summer Food Service Program
24. Commodity Supplemental
25. Food Program Nutrition Assistance for Puerto Rico
26. The Emergency Food Assistance Program (TEFAP)
27. Nutrition Program for the Elderly
28. Indian Education
29. Adult Basic Education Grants to States
30. Federal Supplemental Educational Opportunity Grant
31. Education for the Disadvantaged—Grants to Local Educational Agencies (Title I-A)
32. Title I Migrant Education Program
33. Higher Education—Institutional Aid and Developing Institutions
34. Federal Work-Study
35. Federal TRIO Programs
36. Federal Pell Grants
37. Education for Homeless Children and Youth
38. 21st Century Community Learning Centers
39. Gaining Early Awareness and Readiness for Undergraduate Programs (GEAR-UP)
40. Reading First and Early Reading First
41. Rural Education Achievement Program
42. Mathematics and Science Partnerships
43. Improving Teacher Quality State Grants
44. Academic Competitiveness and Smart Grant Program
45. Single-Family Rural Housing Loans
46. Rural Rental Assistance Program
47. Water and Waste Disposal for Rural Communities
48. Public Works and Economic Development
49. Supportive Housing for the Elderly
50. Supportive Housing for Persons with Disabilities
51. Section 8 Project-Based Rental Assistance
52. Community Development Block Grants
53. Homeless Assistance Grants
54. Home Investment Partnerships Program (HOME)
55. Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS (HOPWA)
56. Indian Housing Block Grants
57. Neighborhood Stabilization Program
58. Grants to States for Low-Income Housing in Lieu of Low-Income Housing Credit Allocations
59. Tax Credit Assistance Program
60. Indian Human Services
61. Older Americans Act Grants for Supportive Services and Senior Centers
62. Older Americans Act Family Caregiver Program
63. TANF social services
64. Child Support Enforcement
65. Community Services Block Grant
66. Child Care and Development Fund
67. Head Start HHS
68. Developmental Disabilities Support and Advocacy Grants
69. Foster Care
70. Adoption Assistance
71. Social Services Block Grant
72. Chafee Foster Care Independence Program
73. Emergency Food and Shelter Program
74. Legal Services Corporation
75. Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) (employment and training component)
76. Community Service Employment for Older Americans
77. Workforce Investment Act (WIA) Adult Activities
78. Workforce Investment Act (WIA) Youth Activities
79. Social Services and Targeted Assistance for Refugees
80. Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) employment and training
81. Foster Grandparents
82. Job Corps
83. Weatherization Assistance Program
We are being dehumanized and set up for liquidation by the state.
************
After all attempts at reeducation have failed.
The message of this new regime:
Big Brother Biden and Little Sister Harris have your best interests at heart. That pesky little thing called the Constitution needs some updating. You’d do well to get with the program, or else!
Dont be so unreasonable.....there’s Biden (cough) reasoning behind all that.
What are you against the endless Biden Crime family becoming multi billionaires on insider deals.....
besides getting guaranteed govt pensions and six-figure no-show govt jobs?
Joe Stolen is not the instigator on any of these policies, they have been written up in some series of think tanks over a period of years, only waiting for the first opportunity to assert them boldly and quickly.
*************
Good post.
Bold and quick are a dangerous combo. Even with the most able people at the helm its a huge challenge. It generally ends in spectacular failure. Several books have been written on the topic of how complex system can quickly plunge into enormous and costly disasters. We’re on that path right now.
....”or else”.......
Better be on that midnight train to reeducation camp....if you know what’s good for you.
Vote out every RINO who must face a primary in 2022 and replace them with conservative patriots at every level
************
The party works hard at backfilling their losses. They seem to have a conveyor belt with an endless supply of RINOs. We also have the bigger problem of stealth RINOs (i.e., those that talk a good game but can easily be persuaded to tow the party line).
Trying to “turn” the GOP is an enormous challenge. Its a big, well funded machine with a long history of successfully deceiving its base. Just saying.
Biden’s Admin is not as smart as a Wrecking-Ball
Damn right he’s a puppet. That’s why I always refer to him as pResident Xiden. Have since the fraudulently elected dimwitted empty vessel was installed by China.
Each taxpayer’s share of the exploding national debt is $225,000. It’s obviously beyond the real of possibility for taxpayers to pay that amount. Yet here we are.
We elect people who refuse to acknowledge economic reality. They will keep spending us into oblivion until something breaks and impoverishes us all. But what do the elites care? They will ride out any crisis in comfort and security.
It seems as if most Republican officials don’t even KNOW what the right thing to do is, let alone have the courage to stand up for it.
**************
Oh, they know all right. Their constituents tell them all the time but they just ignore it. They don’t care what Joe the Plumber thinks. They only care what Plumbing Supplies, Inc. thinks and how much they can contribute to the reelection coffers. Its all about one thing: MONEY.
Trump MAGA - Make America Great Again
Xiden MAGA - Make America Grovel Again
Show the list federal “needs based” programs to a Welfare Stater Leftist, and they look past it, to the trillions to be spent on Federal National Income programs, illegal alien resettlement systems, etc. This will never end, until it does. When it does, it will be because the entire economy has become what is now ruling us all, a basket case. This is more than wrong, it is disastrous... so, we kick the can down the road.
In an earlier time, I would request of the author listing of expenditures, if they can even be honestly determined, or all these “needs based” programs, but veracity and truth in government is long a thing of the past.
So that list is the “mutual fund” we all “invest” in every April 15th...at gun point. Where are the dividends from our “investment”?
And all passed because of 24-7-365 covid fear porn. “We have to do something NOW. It’s a public health emergency.”
Look how many people so willingly gave up their God given freedoms at the command of a government bureaucrat.
I am in my seventies and going through all 83 federal assistance programs am glad to see I have never used even one of them.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.