Skip to comments.How the ctrl-Left drove me away from American liberalism
Posted on 02/08/2017 6:41:28 PM PST by Auntie Mame
A good friend of mine, who also happens to be an outstanding author, once quipped, If I am forced to choose a side, I choose the side which is not forcing me to choose sides.
Seldom have I ever encountered phrasing more apt. Because thats precisely how I feel. Ive been feeling that way, for years now. It was not a sudden thing. It was a gradual realization. The slow clarity of an underlying sentiment, incrementally surfacing.
To make the picture more specific, let me lay out some background details. This is a bit wordy, so bear with me:
When I first met my wife in 1992, we were both volunteering at community radio station KRCL-FM in Salt Lake City, Utah. Back then, KRCL was something of a tentpole organization for folk who styled themselves as counter-culture. It was staffed with an oddball assortment of old-school Hippies, new-school progressives, the occasional play-anarchist, plenty of environmentalists, a few gays and lesbians, a tiny handful of non-caucasians (my future wife among them) as well as one or two small-c conservatives and small-l libertarians who worked very hard to keep their political cards held close to their chests; at least around the other staff. George Carlin was arguably my favorite comedian. I was attending the University of Utah, having turned down an Army recruiter the year before.
In other words, I was the proverbial sapling, with his roots sunk into decidedly progressive soil.
By the end of 1996, my wife and I had moved to the Puget Sound in Washington State, we were again involved with a public radio station I was student program director of KSVR-FM from 1995 to 1998 and I had just voted in my second U.S. Presidential election, selecting Bill Clinton for a second term. I didnt think Bob Dole was a bad guy, but I tended to pick Democrats in most categories. Why not? Nothing in my life had convinced me that the Democrats werent my party. And I was surrounded by men and women who all felt the same way. New Dimensions was my favorite weekly talk program, and I was an avid Carl Sagan fan. Being in an interracial marriage practically made me a Democrat by default, though I did not ever sign up with the party, because I liked to be able to keep my options open and not feel like I owed my vote to anybody. I was (and remain) pro-choice, as well as pro-legalization (rec drugs) even though I am an LDS teetotaler of same.
For the year 2000 I voted Al Gore and was quite upset about Bush 43s win, as some of my friends from the old incarnation of the ESPN Utah Jazz message forum may recall.
All of which is to say, I may not have been a card-carrier, but I was as reliable a constituent as any Democratic Party planner could have hoped for a liberal by any reasonable definition of the period. Living in a liberal part of the country, too.
But . . . things had already begun to shift, even if I myself did not yet realize it.
Again, let me lay out some background details:
Id watched the unfolding of the Clinton-Lewinsky scandal, and could not understand why so many determined liberals and especially feminists, were so willing to give Bill Clinton a pass. Yeah, sure, I voted for the guy too, but voting for a guy and lending him blind license to ill, are not the same thing. I was pretty sure (then, as well as now) if Bob Dole had been in Clintons place, everyone defending Clinton, would have crucified Dole. Bill Clinton (and his ardent defenders) let me down as a result.
Likewise, Id had a front-row seat for the WTO riots in Seattle. Beyond the disruption those riots caused at the time, I was working at One Union Square I couldnt understand what the rioters hoped to accomplish. They seemed to be protesting anything and everything. There was no coherency. Likewise, there was no discipline. Window-smashers assaulted downtown businesses, while anarchists baited the police into overreacting. Crowds pushed up the ramps near the convention center, trying to block I-5. Public transportation was blocked and vandalized too. It seemed to me I was witnessing, not a dedicated movement for change, but a kind of ritualistic cultural event for all those who felt like the need to express themselves outweighed actually trying to accomplish a goal with measurable metrics. I was very turned off by the whole episode.
Of course, then came the morning when some nice Middle Eastern gentlemen of a certain religious affiliation converted four full airliners into cruise missiles aimed at U.S. targets on U.S. soil. Ill never forget that day. Even though I was on the other side of the country. It was the moment when many of my conventional wisdoms about how people, and the world, work began to spectacularly unravel.
