The Roman Emperor Who Broke the Nose of Alexander the Great’s Corpse

Just like in modern times, many people in antiquity enjoyed visiting the tombs of famous historical figures. One of the most famous historical figures in the Greco-Roman world was Alexander the Great. According to ancient records, one of the Roman emperors visited his tomb. However, while doing so, this Roman emperor ended up breaking off Alexander the Great’s nose. Did this really happen, though?

Alexander the Great died in the fourth century BCE in the year 323. He was buried in a magnificent tomb, which was just as famous in antiquity as it is today. It was a sarcophagus that fit his body like a glove, and it was made out of solid gold. There was an expensive, purple robe covering the torso and possibly the legs with gold embroidered on it.

Later on, Alexander’s tomb changed significantly. According to Strabo, a Greek writer of the first century CE, King Ptolemy X took the gold from Alexander’s magnificent tomb and melted it down for his own purposes.

After this, the gold tomb was replaced with one made of glass, as per Strabo. Many scholars consider it likely that this is a reference to alabaster, a type of material occasionally used for small windows due to its slight translucence. It was this “glass” tomb that one of the Roman emperors visited when he allegedly broke off Alexander’s nose. But how did this happen?

Alexander the Great’s tomb visited by a Roman emperor The emperor in question was Augustus Caesar, the first true Roman emperor. One of the main accounts about his visit to Alexander the Great’s tomb comes from Suetonius. This visit occurred in 30 BCE, a few years before Augustus actually became emperor. At that point, he was known as Octavian.

According to Suetonius’ account, Octavian placed a gold crown on the head of the fallen king, as well as flowers on the tomb. However, there is a later account which adds another peculiar detail.

This later account comes from Cassius Dio. He lived in the late-second to early-third century CE. For reference, this is about one century after Suetonius. His version of events obviously does not hold as much weight as Suetonius’ version for this reason. But what exactly did Cassius Dio say about Octavian’s visit?

“After this he viewed the body of Alexander and actually touched it, whereupon, it is said, a piece of the nose was broken off.”

This is all that Cassius has to say about Octavian’s visit. He does not even mention the future emperor placing the crown and flowers on the tomb. Some modern sources say that Octavian broke the nose while leaning down to kiss Alexander. Others say it occurred while Octavian was placing the crown on Alexander’s head.

However, as we can see from the original account in which this story is found, neither of those claims actually hold up. Cassius merely says that Octavian broke the nose when he touched the body. He offers no additional details.

This brief account has lead to speculation regarding its historicity. Some scholars believe that this may well have actually happened, whereas others believe it is just a bit of ancient fiction. What does the evidence really indicate?

The first thing is that Suetonius mentions nothing about this. He lived a full century closer to the event in question than did Cassius Dio. For this reason, his account is logically more reliable than that of Cassius Dio.

Of course, Suetonius does not specifically say that Octavian did not break off Alexander’s nose (although, if that story had not already circulated, why would he have?). He also does not include any information which absolutely precludes the idea. Nonetheless, this is such a remarkable incident that we would surely have expected him to have mentioned it if it had in fact happened.

Another consideration is the fact that Cassius adds the phrase “it is said” when recounting the story. This suggests that not even Cassius was fully convinced it had occurred. For these reasons, many scholars believe that the account of this Roman emperor breaking off the nose of Alexander the Great is merely fiction.

I seem to remember reading Caligula had a penchant for
robbing Alexander’s tomb of items such as armor and prancing around in it.
Then, Alexander’s remains disappeared. Probably buried secretly for safe keeping whatever was left.

There is a scene in one of Stephen Saylor’s historical fictions of Rome where the star of the story is with Augustus in Alexandria when Augustus kisses Alexander on the cheek and does knock his nose aside.

https://www.amazon.com/Roma-Novel-Ancient-Steven-Saylor/dp/0312328311

The rest of the keyword, sorted:

