She may have a legal case. She had already paid for the sperm...................
She entered into a binding contract which appears to have covered the situation. And she was the party to breach. Doubt she has a case at all but she's certainly looking at $20K in liquidated damages (plus the attorney fees on both sides of the action most likely) if she wants to push it.
But, she violated the contract.
They refunded her the money for the vials. She signed a contract to not contact donor. She violated the contract
Maybe they already destroyed that sperm.
So in this case, Doctor FrankenSTEEN should send EYE-gor to get some more, and he would come back with Abby Normal’s sample.