Because none of the Left-wing reactions to September 11, 2001, made any sense to me.
College professors called for solidarity with the terrorists. Liberals were openly self-blaming the United States for the event. Conspiracy theorists said it was an inside job by Bush, to fool us into going to war. People once again lamented the fact Gore had had the Presidency stolen from him because what was needed most of all, was a President who could go to the United Nations and repent before the world; on account of Americas long history of sordid capitalistic colonialist nationalist imperialism. Or something along those lines.
My reaction to it all was to openly say, What the f***?!
The United States indeed, the liberal West as a whole had been brutally attacked! Thousands died!
Yet the Left blamed us for the thing? We were the bad guys??!
Clearly, there was a major malfunction happening at the ideological level.
And the more I began to openly criticise these Left-wing reactions including my adamant insistence that Gore would have been compelled to go into Afghanistan, just as Bush had been the more hostility I encountered. And not just theoretically, either. I mean from people I worked with, went to school with, and also had become friends with. The culture of King County was going in one direction about the whole event, and I was going in a different direction. The more time went on, the wider the gap between these two trajectories became.
By the end of 2002, I was signed up with the Army Reserve. Me, they guy whod been talked out of joining ten years prior, because my Dad knew I was an easy-going fellow who liked to take it easy, and Dad was convinced Id hate military life.
Dad was right, too. I am not a natural serviceman. Its an existence quite foreign to my sensibilities. But I signed up anyway, because 9/11 felt to me like my generations version of Pearl Harbor. To arms, young men! Do not be caught standing on the sideliness of history! Take up the flag of your country, right or wrong! That sort of thing. I had no illusion Id be any kind of Rambo. When I joined, I had bad eyes, a bad knee, was very sedentary, and did not possess any talent for tactical training like the Army employs. I wouldnt be an infantry rock star. I just wanted to help out, in whatever capacity theyd have me. Because thats my general instinct in most crises: I simply want to assist, in tangible ways that count, versus merely being somebody who gets pissed off on the internet.
Trajectories, continuing to diverge. The ground lurches beneath the tree?
Seattle Democrats took an election away from Dino Rossi. Who won fairly if narrowly in the Washington race for governor. The Democrats of King County demanded a recount, then set about inventing ballots for Rossis competitor all along the way, and once they put Christine Gregoire over the top, magically the results became legit.
These Democrats didnt even try to hide what they were doing. They crowed about it, exclaiming, Were just getting revenge for what Bush did in 2000!
There was the woman on the street who said, Go Army, rape those Iraqis! when she saw me wearing my Army sweatshirt outside my apartment complex on Lake City Way. This somewhat startling comment would be reminded to me a couple of years later, when a classmate at Seattle Central Commun(ist) College told me it was a shame I signed up with the Reserve, because my job was to kill people. Uhhhh, what? Since when does being an HR Specialist at a Garrison Support Unit involve killing people? It got even worse when the students at SCCC began throwing water bottles at Army recruiters, as well as destroying Army recruiter literature. The students ran the recruiters off campus and cheered themselves doing it!
Those of us who were military, and attending, wondered how long it would be before we ourselves became targets.
This was about the time a one-man protest operation named ReplacementsNeeded! was covering every light and utility pole in the First Hill and Capitol Hill area, with quasi-anarchist, anti-military agit prop posters. They were vulgar, ghastly, and inflammatory, and they stretched from the sidewalk to seven feet above the pavement. Every. Single. Pole. Within about a two mile radius, give or take. He never cleaned up after himself. He fled Seattle with $10,000.00 in fines on his head, unpaid, then bitched on-line about how Evergreen State College wasnt progressive enough for him. I think hes since left the States altogether? I am not sure. I know he never took down any of his signs, despite the city ordnance.
Anyway, anti-military and anti-Bush protest marches were also routinely sprouting from the Capitol Hill district, usually kicking off at SCCC and meandering their way through downtown streets, leaving a wake of debris and sometimes damage to public and private property.
