Langa Letter: XP's No-Reformat, Nondestructive Total-Rebuild Option

TechWeb ^ | June 19, 2006 | Fred Langa

[Eagle9]

It's one of those software design decisions that makes you scratch your head and wonder, "What were they thinking?"

The "it" in this case is XP's most powerful rebuild/repair option, and yet Microsoft chose to hide it behind seeming dead ends, red herrings, and a recycled interface that makes it hard to find and (at first) somewhat confusing to use.

But it's worth exploring because this option lets you completely and nondestructively rebuild, repair, or refresh an existing XP installation while leaving already-installed software alone (no reinstallation needed!). It also leaves user accounts, names, and passwords untouched and takes only a fraction of the time a full, from-scratch reinstall does. And unlike a traditional full reinstall, this option doesn't leave you with two copies of XP on your hard drive. Instead, you end up with just the original installation, but repaired, refreshed, and ready to go.

We've saved this technique for last in our discussion of the various XP repair/rebuild options because the fixes we've previously discussed are like first aid--the things you try first. For instance, see this discussion on removing limitations on XP's Recovery Console, turning it into a more complete repair tool; or this discussion on the Recovery Console's little-known "Rebuild" command that can cure many boot-related problems. (There's also lots more on the Recovery Console here.

But when the Recovery Console techniques don't work, and you're facing the prospects of a total reformat/reinstall, stop! Try the no-reformat reinstall technique we're about to illustrate, and you just may get your XP setup running again in a fraction of the time and with a fraction of the hassle of a grand mal wipe-and-restore.

The First Fork In The Road
The no-reformat reinstall operation starts with a normal boot from an XP setup CD. Ideally, to save time, use a setup CD that's been "slipstreamed" to include the SP1 and SP2 patches and upgrades. (Need info on slipstreaming? See "How To Save An Hour (Or More) On XP Installs" and also this third-party site.

Start your PC with the setup CD in a drive, and hit a key when you see the following screen:

Screen One Boot from your XP setup CD to gain access to the no-reformat reinstall option. (click image for larger view)

If instead of booting to the CD your PC boots from the hard drive, you may need to modify your PC's "boot order." It's easy and only takes a minute to make the change so that the PC will check for a bootable CD before trying to boot from the hard drive. See this for more information.

Once your PC starts to boot from the CD, you'll see something like what's shown in Screen 2:

Screen Two Let the CD boot proceed normally and automatically through "Setup is inspecting your computer's hardware..." to the "Windows Setup" screen. (click image for larger view)

After a minute or two, you'll see the "Windows Setup/Setup is starting Windows" screen, shown in Screen Three. Don't be alarmed: It's still just the setup process running, and nothing's been changed on your PC yet.

(click image for larger view)

Screen Three The "Starting Windows" screen is a bit of an overstatement; it's just the setup process getting going. Windows, as we normally think of it, isn't running yet, and no changes have been made to your PC.

Soon after Screen Three, you'll be presented with the normal "Welcome to Setup" screen, as shown in Screen Four.

Screen Four The "Welcome to Setup" screen is poorly worded; the "Repair" option we want isn't the one explicitly offered here. In fact, the repair option we want isn't shown at all. See the text for full detail.

(click image for larger view)

The poorly worded options in Screen Four lead many users astray. The only mention of "Repair" here is "...repair a Windows XP installation using Recovery Console..." but that's not the no-reformat repair/reinstall we're seeking. (The Recovery Console Repair option is useful in its own right for fixing relatively minor problems with the operating system, and we fully explore it in the links listed above.)

The repair option we do want--a nondestructive, no-reformat reinstall--is actually hidden beneath the Setup option, "To set up Windows XP now, press ENTER."

So hit Enter, just as if you were setting up Windows afresh and from scratch.

The next screen, about licensing, gives no reassurances that you're on the right path for a nondestructive repair/reinstall--in fact, it's the same screen you see when you're setting XP up on a virgin hard drive. But this is only the first of many screens that the Repair option will borrow from a full-blown setup. Press F8 to accept the licensing terms and to go on.

(click image for larger view)

Screen Five The licensing screen gives no indication that this is a Repair and not a brand-new, from-scratch installation. But don't be alarmed. You're on the right track.