Who Owns Alexander the Great? It's a Diplomatic Minefield.North Macedonia has claimed historical figures as part of a drive to build a national identity. That has ruffled the feathers of the Balkan nation's neighbors. [06/19/2024]
Tiny, 1800-year-old portrait of Alexander the Great found in Denmark [05/07/2024]
How Alexander the Great's Army Horses Discovered Himalayan Salt [03/11/2024]
Was Alexander the Great Gay? What the Historians Say [02/02/2024]
The identities of the occupants of the unspoiled 4th-century BCE Royal Tombs at Vergina in northern Greece have been identified [02/01/2024]
The 2,400-Year-Old Palace Where Alexander the Great Was Crowned Reopens in Greece [01/09/2024]
Pictures: Greece Unveils Palace Where Alexander the Great was Crowned King After 16-Year Restoration [AP so no posting pics] [01/07/2024]
Ancient Iraqis may have worshipped Alexander the Great: Archaeologists discover a temple where the Greek king was proclaimed 'divine' 2,300 years ago [12/05/2023]
The Greek Kingdoms in Ancient China [10/31/2023]
Is this Alexander the Great's escort? Tomb of a courtesan who may have seduced the Macedonian king is discovered after 2,300 years [10/08/2023]
The Aral Sea: The Toxic Soviet Sea [09/11/2023]
Was Alexander the Great an Alcoholic? [08/17/2023]
Turkiye receives ancient tomb stele repatriated from Italy [07/19/2023]
Alexander the Great's New Facial Reconstruction Presented by Researchers. [05/07/2023]
Archaeologists hail find of 'Seleucid satrap tomb' in west-central Iran [05/22/2022]
Why an ISIS Propagandist Abandoned Islam [04/06/2022]
How much Gold did the Romans have - and where is it now? [12/08/2021]
Ancient Greek Buddhists [10/15/2021]
The Lost Greek Cities of Central Asia [09/05/2021]
If They Want Compliance, Officials Should Follow Their Own Rules [08/07/2021]
Tomb of Olympias, Alexander The Great's Mother, Found! [07/13/2021]
How the UN Stole Jewish Homes in Occupied Jerusalem and Set Off the Latest Conflict [05/23/2021]
356 BCE: Herostratus burns the Temple of Artemis [07/20/2020]
Ex-Green Beret claims he led foiled raid into Venezuela [05/03/2020]
Has the location of Alexander the Great's Tomb been found [03/12/2020]
Why the Ruins of Persepolis (Iran) is one of the Wonders of the Ancient World [01/08/2020]
A new mathematical model predicts a knot's stability [01/03/2020]
The Sacred City of Mecca: Have We Got It Wrong? | TRACKS [08/02/2019]
What three historical people do you wish lived longer? [05/27/2019]
Alexander the Great 'was ALIVE while his body was prepared for burial' [01/29/2019]
"The Recently Discovered Journal of Alexander the Great" by Henry Livingston (1793) [12/10/2018]
Trump Is Cutting Old Gordian Knots [04/04/2018]
Macedonia Ready to Give up Claims on Alexander the Great [12/28/2017]
The Lowly King of Israel...Zechariah pt 13 [02/23/2017]
Gentile Powers Will Be Overthrown...Zechariah pt 12 [02/22/2017]
Archaeologists discover layers of Indo-Greek city in Swat [06/26/2016]
Inscription Spurs Debate Over Mysterious Greek Tomb [Amphipolis] [03/05/2016]
BOMBSHELL: Amazing Biblical Archeological Discovery In Jerusalem... [11/10/2015]
Fortress of Antiochus Epiphanes Uncovered in Jerusalem [11/04/2015]
Archaeological find in Jerusalem's City of David may answer ancient mystery [2 Thess 2] [11/03/2015]
Border Fence - India's border fence at night [10/05/2015]
Huqoq 2015: New Mosaics Unearthed at Huqoq Synagogue [08/08/2015]
Alexander the Great-Era Treasure Found in Israeli Cave [03/10/2015]
Coolest Archaeological Discoveries of 2014 [CHEESE!] [12/30/2014]
Massive 2,800-year-old farmhouse found in central Israel [12/19/2014]
Second Temple Era Military Outpost Discovered, Possibly Destroyed By Alexander the Great [11/24/2014]
Amphipolis skeleton from Alexander's time found in Greece [11/12/2014]
Large mosaic in ancient tomb uncovered in Greece [Amphipolis update] [10/13/2014]
Remains of Alexander the Great's Father Confirmed Found [10/11/2014]
Have they found Alexander the Great's tomb? Or maybe his mother's? [10/03/2014]
Fever mounts as stunning statues found at ancient Greek tomb (Amphipolis) [09/07/2014]
Historian Claims The Louvre Museum Holds Ancient Amphipolis Tomb Treasures [08/26/2014]
Greek archaeologists enter large underground tomb [Amphipolis update] [08/26/2014]
Greek tomb at Amphipolis is 'important discovery' [08/13/2014]
Mystery over massive Alexander-era tomb unearthed in Greece [08/13/2014]
Egypt Archaeologists May Have Found Alexander the Great's Tomb [05/03/2014]
War Elephant Myths Debunked by DNA [01/20/2014]
Did toxic wine kill Alexander the Great? Scientists 'find plant behind ancient leader's'... [01/11/2014]