Like when they defended Clinton in 1998, I was severely let down by the liberal behavior I witnessed and experienced, after I joined the military. Nobody seemed to care if it was organized, or not. Nobody seemed to question the sense of attacking soldiers because the attackers hated the President. Feelings mattered more than facts. The ends justified the means. They were proud of it, too.
The tree finds itself standing still, as the sod runs like a river to the left . . .
Needless to say, I voted Bush for his second term. First time ever for me, selecting a Republican in a Presidential race. Even I was surprised. I had been unhappy with the Bush win four years earlier. But the nation was at war. Id always thought that failing to remove Saddam Hussein in 1990/1991 was a mistake. The 2003 Iraq invasion seemed like the U.S. was simply taking care of long-unfinished business. And Kerry? Goodness, how in he world was I supposed to take that man seriously? He seemed to embody everything that had been going haywire (in my opinion) with American politics, in the wake of 9/11. Hed thrown his medals over the White House fence when it was politically expedient, and now he was reporting for duty and saluting at the DNC, when it was politically expedient.
I did not trust John Kerry to lead the country any better than Bush had. So, while I did not think Bush was flawless he wasnt I thought he was the better option. Just as Id thought Clinton was the better option, years before.
But, to be an outted Bush voter in Seattle, was to be an unwanted alien living and working in the Puget Sound I-5 corridor.
I had betrayed the zeitgeist of the region.
Eventually, my wife and I moved back to Utah. Not because of the politics, but because of the cost of living. For an area that prides itself on being merciful to people who dont have a lot of money, the Puget Sound I-5 corridor is a wickedly expensive place to try to function on a single income; when youve got a wife and child to house and feed. Plus, we knew my Mom and Dad would be needing some assistance soon, and it was far easier for us to go to them, than for them to come to us.
But when the Obama election rolled around later that same year, even being in Utah was not sufficient to insulate me from the same attitudes I used to face routinely in the Puget Sound. Because suddenly, if you werent fainting to the ground with love and adoration for Saint Obama, you werent just called stupid, you were declared evil. You were RACIST! Because nobody could not vote for Obama, without being a RACIST! could they? Of course not. Both the media and the Obama voters let all of us in poor dumb hick fly-over country know just what kind of reprobates we were. For not being on board the Obama bandwagon.
And I didnt even vote for McCain. He seemed like a dud to me. Nor was I impressed with Obama, who seemed like he was all flash, but little substance. I wrote in Mitt Romney for (P) and Condi Rice for (VP) knowing I was throwing away my vote. It had not been the first time, nor would it be the last.
Didnt matter to the Obama zealots, of course. Nor did my marriage. Everybody who was not 110% pro-Obama, was magically painted with the RACIST! brush. This was a fact, the zealots said. We were all RACIST! It was declared over, and over, and over again. Apparently this made my wife a RACIST! too, against her own kind because she voted third party in 2008, as she has often done over the years (shes just an independent gal like that, and was not impressed with Obama either.)
So, did Obama eventually win me over, the way Clinton and Bush had won me over?
No. Obama cut arbitrary deals with Wall Street and the banks. The economy already headed into the hole crashed and burned. He paid lip service to promises made on the campaign trail closing Guantanamo bay, removing U.S. troops entirely from places like Iraq while courting the favor of vocal elites in academia, the media, and the entertainment industry. He loved being treated like a rock star, because in reality he was still just that nerdy, underachieving, culturally-white black kid; who had to affect a ghetto accent when politically touring dilapidated inner-city streets he never lived on.
But damn if Obama didnt make his Leftist white voters feel spectacular about themselves, for having voted for him!
Apparently this was the sole great benefit of re-voting for Obama again in 2012: being able to proclaim your awesomeness as a human being, for having re-elected Teh Furst Black Presadent.
I am sounding mighty cynical at this point, am I not? But wait, theres more.