Next, the XP setup process will show another screen that you may recall from your initial setup of XP. It searches for "a previous version of Microsoft Windows." In our case, we're not replacing a previous version of Windows, but rather repairing the very same version that's on the setup CD--but that's OK; it's just another poorly worded screen.

Screen Six Our intent is to repair the same version of Windows as is on the setup CD, but another poorly worded screen makes it seem like you're upgrading a previous version of Windows or installing one anew. But don't let the bad wording alarm you; we're still on track for a nondestructive reinstall.

(click image for larger view)

Screen Seven finally shows verbiage that's not recycled from the generic XP setup, but is specific to our Repair task. Setup should find your damaged copy of XP and present it for repair, as shown:

(click image for larger view)

Screen Seven At long last, Setup begins to refer to a Repair option. Here, Setup should have found your damaged XP setup, which you can select and then press R to start the nondestructive repair.

If your damaged copy of XP isn't highlighted in the list box, highlight it now. When it's selected, press R to start the repair process.

The Repair process then selectively deletes system files in the \Windows folder and subfolders and copies undamaged replacement files from the setup CD to their proper locations.

Screen Eight The Repair operation replaces all potentially damaged system files with fresh copies from the CD. (click image for larger view)

The Repair process then works on the current setup's Registry, leaving much of it intact and rebuilding the rest.

(click image for larger view)

Screen Nine There's no fanfare, but this is one of the nicer parts of the Repair process: Setup retains what it can in the current Registry so that already-installed hardware and software will remain installed.

The system then needs to reboot and will do so automatically. If your setup CD is still in the drive, remove it so that the system won't try to boot from it.

Screen Ten With the system files freshly copied and the Registry ready for rebuilding, the system needs to reboot. Remove the CD from the drive so that the PC will boot to the hard drive instead of to the CD. (click image for larger view)

The first Repair reboot will take longer than normal. Don't be alarmed. Also, don't be alarmed when Setup resumes. Once again, it will appear that you're performing a full, from-scratch setup; there's nothing on-screen to indicate that you're repairing an existing version of XP. But although the setup screens are the same as what you'd see in a full install, it's still a repair process, as will become clearer in a moment.

The first two of the Repair setup screens ask for your language preferences and product key. Enter these normally.

	Screen Eleven (click image for larger view)			Screen Twelve (click image for larger view)
	When Setup resumes, it will appear that you're performing a full, from-scratch setup. But don't worry--you're still indeed repairing your existing version of XP.

Many of the next few Repair screens will also be familiar. The "installing devices" screen, for example, is identical to the one you normally see during a full, from-scratch setup. But Repair is actually retaining much of the current setup's configuration and so will move through these steps faster than in a full setup.

(click image for larger view)

Screen Thirteen The Repair version of the setup process skips or shortens many steps because it already has the information it needs from the existing setup. For example, Repair's "installing devices" and the network setup steps are both much faster and require less user input than a new setup does.

The setup screens don't reflect the fact that a Repair proceeds much faster than a normal, full setup. In fact, the time estimates in the setup progress bar will be way off. You'll be done in far less time than the progress bar predicts.

Screen Fourteen Just as with "installing devices," the network setup proceeds rapidly because Setup can reuse many of the configuration details from the current installation. In fact, a Repair setup takes far less time than the installation progress bar indicates.

(click image for larger view)

When this portion of the Repair is done, you'll see a "completing installation" screen:

Screen Fifteen The "completing installation" screen means most of the heavy lifting is done, and you're just minutes away from finishing the repair operation. (click image for larger view)

Setup then reboots your PC again, and this reboot will also take longer than usual. This is normal.

Screen Sixteen With the bulk of the repair work done, your PC needs to reboot once more and will do so automatically. The reboot will take a bit longer than a standard boot, but this is normal. (click image for larger view)

After the reboot, you'll be brought to an abbreviated version of the "Welcome To Windows" setup pages.

Screen Seventeen The Repair process ends with still more screens borrowed from the full setup. (click image for larger view)

You'll be asked if you want to register and--depending on how badly hosed the previous installation was--you may or may not be asked to reactivate the copy of Windows. Next, the setup software handles the final networking details and then offers a "thank you" screen.

