This is the exact scenario I have suspected from the very beginning.
Simple and makes the most sense.
-
Occam’s razor
She’s 84...of course she’s fragile...Anyone with brains would change their plans and just rob the place and leave.
Same
And as someone once said “There’s a LOT of holes in the desert”.
Could be, but I’m not convinced it was ever a kidnapping.
Pure, unadulterated evil. And 83 and having had parents who lived to 88 and 93 I’ll say that just about anybody in this age group has a number of apparent and, possibly, not so apparent health problems that would make being kidnapped an absolute disaster and likely to provoke a terminal cardiac event.
They may have underestimated her health.
But the kidnappers did not underestimate the incompetence of the Pima County Sheriff and his department.
It may have been a botched kidnapping but not nearly as botched as the “investigation” which was textbook of what not to do.
She likely didn’t survive more than a day or two given the stress of the kidnapping and her frail health. The kidnappers underestimated both the wealth of the Guthrie family and the health of Nancy Guthrie. Let’s hope they get caught and face murder charges
I think Nancy had something to do with it and is milkin’ it for all it’s worth. Just an opinion.
She’s in a shallow grave in Mexico.
Tend to agree
No more ransom demands = She is dead and discarded
84 years old.
Who knew? 🤷♀️
Yes.
And I believe she died very quickly after she was abducted.
Very sad and I hope the bastard(s) who did this are caught.
The women who are speaking out and threatening Eric Stalwell are receiving glossy pictures of Nancy Guhrie in unmarked envelopes.
Likewise. Pitiful isnt it?
That possible scenario was floated around by everybody from about day three.
I don’t understand the hostility toward the Sheriff’s Dept. The perps didn’t leave any clues. One can’t make something out of nothing. Cases like this always rely on tips.
You and me must be experts too, since that’s been my theory from the start as well.
Nancy Guthrie will now join the club of missing persons like Amelia Earhart and Jimmy Hoffa and Madeleine McCann.
That door cam video really highlighted how competent the “kidnappers” were. First, the backpack seem full. If one is doing this for money, it would make sense to either not have a full backpack or at the very least bring an extra bag to carry valuable items. If the backpack is full, there should be something in the backpack to deal with the door camera but the “kidnapper” just looked for part of a tree to try to cover the camera.
I agree with the theory that Nancy Guthrie likely died shortly after the kidnapping because the kidnapper likely just gave up trying to collect millions of dollars in bitcoin. If one has already setup an online address to collect bitcoin, the kidnapper should have given Savannah extra chances to send the money or anonymously drop videos at local television stations showing Nancy still alive. I wonder if this was the police of FBI’s theory early on and maybe that is why the FBI told Savannah to not pay the ransom but the FBI didn’t want to tell Savannah their belief that Nancy already died.
It may take years, but it seems likely that eventually someone will talk.