By late 2015, I was overseas with a Joint Task Force designed to confront ISIS. We watched Obama effectively yank the cord on our mission. We also watched as Hillary Clinton recently of Benghazi disaster fame wiped the walls with Bernie Sanders. She would face Trump for the Presidency in 2016. It was a certainty that she would win. No way would Trump make it. He was an absurd candidate. Hillary was inevitable. Very few of us in that Task Force trusted her. But Trump? The reality TV star with bronze hair and orange skin? What?
My UK counterpart in the Task Force, a 30+ year British Army veteran, was cannier than I was. Mate, get ready for President Trump, he said. I told him it was impossible. After watching Romney lose in 2012 the only Presidential election in which Id ever felt truly and deeply invested I had no faith in any kind of resistance to someone like Hillary. She would cake walk her way into the Oval Office.
My Brit friend turned out to be right.
But not before all of us who could not stomach Hillarys lying and duplicity in Washington D.C., got to be labeled SEXISTS!
Failure to be full-blown enthusiastic about Hillary was SEXIST! We were woman-haters, all of us. Even other women, who clearly detested their own vaginas, by not supporting Hillary.
Many of us would have happily voted Democrat in that race, if someone like Joe Lieberman or Jim Webb had run. I myself would have cheered a Lieberman or a Webb candidacy. I would have been all in. Hell, I was half-serious when I said Id vote Sanders before Id vote Trump. Remember what I said, about not wanting to owe a vote to anyone? The Republicans had not captured me. I was in play. And so were many other people. I know. I talked to them. It was the easiest crossover bet for the Democrats since Clinton in 1996. Surely. Because . . . Trump?! Seriously??!
But no. Hillary railroaded the DNC and PWN3D the Dem primary process, tossing Bernie out on his ear. As had been the case for a long time, what Hillary wanted, Hillary got. And it didnt matter who stood in her way.
Meanwhile, the Left applauded, and applauded, and applauded some more.
If you werent With Her! you were deplorable. Everybody who was anybody, was going out of his or her way, to wave the Hillary flag. It was wall-to-wall virtue signalling, dialed to eleven.
Then came the evening of November 8, 2016. Oh my.
I was as shocked by the Trump win as any other non-Trumper. Outrageous. And yet, it was nice to see an ideological inevitability Im with Her! overturned by a republican (note the small r) process still healthy enough to stand up to a vainglorious technocrat of Hillarys raw ambition. I mean, she did everything right. She courted celebrity opinion. She raked in the endorsements. She had corporations in her hip pocket, and billions of dollars behind her, plus a friendly media who ate out of both her hands. Academics loved her. All the Obama faithful loved her.
Not loving her, was a sure sign of misogyny. Nobody wants to be a woman-hater, right? How does she not win?
Apparently, by being the one candidate 63 million voters disliked even more than Donald Trump.
Which of course has touched off close to 90 days of destructive political pandemonium in these United States. Denunciations. Riots. Beatings. Calls for the White House to be bombed, and for the military to rise up and overthrow the government. All from liberals. All by liberals. A righteous junta! Nevermind that the military vote went to Trump at a 3 to 1 ratio, with a large percentage of the remaining military vote going to 3rd parties. I was in the latter category.
And I have been reminded every single day, just how far Ive been pushed away by so-called progressives in this country.
Sure, some of that is me walking my talk. I am not exactly the same guy I was 25 years ago. And not because I dont think some of the idealism of liberal thought is not worthy, or even evocatively beautiful.
Liberalism the kind I was attracted to in my teens, and early twenties mostly focuses on brighter futures with better choices.
Yet at many points over the past quarter century, that shining picture of what the Left supposedly stands for, has been undermined again, and again, and again, and again, by the behavior of self-styled Leftists.
Maybe it all comes down to the fact that I decided Alinskys ballyhooed rules are pernicious. Not once do they involve self-reflection, nor questions of higher moral obligation to a power or a need beyond simple political expediency. Like with the 2004 Washington State governors race, the ends justify the means. If youre a Leftist and you have to lie to get what you want, then lie. If youre a Leftist and you have to cheat to get what you want, then cheat. If youre a Leftist and you have to hurt people to get what you want, or if you have to frighten people into not opposing you, then hurt and frighten people.
