American Idol 2013--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 16, 2013

[patriotspride]

I think she’s a pretty sharp cookie.

---

As the show has progressed she has shown to be the “ adult” at the table.

[silent_jonny]

Good morning, J!! :)

[ken5050]

The final four should all be female..

Candace is Jennifer Hudson 2.0 Jenny Craig can't wait to sign her up

Are ANY of the guys straight?

Now that FR is fixed and super fast..can Sparkleez be far behind?

Minaj was very "dark" tonight...it's getting beyond weird..wonder if the producers read her the riot act..or put vodka in her Coke ..

[silent_jonny]

Whenever these singers look so intently into the camera....all I think of is the years they spent tying up the bathroom, singing into the mirror with their hair brush or toothbrush as the mic

"What the hell are you doing in the bathroom all day and night? Why don't you get out of there and give someone else a chance?"

[CAluvdubya]

Oh. So she is just late?
Tardy Ho.
Overslept Ho. Unprepared Ho. Forgot it was Wednesday Ho.

Oh h*ll, just HO! I was so disappointed that they woke her from her drug induced stupor to come to the show.

My favorite part is when the camerman pulls back so I can watch the looks Mariah gives when the Hooded Ho speaks!

Hubby Googled AI & Nikki.....whoa! Everyone hates her!

[CounterCounterCulture]

My rankings

Girls
1 (tie) - Kree
1 (tie) - Candice
3 - Angie (was my favorite coming out of "Hollywood Week", but Candice and Kree have been great)
4 - Amber
5 - Janelle (I like her personally, and it's good to have a country girl, but just doesn't come close to the others in nailing the songs)

Guys
Devin has become my favorite (seems most relaxed and natural). Curtis is starting to bore me big-time. Burnell is okay. Paul is okay but obviously fruity. Lazaro is by far the weakest singer and if he didn't have the stutter to endear him with the crowd, he wouldn't have been anywhere near the Top 40.

[Netizen]

I think your line up is pretty accurate. I would put Kree slightly ahead of Candice. Jimmy told Kree to be careful to not over sing. Good advice for all of them including Candice. jmo

[floriduh voter]

I luv Amber Holcomb's voice. She has mad skills. Angie has great talent and stage presence and Candace is a throwback to the great jazz singers if she wanted to go that route. The country girls are not as talented as Carrie Underwood. The guys - they can all go home for all I care. It's either karaoke or gospel - and they all look awkward on stage.

The cable company forgot to unhook my cable on Monday so I have free cable last night and tonight. I'll be downstairs tonight watching AI on my tiny tv that's still hooked up to cable.

I kept it plugged in so MY DUCK could watch animal planet. His favorite is to watch the dog rescue shows. When the dogs wag their tails, Les wags his.

Be back to comment on tonight's elims later on. HAVE FUN AI, HOLDOUTS. This year the singing is okay but I think the show FORMAT is tired and they should change the show format to keep it fresh.

We all know what Ryan's gonna do and say, we know the format after all these years. The only hope and change I'd like is AI's format. Tweak, please. Bye.

[floriduh voter]

Kree is very manly imo. I don’t know how she can change that but the stylist isn’t picking up on that. If Kree can find her feminine side, maybe but she’s not in my top three.

[floriduh voter]

Agree to disagree w/me. Kree imo is not very girly. They need to style her cuz she won’t get any votes for her stage presence/appearance. The woman in her isn’t showing up on stage. IMHO. Very plain and not graceful.

[floriduh voter]

My favorite moment last night was when Keith Urban asked Lazario something about his technique. Regrets, Keith had a few.....

[floriduh voter]

Pope Iovine of the Oversingers.

[patriotspride]

Good list. Slight tweak on 1,2,3

Kree

Angie

Candice

Amber

Janelle

Agree on Devin. Too bad the rest of the guys can’t go home tonight LOL

[patriotspride]

Pope Iovine of the Oversingers.

---

Good one. Took me another read to catch the witty “ Oversingers” LOL

[silent_jonny]

Well crap. FR is fast, but we’re back to the “I can only see the first 14 posts” thing again.

[silent_jonny]

Now I can see the posts.

[MagUSNRET]

Me too...I tried to fix it, but I cant..Oh well...at least I can find this thread :-)

[patriotspride]

Evening Jonny.

All

I’ll go out on a limb and predict a guy goes home....... Ha Ha Ha.....

[silent_jonny]

The Results Show

Click here for pics & bios of the Top 10

Click here for pics & bios of the Top 20

As always, if you want on or off this ping list, just let me know :)

[silent_jonny]

You did make it, lol :)

Francis sounds too woosy-like for the job he has to do.

I agree.