An Ancient City Is Discovered Underwater. What They Found Will Change History Forever [12/07/2013]
Have archaeologists discovered the grave of Alexander the Great? [08/23/2013]
Origin of Kalash inferred with Eurogenes K=10 "test" calculator [08/03/2013]
Stuck between Israel and PA, key archaeological site neglected [Sebastia] [07/28/2013]
Rare Finding of Ancient Greek Warrior [05/25/2013]
Macedonia's 'Indiana Jones' Won't Rest Until He Finds Alexander's Tomb [11/23/2012]
Alexander the not so Great: History through Persian eyes [07/25/2012]
Mosaic in Israel Shows Biblical Samson [07/05/2012]
New Indo-European Language Discovered [06/21/2012]
Greeks claim having found Alexander the Great's tomb, Ark of the Covenant [11/09/2011]
Restored ancient citadel in western Afghanistan is symbol of hope in nation beset by war [10/17/2011]
(January 14, 2011) 2,100 year-old Greek coin may have marked rare astronomical event [01/17/2011]
Cleopatra Not First Female Pharoah of Her Line: Queen Arsinoe II, an Olympian medalist... [12/12/2010]
Big noses, curly hair on empress's coffin suggests deep cultural exchange on Silk Road [09/20/2010]
Experts question claim that Alexander the Great's half-brother is buried at Vergina [09/12/2010]
Hellenism's agent of revival in Afghanistan [08/27/2010]
Alexander the Great Killed by Toxic Bacteria? [07/19/2010]
The First Wristwatch [05/12/2010]
Obama celebrates Greek Independence Day [03/25/2009]
Hunt for Alexander's tomb: Greece, Egypt, Persia, India, Broome [03/20/2009]
Did Muhammad Ever Really Live? [09/19/2008]
Archeologists find vast ancient city in Afghanistan [08/17/2008]
Rag And Bone Cup Dates To 300BC [05/27/2008]
Alexander the Great's "Crown," Shield Discovered? [04/25/2008]
Alexander's Gulf outpost uncovered [08/07/2007]
Hidden City Found Beneath Alexandria [07/25/2007]
Alexander and the tomb of Cyrus the Great [Deep Respect] [03/21/2007]
Greek language engravings discovered in Alexandria [09/22/2006]
Macedonian history unearthed [08/05/2006]
Greek tomb find excites experts [02/12/2006]
Greeks find largest Macedonian tomb of nobles [02/12/2006]
Rewriting Victors' View of Persian History [09/13/2005]
Alexander the Great and his staff meetings [09/06/2005]
Egnatia Digs Reveal Roman Road Secrets [07/28/2005]
Oliver Stone Cuts Gay References for 'Alexander' DVD Release [05/12/2005]
Gay history month to 'out' Newton and Nightingale (Is there anybody who WASN'T gay?) [01/18/2005]
Oliver Stone fumes at new fundamentalist morality in US [01/11/2005]
Oliver Stone laments 'Alexander the gay' [01/01/2005]
Alexander the Not So Great [12/31/2004]
Queering History: Alexander [12/14/2004]
The Greeks Won't Sue Oliver Stone: They Don't Know Where to Start [12/05/2004]
The Truth About Alexander the Great in World and Bible History [12/05/2004]
Alexander wasn't gay [11/26/2004]
'Alexander' - Vast story potential is reduced to plodding soap opera [11/24/2004]
'Alexander' Evokes Parallels to Politics [11/22/2004]
Oliver Stone's world-weary philosophy [11/21/2004]
NYP: ALEX THE GAY -- Greeks fuming at 'flaming' film by Oliver Stone [11/20/2004]
Outraged Greeks say Alexander was not bisexual. [11/20/2004]
Outraged Greeks say Alexander was not bisexual (Hollyweird rewriting history) [11/20/2004]
Alexander the Great [11/19/2004]
Stone Defends Alexander [11/18/2004]
Alexander The Great's Death Debated [08/03/2004]
Alexander the Great visits tomb of Cyrus the Great [06/12/2004]
Library of Alexandria discovered [05/17/2004]
FR Canteen ~ Alexander The Great: Conclusion ~ January 13, 2004 [01/13/2004]
FReeper Canteen ~ Alexander The Great: Conquest of Syria, Phoenicia, Egypt ~ January 6, 2004 [01/06/2004]
USO Canteen FReeper Style ~ Alexander The Great: Philip's Kingdom ~ December 30, 2003 [12/30/2003]
USO Canteen FReeper Style ~ Ancient Greek Military: Alexander The Great ~ December 23, 2003 [12/23/2003]
How Great Was Alexander? [06/13/2003]
Greeks, Turks and Bulgarians, are they related? [04/15/2002]
Floods Swept Ancient Nile Cities Away, Experts Says [10/18/2001]

Indeed, I read every one and loved them. Then I read his 3 volume set on the one Roman family from the beginning through 1000 years. Then I switched to a competitor who also writes about a Roman detective who is at some of the same events at Gordianus. That is the SPQR series by John Roberts.

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B003J5650W/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_d_asin_title_351_o00?ie=UTF8&psc=1

Enjoy!

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.