Never doubt that everything you the Leftist says or does, is done justifiably.
Everyone and everything is a fair target. Lash out. Incriminate. Slander. Punish. Make them quake in their boots. They deserve it, the jerks. If youre not with us, youre with the terrorists! Oops, Leftists excoriated Bush 43 for saying that. Now they themselves live it every day. If you didnt vote for Hillary, youre with the KKK and the Nazis!
Leftists now give all of us a political litmus test, without exception. Wrong-thinkers will be singled out for eviction from the human equation.
I certainly experienced plenty of this crap during the Sad Puppies campaign, wherein us rowdy sci-fi nonconformists from Delta Tau Chi crashed the Faber homecoming parade, and all hell broke loose with the people from Omega Theta Pi.
And if youre wondering how in the world an Animal House analogy works in all of this, consider the fact that Senator Blutarsky undoubtedly switched to the Republicans after 9/11/2001. Donald Trump rallies were the toga parties of the election. The Electoral College smashed Hillary Clintons guitar against the stairwell wall.
I dont feel like Ive stopped being the liberal I was at age 19 still married to the same amazing lady, still enjoying public radio, still pro-choice, still pro-legalization, still about people having brighter futures as much as I feel left behind.
The cultural shift thats masqueraded beneath a banner of liberalism, kicked me out. Or I walked away. Whichever.
Like Hermey the elf, from Rudolph the Red-nosed Reindeer. You cant fire me, I quit!
Naturally, my liberal friends reading this will shake their heads from side to side, with pained expressions on their faces. Hes got it all wrong. The Right is so much worse. They are always worse.
Hey folks, I never said the Right was perfect. Nor are the people of the Right immune to being hypocrites about a lot of things.
But heres the shocker. There is far, far more true liberalism on the American Right, in this 21st century, than inhabits the American Left.
Ill say it again: there is far more real, actual, tangible liberalism, on the American Right, at this point in time, than on the American Left. By a significant margin.
This is not my opinion based on Fox News, Limbaugh, or Breitbart. I dont watch Fox News, nor do I listen to Limbaugh, nor do I follow Breitbart. This is my opinion based on a quarter century of cumulative experience and analysis. I have reached this point, having felt the spectrum of American political discourse being dragged beneath my feet, such that many of the old-style liberal heroes of yore would be called dangerously extreme Republicans today.
Doubt me? Hell, JFK was a recklessly warmongering one-percenter. Like Bush 43 and Romney rolled into one! He could not hope to win the Democratic ticket in 2017. Hed be compared to Trump, and lambasted in a similar manner. Meanwhile, Martin Luther King would be called a race traitor, for failing to embrace intersectional identity theories and their attendant anti-caucasian, anti-male, anti-straight, anti-cis hatreds which place Victimhood (caps v) above content of character.
Even the original Suffragettes would be kicked out of the Good Guy club, for their traditional opposition to abortion.
In other words, there is almost nothing about the 21st century American Left, which can be accurately called liberal. No way in hell.
The 21st century American Left is instead a cultural and political enforcer of both dogma, and uniformity. Which preens in the mirror each morning, celebrating its eminent superiority, and talking down to, attacking, or otherwise throwing out anyone and everyone who steps out of line.
It doesnt take much to get put on the bad people list. Witness all the proper progressives forever being witch-burned on our campuses, by the intersectional crybabies (in grown bodies) who demand to never be disagreed with, otherwise theyre triggered and need to run to their safe spaces.
I cant ride in that dysfunctional clown car. It is anti-intellectual, and anti-reason. It proposes to elevate feelings above all else, and has turned victimization both real and imagined into a bizarre form of morally-elevated celebrity.
Being a victim is now chic!
Failure to abide by the dogma, gets you attacked. You cant even criticize the dogma from a friendly standpoint, without being ejected from the tribe of propriety. You are kicked to the curb. Shamed. Shunned. Called names. They attack your friends, your family, try to get you fired from your job, and worse.
