Posted on 01/12/2006 8:59:10 AM PST by Dane
Student escapes prosecution over 'gay horse' remarks 12/01/2006 - 15:09:47
An final-year Oxford University student from Belfast who called a mounted policeman’s horse gay will not be prosecuted, it was announced today.
Police stood by their decision to take Sam Brown (aged 21) to court for making “homophobic comments” after the Crown Prosecution Service today dropped the case.
Mr Brown approached the officer during a night out with friends in Oxford after his final exams, and said: “Excuse me, do you realise your horse is gay?”
Moments later, two Thames Valley Police squad cars appeared in the High Street and Mr Brown was arrested under section five of the Public Order Act for making homophobic remarks.
His remarks were deemed likely to cause harassment, alarm or distress.
Mr Brown, an English Literature graduate, then at Oxford’s Balliol College, spent the night of May 30 last year in the cells.
He refused to pay an £80 (€117.10) fine, so police took the case to court.
But at Oxford Magisrates’ Court today it emerged the Crown Prosecution Service had chosen to discontinue the case.
Prosecutor Cariad Eveson-Webb said: “The police issued a summons but the CPS have decided they do not wish to proceed.
“In their opinion there is not enough evidence to prove it [Mr Brown’s behaviour] was disorderly.”
Thames Valley Police today defended their decision to take the case to court.
A spokesman said: “We present the case to the CPS and the CPS make the decision to proceed or not.
“He made homophobic comments that were deemed offensive to people passing by.”
He denied the police were heavy-handed, and claimed that Mr Brown was drunk and that he had made repeated comments about the horse being gay, despite requests from the officers to desist.
Matthew Williams (aged 21), a friend of Mr Brown, witnessed events last May.
He said Mr Brown jokingly approached one of two mounted policemen saying: “Excuse me, do you realise your horse is gay?”
Mr Brown then repeated: “Your horse is gay,“ he said.
Mr Williams, a fellow Oxford English Literature graduate, said the officer called for back-up and two squad cars appeared. Mr Brown was then arrested and taken to the station.
“Sam’s comments were said in jest. It was very clear that they were not homophobic,” he added
He had to call for backup? I guess the horse wasn't the only one gay.
-Eric
Maybe he was saying that the horse looked happy.
I can't imagine visiting Europe in the forseeable future. I'd get thrown in jail within minutes.
Sensitive horses across the pond.
The British might just as well be auctioning off their personal freedoms on Ebay...at least they'd be making a little money on their trip towards totalitarianism.
I was wondering who had the Gay Police Horse Pinglist this week.
Freedom of speech.
Why does the scene from Animal House where Studemeyer's white horse is led into Dean Werner's office come to mind?
Maybe this student is hoping to help Political Correctness will explode
when taking to it's logical end.
"the officer called for back-up and two squad cars appeared"
Sounds like the Keystone Cops.
Hmmm... Does the horse speak English? In that case, I can understand his distress.
Alas! Poor Mr. Orwell died at a young age. He never got to see life imitating his art.........
That would make a great tagline.
I'm glad the CPS realised how stupid this was.
I'm also glad I live in a part of England so conservative there's a Bible shop in the centre of town.
Regards, Ivan
Why didn't they just charge him with drunk and disorderly?
Did anyone consider whether or not the horse WAS really gay? If the horse was, than what is the offense? Outing the Horse? And if the horse wasn't, does that make the officer and horse homophobic for being upset about being called gay?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.