American Idol 2012--Live Thread

americanidol.com ^ | January 18, 2012

[silent_jonny]

Brielle Von Hugel

She sings "Sitting On The Dock Of The Bay". A lot of flat notes. Not good enough.

Steven: You got a great sense of the blues. Well done!

J-Lo: You are a true performer. You eat-it-up. You understand what it is to entertain.

Randy: When you got into your sweet spot vocally, I was like YO. You surprised me. A little Janis Joplin in there?

What song were they listening to?

[peggybac]

http://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/lea-michele-hooking-up-with-glee-costar-cory-monteith-2012292

[Netizen]

I didn’t care for that either.

[retrokitten]

No kidding. Out loud I yelled, “WHAT??” when Steven said she ‘knew the blues’. I mean, really?? She started out at least a key too low and it never got better.

Not to mention she looked she was having a very aggressive hemorrhoids attack.

[stylecouncilor]

[stylecouncilor]

[Fawn]

Jonny, in your photo...Steve Tyler looks like Joan Rivers to me....

[peggybac]

From Vote for the Worst:

Spoilers for the Top 24 Girls (With Terrible Adele Covers)
Posted by thefunnystone on Wednesday, February 29, 2012 at 3:43 PM EST
Tags:

American Idol Updates
Spoilers

Share: ShareThis

@idolspoilers is tweeting some of the song spoilers. Here’s what he’s said so far:

Brielle Von Hugel is singing “Sittin on the Dock of the Bay” (stupid choice)

Chelsea Sorrell is doing a Carrie Underwood song (duh)

Erika Van Pelt is doing “What About Love” by Heart (boring choice)

Haley Johnsen is doing “Sweet Dreams” (train wreck potential)

Hollie Cavanagh is doing “Reflection” by Christina Aguilera (boring choice)

Jessica Sanchez is doing a song by Jennifer Hudson (probably a boring ballad)

Elise Testone and Jen Hirsh are doing the same Adele song (kill me now...)

This night is looking like a snoozefest. Ladies, what did I say about doing Adele songs? I can’t take it. I just can’t take it! Then again, Eben did an Adele song and it was classicly terrible. But knowing those 2, they’ll be boring as always.

Season 11 is the season of terrible Adele covers. Thank god she’s only had like 3 songs so we’ll run out soon.

[silent_jonny]

LOL—a rare Peggy gif :)

[Shelayne]

Wait.. what?

There is a FB group for THIS group??

[silent_jonny]

Brielle talks about her self in third-person.

Brielle likes her chicken spicy.

[retrokitten]

I have some great Peggy gifs, but I never get the chance to use them!

[Fawn]

I think this girl will be one of the top 3....Haley

[maggief]

“Brielle talks about her self in third-person.”

maggief no like Brielle.

[MagUSNRET]

OK...let me be the first to recommend that ADELE songs be added to our current Michael jackson, Whitney Houston “Do Not EVER Sing these on AI” list.

[twin2]

Another sequined rack on stage

[retrokitten]

No facebook group. Just a few of us who are friends here are friends there and had a confab on Jonny’s wall. It was a little strange to address everyone as their actual name instead of their screen name. LOL

[freedumb2003]

I have no idea who Adele is and why she rates a first name only moniker...

[MagUSNRET]

Ever notice Santorum speaks in the third person a great deal also? Listen to him speak sometime...more than once, I cocked my head ALA the RCA Victor dog, when he was speaking...in that “WTF?” look....

[twin2]

I feel like we get to go back behind the curtain and be as snarky as we want again:)