Posted on 01/16/2013 5:55:19 AM PST by silent_jonny
These contestants have NO imagination! If I were her, I would have been on stage singing “Shes got legs......she knows how to use them!”
I thought this one was the best so far...
Yes! She drives me up the wall with that stupid baby voice. She will never grow up with her parents doing everything for her.
She sings Fergie's "Big Girls Don't Cry". And she's doing a pretty good job with it. Nice tone in her voice--minus some pitch issues on a couple of big notes.
Keith: You look fantastic! I can really hear your personality. I wish it allowed you to soar more at the end. Vibrato was so beautiful.
Minaj: You know what I love about you? Your humility. Really sweet and endearing. Loved the Fergie song for you. I just overall love you.
Randy: Loved the vibrato too. Got a little bit of the Rhianna vibe. Something very current and infectious about you.
Mariah: We've gotten a chance to see your versatility. You so obviously have multi-platinum potential. You could be someone very big in the industry. Keep doing it.
Perhaps I am jaded...or perhaps I have become deaf after Joanettes yelping...but thusfar, I do not think any of them have sounded “American Idol” worthy...but a few of them do have the good sense to dress such that our attention is drawn away from their voicew and onto their legs. (Zoanette too, but for all the WRONG reasons) LOL
So far, the country gal has the strongest voice and she’s on key. What a concept.
Now this is an interesting version of this song... no telling what the judges are going to think....
I agree. The last girl was very pretty, but her song was meh and this girl is good, but boring as hell. Another poor song choice.
I didn’t think it was boring. I’ll need to listen back after the show... but she took a classic Elvis song and turned it into a country version. I thought that in and of itself was interesting :) I thought she did good too...
But the judges went crazy for it? Okay.
Zoanette exxcluded....I think one of the big problems may be that these gals are WAY too interested in looking cute/sexy on TV, rather than concentrating on singing
She reminds everyone that she was almost sent home last week. (strike one)
She sings a song about her dreams not coming true. (strike two)
It's Elvis' "If I Can Dream". And it's actually pretty good, and a good song for her. (base hit!)
Keith: I loved that bay-bee. Classic Country voice. Great song. Great performance.
Minaj: (fake Southern accent) That's my girl. You're back. You are a little marshmallow that I wanna eat. Best vocal of the night so far. I think sky's the limit for you, I really do.
Randy: I like the old throwback thing in your voice. I wish someone would make a traditional Patsy Cline record. A lot of people want that. You can give them that.
Mariah: You made the crowd happy. You did what you came to do. So glad America gets a chance to vote tonight because you have a very "America's sweetheart" quality about you.
Hi, Peggy! :)
I agree. The last girl was very pretty, but her song was meh and this girl is good, but boring as hell. Another poor song choice.
The judges have hyped and rewarded mediocrity by selecting Zonnette . anyone else sounds better by default but certainly not great compared to past season final 10 ‘s
What is with all the chicks wearing wigs this season? Is it Cancer Drama year? Alopecia week? DO they not know how to wash and style REAL hair? ENquiring minds want to know.
Most Elvis songs were 2 steps away from a country song.
Why are they all singing these pokey, slow songs? Except the Lioness Queen...
Fishy Fishy. Makes up for Zonnette .........
agreed. Certainly in chord progression etc. Rockabilly etc.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.