Posted on 01/16/2013 5:55:19 AM PST by silent_jonny
American Idol needs to really think about bringing Pauler and Simon back next year. This has gotten out of hand.
MacArthur Park sucked big time. I don’t understand why the judges went so gaga over it. Iovine was right on. He should be a judge.
Nicky is such a camera whore and Randy is following her lead.
I had one that I liked a lot :)
No kidding.
I don't know what this is. I don't care. It's slow, old and BORING.
Minaj: I was groovin' with it with you. I'm proud of you. She interrupts her critique to praise Amber again?
Randy: You took your time with it. Another great performance. Vocal is crazy. You're settling back in now. All of us judges strongly disagree with Jimmy.
Mariah: I don't want to go on forever (but she does. She loved the song and Candice)
Keith: Are there any one hit wonders from at least the last decade? Every song choice matters. That was breezy lovely nice, but (missed out on a big moment)
Seacrest brings Iovine out on stage for damage control. How dare he criticize Amber??
Candice stands there quietly.
Jimmy explains why he was right about Amber's corny performance. Amber this. Amber that.
Candice stands there quietly.
Minaj leaves the judges' table and clomps up on stage (with Randy close behind) pretending to attack Iovine for his anti-Amber stance. But it's all done for laughs.
Candice stands there quietly.
So far Kree is sounding great on WHiter Shade of Pale.
I would have been grounded, had I got caught wearing one. Ha! I remember I borrowed my friend’s “Mood” tee shirt, that had a sticker on the front that worked like the Mood Rings, and it said, “I’m in the Mood...” My mom was not very happy with that one.
OOh, “Whiter Shade of Pale”. This should be good! The song is very haunting...
What is their definition of a one hit wonder?? This is a huge song and Procol Harem was very popular.
Nooooooo.....there is a reason these songs were one hit wonders......I hate this....Whiter Shade of Pale. STABBY!!
Yep...
I know no other song by this group. Were there other hits?
So far all of the one hit wonders were originally sung by white boys LMAO! (coincidence? With THIS panel of judges? I think not!!)
I really do not like how the Ho refers to Kree as her wife. Barf. And then Kreedom.
Oh, please make her just go away.
Kree is set up to drop out. Minaj just gave her notice.
So nasty! Idol really hit the gutter when they put her on the panel...
This “FAMILY HOUR” program has been pushing the gay agenda for at LEAST 6 seasons. I am sick to death of it!!!!!!
I was too young when they first began so I don’t remember names of songs but they produced like 8 or 9 albums.
I don’t know what they were thinking—maybe thought her catfights with Mariah would make good TV.
They were wrong. It sucks.
(Sorry, Momsy, for the “sucks” ;^) )
Wearing all black, sings Percy Sledge's "A Whiter Shade of Pale". Wish she chose a more exciting song, but this is still great.
Randy: You know what will never be your problem? Singing! You can flat out sing! You sang you're face off. You redeemed yourself.
Mariah: A great artist A great song will always accentuate it and you just did.
Keith: (complains Kree has picked too many "middle-ground" songs lately)
Minaj: Watch how you talkin' to my wife, Keef. I ain't gonna have that too many times. (to Kree) Do I believe that will keep you out of the bottom two tomorrow night? No. Something inside of you seems to be dimming a little bit. But if you leave tomorrow, I know you can put out a multi-platinum album.
Seacrest flitters in, says that song means a lot to you personally, doesn't it?
Kree: I opened for Percy Sledge when I was 8.
Only ten minutes left for a performance and a recap—the judges’ comments should be very short. I hope.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.