Screen Eighteen The final steps in the Repair process pass very quickly, and you'll soon reach the last screen in the Repair operation, a "thank you." (click image for larger view)

In most cases, the system will now reboot for a final time. The Repair is done. It's a normal boot, bringing you to the normal choices for login.

Screen Nineteen With a final, fully normal reboot, you're done. Your copy of XP should be as good as new, but with all your previously installed hardware, software, and user configuration data undamaged! (click image for larger view)

If all has gone as planned, you'll find all the user accounts and passwords intact, all the hardware devices set up as before, and all the previously installed software still installed and configured. In fact, if all has gone as planned, the only significant change will be that whatever problem your copy of XP was previously experiencing will now be gone!

You now have a range of repair tools at your disposal, ranging from simple on-the-fly fixes such as Registry cleaning and safe Mode fixes to Recovery Console fixes (see links in the beginning of this article) and, now, a nondestructive, no-reformat repair/rebuild option.

With this information, you should almost never have to face a dreaded start-over-from-scratch reformat/reinstall of XP!

---

To discuss this column with other readers, please visit Fred Langa's forum.

To find out more about Fred Langa, please visit his page.

[Eagle9]

I haven't tried this 'no-reformat total-rebuild' method yet, but will when necessary.

[Peter W. Kessler]

That settles it.

I'm buying a Mac.

[Space Wrangler]

Bookmarking.

[M Kehoe]

A post that makes you go "hmmmmm." Good post.

5.56mm

[cardinal4]

Im bookmarking this thread, too..

[Echo Talon]

OMG.. a whole article for this? how dumb, i have know this forever.

[chaosagent]

Bookmarked

[martin_fierro]

I hope to have one (or both!) of my old Win 98 boxes running at least a dual-boot with Knoppix Linux here in the next few weeks.

Ideally, I'll have learned enough about Linux to make them exclusively Linux boxes.

[KellyAdmirer]

If all has gone as planned

I've been through this more times than I can remember, and all I can say is: don't bet on it.

[Publius6961]

BUMP!

[Khurkris]

exactly 30 days too late for me. I had a major crash - my only one in 9 years - and lost all of my files. I still have clients chewing my ass about it.


Oh well...will copy and save. Thanks.

[HAL9000]

That settles it. I'm buying a Mac.

If you ever need any technical assistance, we have some good Mac experts on the forum. I hope it will be an enjoyable first-class solution for you.

[ThePythonicCow]

Thanks - valuable post.

[HAL9000]

This is much easier that the Windows reinstallation technique described above -

Apple.com - How to move your stuff from your PC to your new Mac

[phoenix0468]

Nice post Eagle9 but some further information is necessary. And I have a couple of questions to address this information. First, how are the myriad of updates affected? I.E. will the user have to go to Microsofts update site and reupdate the newly repaired installation? Also, is this method truly proven to solve all problems? Some viruses can infect the boot sector of a Hard Drive or even the BIOS, which in this case you would still have problems.

With Windows there are really only two ways to truly clean your system. Wipe and resinstall or switch to an alternate OS such as Mac or Linux. I would suggest some try the later solution.

[garyhope]

Wow, thanks for a good post and info.

[listenhillary]

Useful information ping

[Quix]

Thanks.

Looks quite useful.

[rockrr]

I have tried it.

Unfortunately it depends on the integrity of the registry (although it doesn't explicitly say so). I've found that it fails about 80% of the time.

It also doesn't do anything about the virus that hosed the system in the first place - that still has to be hunted down and killed.

I use the bootable Bart PE CD to boot the PC outside of Windows so that I can kill suspect files without them able to re-spawn.

Good luck!

[Eagle9]

First, how are the myriad of updates affected? I.E. will the user have to go to Microsofts update site and reupdate the newly repaired installation?

I'm no expert when it comes to computer software. I think that if you had a slipstreamed WinXP installation disc, you would still need all of the other Windows updates from MS.

Also, is this method truly proven to solve all problems? Some viruses can infect the boot sector of a Hard Drive or even the BIOS, which in this case you would still have problems.

No, it won't solve all problems. Yes, you are correct about viruses, and I think you could include rootkits and some of the other malware.