I mean, good Lord, they attacked Lady Gagas Super Bowl halftime show, because she didnt get up on stage and pull a Madonna or an Ashley Judd.
Thus Lady Gaga failed the movement. She is a traitor. Yes, Lady Gaga.
Meanwhile, you can apparently beat a woman to the ground on the campus of U.C. Berkeley, and its no-harm no-foul so long as you can call that woman a fascist just because you feel like shes bad, for having a different opinion.
My gentle suggestion would be: the first step in fighting fascism, involves not being a fascist.
But isnt the American Right crackers too? Sometimes, sure. Delta Tau Chi is hardly a monolith of coherency.
Its just that, I think the ass-paddlers of Omega Theta Pi can have their black robes and their rituals of humiliation cough, check your privilege, cough while I will be over at the slum fraternity, having fun with the other deplorables. Delta Tau Chi never tells me I have to prove I am a good ally by debasing myself endlessly, then going on the attack against others. They also dont demand that I model and emulate an increasingly strident and narrow form of ideological purity. They further do not believe in throwing friends to the wolves when the torches and pitch forks of the Left arrive at the door.
Omega Theta Pi the modern American Left are control freaks by comparison. They are in love with banning things. Outlawing words. Ideas. People. Making it a punishable offense to disagree. All while taking selfies and giving themselves squishy hugs for being such wonderful, proper, altogether forward-thinking and forward-believing human beings.
And if you believe otherwise, then f*** you, youre a RACIST! and a SEXIST! and a HOMOPHOBE! and an ISLAMOPHOBE!
Which reminds me: every LDS person in good standing has become painfully aware of just how big the double-standard is, when the Left talks about religion, and religious cultures. Islam and Muslims are a protected, sacrosanct class. Mormons? F*** em. Racist, sexist, inbred, fanatical morons. The LDS leadership in Salt Lake City cannot utter a single peep about church policy, without it becoming an excuse for breathless Left-wing tabloid hyperventilation about the problem of Mormonism. Meanwhile, Islamic radicals continue to murder on just about every continent, and violate every sacred belief in the progressive playbook, but we as a nation are piously reminded to never hold Islam or Muslims accountable. Never, ever, ever, ever. If you say otherwise, you are ISLAMOPHOBIC!
And being ISLAMOPHOBIC! is almost as bad as being TRANSPHOBIC! Even though getting caught being gay or trans in many Isamic countries, is a death sentence. Or worse.
But then, the modern American Left is not great at logical consistency. Thoughts dont count. Its the feelz.
Skeptical? Check this out.
Want to be a woman today, even if youre genetically and anatomically male? Shazam! Youre a woman! Here is your golden Victim crown of identity! Nobody is allowed to say otherwise! Oh wait, women who are actually women with lady parts and everything cease to be women the instant they run for office as Republicans. They magically lose their melanin too. Just ask Mia Love if shes still allowed to be black.
The American Left will confiscate your gender and your ethnicity, if they catch you playing for the wrong team.
Again, the pattern emerges: taking away, taking away, taking away. The modern American Left is obsessed with removing things. I dont know how or why it came to this, but it has. They want to take away your single-occupancy vehicle. They want to take away your ability to operate your private business according to your religious convictions except Muslims, who will get a pass. They want to take away your right to choose where your kids are schooled, and how. They want to take away your furnace, and your air conditioner global warming, cough, climate change, cough, reasons, cough. They want to take away your options at restaurants, and also at the grocery store you will no longer be allowed to have bad things in bad quantities. They want to take away your right to own firearms and defend yourself, your family, and your property because only the police should have guns. Even though the same mouths claims the police are out of control and kill black people for sport.
This is not liberalism. Its contradictory, nonsensical tyranny, which dresses itself up in a ghastly pink-fuzzy bunny suit of false benevolence. Like Ralphie from Christmas Story, except hes been zombified, and hes going to eat you.
