Posted on 03/21/2007 11:08:14 AM PDT by EveningStar
"South Park" fans take for granted that the show consistently shocks and amuses in an environment flooded with distractions and imitators.
Watching the Comedy Central series' Emmy-winning ninth season reinforces why. Creators and former CU-Boulder film students Trey Parker and Matt Stone position their pop culture texts violently against the grain, smartly engaging their characters in taboo topics of race, gender and sexuality.
The duo's biggest asset? Their writing encompasses more more than shock value or self-amusement. Yes, potty humor and cheap shots fly left and right, attacking soft-skulled liberals and myopic conservatives alike. But the boys always make an intelligent comment in the end - however brutal the path...
(Excerpt) Read more at denverpost.com ...
A great adventure is waiting for you ahead
Hurry onward SittinYonder, or you will soon be dead
...
The road ahead is filled with danger and fright
But push onwards SittinYonder with all of your might
Your problem is that you criticize the show, without recognizing that amongst the juvenile humor and potty language, which truly is irrelevant to an inciteful critique of the show, they have a very incisive, sarcastic humor that takes real intelligence to recognize.
Maybe that's your problem? You can't recognize the humor and therefore fixate on the irrelevant?
Gary's speech at the end of "Team America" summed up Foreign Relations better than any policy wonk ever could.
If you were to say that South Park is just too vulgar and no amount of good political satire makes up for that, I might disagree with you, but you would still have my respect. (Michelle Malkin has taken such a position.)
But to say it is "juvenile at best" implies that it is nothing BUT potty humor. This indicates that you don't know what you are talking about, and thus deserving of indignant bile.
Actually, I loved the "nagger" show. I thought the "praying the gay out" was lame and pretty obvious except for the picture of Cartman sub plot. Just MHO.
;)
"The road ahead is filled with danger and fright"
And listen to the Sparrow King.....
Last week's epi pushed the line. But that was fourth graders "experimenting" with gayness, and not a representation of a schizophrenic 7th century murdering pedophile, so it was "ok" with the powers that be of the Comedy Channel.
I wonder if the CC execs got to vote at Sundance for the Dakota Fanning rape scene?
Well, the tiebreaker will be tonite! Headlice? Could be one of the grosser ones.
Exactly right... Shut up SittinYonder, you are out of your element ;~)
The fart jokes are not the issue here. :~D
At least it's head lice and not crabs.
Now that would be a gross epi.
I heard a science show last week about crabs coming originally from gorillas, and the evolutionary biologist used a term like "unseemly acts" as a slight possibility of how the parasite jumped species.
"unseemly acts"
My sociology professor in college had a similar theory about the origins of bigfoot :~)
But, sort of getting back to the "other way":
"How did you get crabs from a contemporary gorilla to compare DNA?"Head lice branched off from chimps, btw, as "man" lost body hair."We had to go to people that worked with [protected] gorillas and asked them. They were on very good terms with some gorillas."
"I guess they'd have to be."
"Yes they were."
Actually, your criticism hasn't been so much about South Park, but of the fans themselves, not quite getting into personal attacks, but coming close. You don't "get it." They do. Get over it. If you don't like South Park, then don't watch it. Which it appears that you don't. But that still doesn't keep you from commenting on it, or the people who do "get it." You seem to be looking for something to get your panties in a wad over. Sounds to me like you've just got too much time on your hands.
For instance, if I were to say that South Park is juvenile at best and full of fart jokes, all sorts of indignant bile would be flung my way.
Of course it's juvenile. That's simply one of the best things about it. Because they'll often approach serious issues in such a juvenile way. Sometimes "grownups" don't see how stupid their actions and policies are. This juxtaposition is one of the things that those who "get it" like the most.
The funny thing is that with the exception of the "fart jokes" and "potty humor" comments, your criticisms are about what's normally heard about the "3 Stooges" comedies. Again, some people get it, others don't.
Mark
Or a cheap shot, like last night... I kept waiting to see if AlGore or ManBearPig was going to show up.
Mark
Oh sure, bring up Harlan Ellison!
Mark
So, come on... Fess up. Which one are you, Matt or Trey? You guys were great in Orgasmo! I really hope that there will be a sequel! And Baseketball?!??! A cinematic masterpiece! I loved the scene on "Free Range Chicken Night" at the ball park, when they were "collecting" the chickens! And I swear I couldn't breath from laughing so hard the first time I saw the hospital scene!
Mark
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.