American Idol 2013--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 16, 2013

[Yaelle]

Grrrreat info,Jonny! Hope you guys back east are having fun. Will watch the show and come do the janitorial work after your party! I’ve missed all of you.

And I loved the Voice this season and thought you all would too. Anyone else watch it? Adam and Blake are so much fun!

I hope the Dawg is still a judge.

[silent_jonny]

“Affirmative Ashton”—I wish she had stayed on the show just so we could keep using that name :)

[silent_jonny]

Did Mama outside not say her son could really sing? It seems like she avoided the answer.

"He ... He tries really hard."

[skateman]

It’s good to be back!

[skateman]

It’s good to be back!

[skateman]

Tag line change

[Netizen]

Hi all. :)

[Yaelle]

Oh no, Randy (Jackson was in Journey) is the bad cop!

---

Yes, and instead of “you sound like two cats being thrown from a tall building,” it’s “You’re bad!”

Did you know that Randy sold 100 million records as a producer and artist?

[Yaelle]

So they tell the contestants “ wow, you are great! Go sing it that way for the judges”? That’s kinda sad.

[Netizen]

Oh my heavens!!! Plastic pelvic thrusts....

You guys are killing me! LOL

[Fledermaus]

The only porn star I know that sings.

[Yaelle]

WOAH, 36 minutes in, we get the cancer story....I had 32 minutes.....What do I win???????????? ;-)

---

A matching amputation? An afternoon of chemo?

[Netizen]

OMG OMG OMG LMAO! Did you hear that guys pants SKRUNCH/SQUEAK every time he moved? LMAO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

What a visual! :)

[Yaelle]

Mariah calls herself black but one grandparent was black, one was Latino, two were white.

[Sir_Ed]

Jonny!!!! It’s SO nice to see you again!

I hate to say it, but AI is one of my guilty pleasures and I’ve followed every Silent Jonny AI thread since the beginning.

Thanks!

Ed

[patriotspride]

And I loved the Voice this season and thought you all would too. Anyone else watch it? Adam and Blake are so much fun!

---

Really liked it this year. The judges have to select real talent as they are the coaches and the show is also about them winning.

Also less drama, and bad performers. The people they allow into the contest can sing .

Enjoyed the final 3 greatly. Each had their own style , and to me any of them would beat many of the past Idol winners.

Blake and Adam are the heart of the show. C Lo should join Nicki in wardrobe selection. Christina is ok, and certainly better than J Lo as a judge.

Good to see you on the thread.

[commish]

Well I have to say I was actually OK with the new panel. Nikki actually sounded knowledgable about the craft at times, and was fairly well spoken and very courteous to the contestants.

Kieth Urban was good, but quite reserved, and at times Mariah looked like she was bored with everything.

I did ickup a little on what is probably fueling a lot of the ‘conflict’ between Mariah and Nikki — basically Jealousy. The vast majority of the contestants fawned over Mariah, and you could see Nikki visible bristle every time a contestant went “OMG I can’t believe I am in the same room with Mariah Carey”

[silent_jonny]

You gotta admit it was dang funny when a near-adult told her “I went to your camp when I was a kid!”

LOL, and the girl said she's 28 now. Bet that made Carey feel awesome.

[silent_jonny]

Plastic pelvic thrusts....

Haha!

[silent_jonny]

At first I thought Barry let Moochelle out for the night...

Rofl!