You know what I say to that?
In the immortal words of Ned and Uncle Jimbo, from South Park: ITS COMING RIGHT FOR US!
Speaking of South Park, if you need any further proof that the American Left has dragged the spectrum beneath us, consider the Comedy Central fixture which went from being the prime amusement of adolescent liberals, to one of the few entertainment weapons left in the arsenal of adult conservatives (I know, I know, were often the same people; just two decades older.)
Matt and Trey are among the few vocal entertainment pairs left, who will openly make fun of progressives and progressive gospel.
Fred Armisen and Carrie Brownstein being another pair. I have seldom laughed harder, than while watching Portlandia.
(Satire is Kryptonite to the 21st century liberal moral majority, just as it was Kryptonite to the 20th century conservative moral majority.)
My bottom-line analysis? American liberalism abandoned American liberalism.
I watched and felt it happen, right before my own eyes. The Left became power-drunk on their ascendant ride through our culture, and now its morphed into the very kind of petty, thin-skinned, tin-pot authoritarianism which the Left claims to oppose. It rejects all questioning, and seeks to revile and hurt the questioner. Look at how scientists who criticize climate change alarmism, become pariahs in their own profession called denialist in an almost ritualistic fashion, by the keepers of the gnostic doctrine of the Church of Global Warming. See how women and ethnic minorities and gays and lesbians, who come out as conservative, or Republican, are treated as traitors. Witness business owners and executives who resign in humiliation, when they are outed for supporting religiously-based political initiatives that run contra to the Left-wing agenda. (Unless theyre Muslim free pass!)
Folks, I cant truck with this. I cant be with the authoritarian control freaks people who fight the so-called alt-Right, by inventing an even more problematic ctrl-Left. Not even if the ctrl-Left are the heirs to history, like they always claim they are.
My personal suspicion as someone who recognizes that history is not a straight-line ramp of destiny, but rather a variable waveform of deliberate action twined with chance is that nobody owns the future. The more hotly and adamantly somebody claims to own the future, like Khrushchev slamming his shoe at the United Nations, the more sure I am this person (or this movement) is writing its own epitaph. Authoritarians always fail. Always. If not sooner, then later. Because human beings are unruly. We seldom do as were told. Not even when its the cuddly cudgel of compassionate dictatorship banging down across our skulls.
Yes, yes, I know, the American Right has had plenty of moments in that unkind spotlight too. Theyre not immune to overreaching.
The American Right just seems to better understand the way people and the world actually work, versus how we might wish for them to work. Thus the American Right spends a lot of its intellectual and emotional capital on concepts like individual liberty and limited government, according to the wishes of the U.S. Founders.
The American Left, meanwhile, is obsessed with perfecting the human condition, using the ideas of theorists like Marx. They seek a total reformation of society, as well as the state. They are anti-Enlightenment, believing that empirical science and objective analysis are somehow RACIST! as well as SEXIST! Facts which refute the reformative theory, are to be suppressed, and the fact-finders walled out of polite discussion.
The ghosts of the gulags and the killing fields tell us which of these two paradigms is sustainable, and which is not.
I choose to listen to the ghosts.
EDIT TO ADD: a friend reminded me of something I wrote two years ago. Re-reading it, I have to say, Yup.
If I am insufficiently hateful of a hater who hates, I am therefore a secret hater? And in order to absolve myself of being a secret hater, I have to loudly and publicly hate the hater more than anyone else who presently hates the hater who hates, and this will prove that I am not a secret hater, because I will have hated the hater the way the haters of the hater say I need to hate the hater because he hates? Hating is now how you prove youre not a hater. You just have to hate the people the anti-hate haters approve of hating!
Because being an anti-hater is all about hating the haters who hate, even if theyre not really hating, but you think they secretly hate anyway. Because all of us are secret haters who have to be shown our hatred, by the hating haters of hate who hate all secret haters. So that in order to become an anti-hater, you must hate yourself for being a secret hater, who then goes on to hate the hating haters the haters of hate say you have to hate in order to become an anti-hater who formerly hated in the wrong way. But once you hate in the right way, you are magically absolved of being a hater, and can go around hating on everyone you want.
