American Idol 2011--Live Thread II

americanidol.com ^ | April 5, 2011

[silent_jonny]

In Memory of Bahbah and Carolinamom

[peggybac]

I MISS SIMON!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[retrokitten]

I think of you when I see this KungFoo Panda commercial:)

Hahahaha! Is it cause I share the same shape as the panda? ;-)

[RummyChick]

I never thought I would ever say this..but I feel sorry for her finding out the maid was pregnant at the same time as her and her husband was the father.

[Nea Wood]

How are they handling the naughty words in the song? Just curious.

[Miss Didi]

I remember when Alanis performed this song in Italy at the San Remo Music Fest...all the Italians were smiling swaying back and forth to the music without a clue on the lyrics.

So Haley got the pimp spot I guess.

[peggybac]

I’m glad this sucky song was the last of the night.

[MagUSNRET]

(the only way this chick got as far as she did, is because SIMON is gone!)

[Lil'freeper]

Pickler II Round 1: Slow down enough to actually sing the words, mebbe?
Round 2: Not too shabby. The makeup on the legs was a nice touch. The shimmer dust was just perfection.
Round 3: Nothing quite like a little steel guitar and a little Crystal Gayle dress.

Screaming Mimi Round 1: The singing was meh, but I really dig her hair. Tho, not sure a rubberized flapper dress is the best way to make a good impression.
Round 2: Stevie Nicks was a great choice. The fan blowing on her during the song was not. The whole thing turned into a screechy wind-blown mess.
Round 3: The song was a good choice on paper, but the execution was all over the place. (Also, this is a pretty racy selection for a family show like AI…)

Scottay Round 2: Liked it. He's so white picket fence and apple pie.
Round 3: Great song choice. I love to hear him just sing.

Judges Bunch of useless blah blah blah

Old Navy Flip flop dresses for the WIN!!!

And also -- Mad Max Beyonce 2012. Worse things could happen to the Pres. race.

[retrokitten]

But she’s in it to win it! :-\

[ChicagoConservative27]

I thought you where skinny mini?

[kjam22]

Still think this comes down to Lauren or Haley... Scotty gets left behind tonight

[ChicagoConservative27]

Were not where.

[Wyatt's Torch]

Ditto. She sang the Zeppelin song well (perfect arrangement). Rhiannon was okay. The Alanis song was not good. Scotty was best overall but it mightnbe a “tallest midget” scenario.

[ChicagoConservative27]

Ryan would love it if Scotty got left behind.

[Netizen]

She changed them

[VampireStateNY]

She sang “would she go down *with* you *to* the theater”. I think I blocked out everything else. >_<

[peggybac]

Vote For The Worst picked Haley!

[Miss Didi]

Scotty’s going home tonight, I think.

[Wyatt's Torch]

She sang the same lyrics that Crystal did last year.

[Netizen]

What did you think of Scotty’s first song?