Posted on 02/20/2019 12:12:51 PM PST by EdnaMode
The Trump administration is set to launch a global campaign to decriminalize homosexuality in dozens of nations where anti-gay laws are still on the books, NBC News reported Monday. While on its surface, the move looks like an atypically benevolent decision by the Trump administration, the details of the campaign belie a different story. Rather than actually being about helping queer people around the world, the campaign looks more like another instance of the right using queer people as a pawn to amass power and enact its own agenda.
It almost goes without saying but the Trump administration does not have a great human rights record at home when it comes to LGBTQ+ issues. Advocacy group GLAAD has kept a record of the many times the administration has harmed LGBTQ+ people, from its transgender military ban to the reversal of plans to include LGBTQ people on the 2020 US census. And prior to his ill-conceived plan to address the HIV/AIDS epidemic, Trump’s administration had an abysmal record on addressing the virus.
The most telling detail of NBC News’ report is that his plan centers homophobic violence in Iran, who NBC News calls the administration’s “top geopolitical foe.” The plan has reportedly been spearheaded by the U.S. ambassador to Germany, Richard Grenell, who is also the administration’s top-ranked gay official, in response to news that a young gay man was hanged in Iran recently. Grenell has had his eyes on Iran for some time and just a week ago, he was trying to get several European nations to pass sanctions on Iran, unrelated to the country’s stance on homosexuality, to no avail.
Homosexuality has been illegal in Iran since the theocratic 1979 Islamic Revolution. By at least one Guardian account, since the exit of president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad in 2013, enforcement of anti-gay laws has softened somewhat. Homosexuality, according to the writer, is an “open secret” and most queer people fear homophobic reaction from fellow citizens more than the authorities.
Grennell’s sudden interest in Iran’s anti-gay laws is strikingly similar to Trump’s rhetoric after the 2016 Pulse massacre in Orlando, Florida. After the deadly shooting, Trump used the 49 deaths as a way to galvanize support for an anti-Muslim agenda rather than find a way to support LGBTQ+ people. In pushing for immigration restrictions and a Muslim ban, Trump argued, he was the true pro-LGBTQ+ candidate. Rather than honor those who died, Trump used the tragedy as a way to stoke fear among the American people, and Grennell is taking similar actions with Iran — trying to reach an economic goal by painting the administration’s opponent as anti-gay.
“We know Trump is very focused on Iran and is looking for ways to demonize it in the public opinion and this is one area where you know the US and European countries see eye to eye on Iran,” Josh Lederman, who reported the original NBC News story, told Out in a phone interview. “So it makes for them to focus strategically on that rather than sanctions, where there’s been a big gulf between the U.S. and its allies.”
The truth is, this is part of an old colonialist handbook. In her essay, “Can the Subaltern Speak?” postcolonial theorist Gayatri Spivak coined the term “White men saving brown women from brown men” to describe the racist, paternalistic process by which colonizing powers would decry the way men in power treated oppressed groups, like women, to justify attacking them. Spivak was referencing the British colonial agenda in India. But Grennell’s attack might be a case of white men trying to save brown gay men from brown straight men, to the same end.
There are several signs that this decision is denoted in a colonial sense of paternalism rather than any true altruism. According to the report, the decriminalization campaign is set to begin in Berlin where LGBTQ+ activists from across Europe will meet to hatch a plan that is “mostly concentrated in the Middle East, Africa, and the Caribbean.”
That sentence alone should set off several alarm bells. First of all, the Middle East, Africa, and the Caribbean are huge geopolitical entities. Attitudes toward gay people differ greatly among countries and regions within those entities and attempting to gather a room of European activists on how to deal with queer issues in those regions is the definition of paternalism.
According to Lederman, the names of the activists attending the dinner, scheduled for Tuesday night in Berlin, are not yet known, but they hail from a dozen European countries, including countries from Eastern and Central Europe, where legal protections for LGBTQ+ people are weaker than in Western Europe. The names of the activists are being concealed as some are not ready to be identified publicly.
Lederman says that the sentiment on the ground is that the initiative is “very much a work in progress” and that they made the announcement while “there’s still a lot of strategy being worked out.” However, Lederman did confirm that as of right now, activists from countries in the regions being discussed — from Africa, the Middle East, and the Caribbean — are not currently being brought to the discussion table.
“They’re not sure what it’s going to look like as it gets fleshed out,” and while he says they could possibly invite people from affected regions “at a future date,” he says right now they’re still working out details.
Lederman plans to sit down with Grennell as well as several activists who attended the dinner meeting in Berlin for an interview that will air on MSNBC at a later date.
Though plans may or may not exist to invite local LGBTQ+ advocacy groups to the table, that they are not there at the plan’s inception is dangerous. Inviting European activists to solve problems in the Middle East, African or the Caribbean — which, once again, are not monolithic in the slightest — is a toothless effort, more PR than progressive.
Anybody read the comments? If you can put up with typical gay male potty mouth, it’s worth reading. The author is not feeling the love.
Obama forced countries....with the purse...
There was never going to be such a box...
In case you were wonder if sodomy is still a mental disorder.,this headline is exhibit #56,194.
Psst. someone remind Out Magazine that the Clinton Foundation took millions from countries that kill gays and lesbians for sport.
As opposed to what queers, blacks, and Democrats do, right?
“There was never going to be such a box...”
Looks like there was, asking about same-sex vs opposite-sex partners, at least according to NPR.
https://www.npr.org/2018/03/30/598192154/2020-census-will-ask-about-same-sex-relationships
These people are psychotic...........................
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
These people want the money for their social justice causes”. If there is no more “cause”, then no need for the money. Their wells dry up..
So queers are a race now?
Not sarcasm, just wishful thinking...anything to reduce California’s electoral votes.
Apparently.
There was an early draft and all sex questions were withdrawn...i.e., they were no where included in the proposal. Just someone idiot with “I got an idea!”
I’m not asking about Obama, I didn’t vote for him. I’m asking about this new Trump administrationnpolicy. Does it target countries if they don’t recognize homosexual marriage? I’m not accusing, I’m asking. I want to know
"It's racist for white people to tell brown people not to murder gays."
This is peak TDS.
Trump’s plan to end the practice of throwing gays off tall buildings met with harsh criticism today...
Trump’s plan to cure racism is homophobic...
Some people are never happy no matter what you do.
another instance of the left using queer people as a pawn to amass power and enact its own agenda.
There, fixed it for them.
War is peace
Freedom is slavery
Proves that the LGBTXYZ movement is about socialism and political control and not sexual freedom
I say include them. Then when we find out how tiny the overall number of them there are we can proceed with ignoring the Gaystapo (that are a smaller fraction of the run-of-the-mill gay folks who bother no one) like every other loud, obnoxious sub-group of "agendized humans". d;^)
I waded into the sewer that is Out. Even the commenters there are bashing this idiotic article.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.