American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[RummyChick]

I laughed and laughed at Smokey singing Tears of Clown while his face isn’t moving

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0EwMvngRtUk

He almost looked like he is reading it off a teleprompter

[freedumb2003]

>>He has just enough DIVA in him to make me shudder<<

I can see him as the star in “Rent”

He really is good, but is it THAT KIND of good is the question...

[patriotspride]

Judges wish

Joshua - Jessica Finale

[kjam22]

So Phillip to do a Dave Matthews song? LOL... might as well just go with the critics I guess....

[silent_jonny]

Joshua Ledet
(2nd Song)

What is this? "Ready For Love" by India Arie. Dreary. His voice is good though, and not as annoying as it has been tonight.

Randy: I don't even know what to say anymore. Another unbelievable performance. So spot on. So beyond your age. This is what it's about. Crazy good!

J-Lo: That was transcendant. You snap us right into reality (?). Such a gift.

Steven: I'm snapped into reality by the way you sing. I hope your label finds some good songs for you because you'll be off to the moon.

[freedumb2003]

They both look like:

[silent_jonny]

Hi, Shelayne! Aw

if he says anything particularly snarky, I will share. :^D

LOL, please do :)

[carmody]

I think she has a lot of potential. The judges nit-pick Holly to tears. And they’ve been doing it for weeks now which has shaken her confidence. To me, it seems intentional and personal. I think it’s not about her singing. They don’t like her personally.

[Poser]

I’d bring out the gaydar meter, but it’s just too obvious. The meter would just be pegged all the time.

[Netizen]

Do you think they might try to get Reba for the finale if Skylar makes it and I think she will.

[Mark was here]

Hi Jonny,

Nice comment on the ping, been tied up going thru a big stack of old unlabeled cd’s.

Had the show on, the Queen stuff was cool, the judges and the contestants, predictable...

[silent_jonny]

Like a sniper—ROFL!

[MagUSNRET]

I think that would be BRILLIANT! ERGO...it will never happen ;-) LOL

[Poser]

This chick should be singing Piece of My Heart. She keeps picking boring songs. Gone this week.

[freedumb2003]

This is... strange.

Not showing off her singing. More her emoting.

[RummyChick]

I finally figured Randy out..he is trying to dress like an updated Temptations

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8H65QEFjj-g

[freedumb2003]

>>Nice comment on the ping, been tied up going thru a big stack of old unlabeled cd’s.<<

What is this “CD” of which you speak?

[patriotspride]

This chick should be singing Piece of My Heart. She keeps picking boring songs. Gone this week.

---

Would have been a great choice for her style.

[MagUSNRET]

I think of Randys recent look as more of something from the Pedophile Pimp collection.
(He looks like a damned idiot)

[Netizen]

Yeah its just weird. I think too many celebs are having too much surgery. Some of the ones that are aging gracefully looks so much better than their plastic counterparts.