American Idol 2014--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | 1-14-14

[advertising guy]

he didn’t make a bad one

[twin2]

Sorry GinanotJenna, but Carrie is miles better on this song.
I agree with Harry on this one.

[Clint N. Suhks]

I HATE she cut her hair. She was so much prettier with the long locks.

[Jrabbit]

Keith and Jlo pimping GinanotJenna big time

[advertising guy]

AI ain’t on here for 20 more minutes...I care less bout b ball or hockey so watchin the DUKE

[Clint N. Suhks]

I don’t know why anyone on this show does a slow song unless the producers compel them to.

Hope Pinky doesn’t fall for that trap.

[Shelayne]

Yeah. When Carrie sings this it ranges in intensity, which conveys the emotion of the song. I thought GinanotJenna just sang the whole song really, really loud, which lost quite a bit of the feel of the song.

Too bad. It’s a great song, and I think if she would have stayed truer to Carrie’s version, she would have been really good.

[silent_jonny]

GinanotJenna

Another Carrie Underwood song. "So Small". Unlike her first song, Jena's voice doesn't fit this very well ... or at all. Don't like the arrangement either.

Keith: You are such a good singer, my word. You're everything Idol is about. You're 17. This is the best journey, to watch you. It really is.

Jlo: It's like the band went away. I'm so in the song, so in the story with you. I've got goosies again.

Harry: You're basing your interpretation from her (Carrie Underwood's) interpretation. I didn't know where you were going. (someone--female--yells from the audience, "I love you Jena!") Yeah, I think a lot of people do love you ... so even though it didn't work for me, I don't think it'll really matter.

GinanotJenna says that she looks forward to the judges advice.

Harry: I think I can speak for Keith and Jen, we get the sense that you do listen.

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Mark and Just :)

[silent_jonny]

You know.... by the time this season is over.... I’m gonna be to a point that I never need to hear Jlo say anything again....

LOL

[Clint N. Suhks]

Top 3 Cowboy Movies ever, and I’m not ranking them;

The Shootist

Open Range

Unforgiven

Ture Grit and Django Unchanged 4-5.

[peggybac]

Good Lord, CJ sucks.

[Shelayne]

GET THE HOOK!

[kjam22]

This kid just can’t sing... how is he still there??

[Clint N. Suhks]

How AI found Carrie “undiscovered” is a mystery.

[Shelayne]

goooonnnnnng

[Jrabbit]

He has a “cry” in his voice....

[kjam22]

Oh yeah... I forgot.

[Shelayne]

At this point, man, you really just need to..."

SING IN TUNE!

[Jrabbit]

He’s desperate, now. Going after the sympathy vote....