EDIT TO ADD AGAIN: if youve not read this excellent piece by my senior at Baen Books, bestseller John Ringo, you should. I agree especially with Johns point reinforced by this viral bit from British satirist Tom Walker, doing his Jonathan Pie character that the voting booth remains one of the very few places in American life where people can express how they think and feel, and not get attacked for it. So the Left can shame and shun and label people all day every day, but when those people pull the curtain and prepare to punch their card at election time, what does all the shunning, shaming, and labeling accomplish? In Tom Walkers words, you get President Trump! (Trust a Brit to see it clearly, just as my buddy in the Joint Task Force did.) But the Left seem to have learned all the wrong lessons from Trumps win. Instead of pushing the PAUSE button and doing a wholesale review of both tactics and rhetoric, the Left have doubled down. The name-calling is even louder. Even more people are being thrown into the basket of deplorables. At this point, the Left are doing so much angry eviction kicking people out of the auditorium theyre liable to wind up shouting at empty seats. The Left are so high on their own supply of smug self-righteousness, they cannot be bothered to come down from their ivory tower, eat some humble pie, and talk to the rest of us like were decent people.
The author seems to hinting or suggesting what happened with Obama's election was somehow as bad or as violent as the historic wide spread organized violence directed at Trump and his supporters for nearly 2 years now. If that's the case, no sale.
Great Post. Thank you.
Good points I completely missed. Thanks.
That is a REALLY good rant!
“The Left became power-drunk on their ascendant ride through our culture, and now its morphed into the very kind of petty, thin-skinned, tin-pot authoritarianism which the Left claims to oppose”
In a word they became “Institutionalized”
This was a great read.
If any are wondering if it’s worth the word count. I’d like to reassure that it really is.
Very interesting. Thanks for posting. “I’m still pro-choice.” The author is smart and a good writer. He has discovered how liberalism is a mental disorder, such as supporting abortion after watching a sonogram.
Not once did the author mention one, simple way out of the narcissistic nightmare of leftist politics: prayer. He should say prayers, ask the Lord for guidance and light a candle for his friends in the Army.
“My Mom and Dad...” That’s what preserved him for the insanity of the left.
“And if youre wondering how in the world an Animal House analogy works in all of this, consider the fact that Senator Blutarsky undoubtedly switched to the Republicans after 9/11/2001. Donald Trump rallies were the toga parties of the election. The Electoral College smashed Hillary Clintons guitar against the stairwell wall.”
This also ignores that there was an entire field of Republicans less desirable than Trump. Hell, one was so despised he couldn't even get applause from members of his party when he begged for it.
“ctrl-Left” - Brilliant!
Great post. I wrote Boxer and Feinstein during the Bill Clinton impeachment. They did respond that they continued to support him because of all the other good things he did. I was a Democrat then and I was appalled and horrified.
Watching the histrionics of the democrats on the floor during the impeachment was the final straw. All sound and fury and emotion, signifying nothing. I never looked back.
The ARE the party of the feelz and they make me sick. I’m just hoping they’re making the younger generation sick too.
Great rant,even if he hasn’t quite come all the way to our side.
I’ve been using “Ctrl-Left” since at least August, and I have seen others come up with that obvious and appropriate parallel to the liberal “Alt-Right” invention. It needs to keep growing; liberals hate it.
I’ve been here for years and never noticed it; thank you. It is a great counter to “alt-right”...
I never used it before last year, but I never heard “Alt-right” before last year either.
The “alt-Left” is the mob that makes up their base (an alternative to the WASP norms - sexual deviants, Welfarians, unassimilated ethnics, etc.); they are the dupes of the Bolshevik “ctrl-Left”. This relationship was epitomized by that white lib b!tch asking for some “muscle” to deal with someone who disagreed with her (leading from behind, beckoning low-information slaves to do the dirty work)...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.