Posted on 01/12/2009 5:57:19 AM PST by silent_jonny
OMG! Cacey’s sooooo bad.
Uh oh...Paula whipped out, “You are beautiful!”
IOW...YOU SUCK
Ewww! Somegayyuck!
You know you’re in trouble when Paula starts off talking about how pretty you are.....
OK, let’s discuss the irony of Paula saying “your phrasing was weird” Am I the only one that is having flashbacks to Paula blithering and bumbling over her words after a few sips of her “coke”?
>>Someone call the COPS! There has to be a noise ordinance somewhere. P.U.
Or at least THE POLICE!!!
My kitty love that song!
LMAO!
Creepy old men and teen boys will vote for her.
I must admit that I don’t get why her song choice was so bad.
I love getting my ass whipped too.
Eh gad, Casey's mother needs support garments.
imho,mkay...
She danced a little like Elaine of Seinfeld
I don’t think the choice was that bad. Sting isn’t exactly who I think of when I think, “Dynamic Singer.”
That's such a train wreck...and I smeared my nail just to type it wrong.
LOL! Why do they ALWAYS say that?? If that was fun....oh boy!
for once Paula’s comments to Casey were dead on
as soon as I heard it was a Police song I knew it was gonna suck donkey b@lls
Casey chooses "Everything She Does Is Magic" by the Police.
Thumbs DOWN. She's flat and off key. But, bless her heart, she thinks she's awesome.
Randy: Uhhhhhh, ooooh, that was not good for me. Weirdly karaoke.
Kara: Everything about that was wrong. [She sings with Randy: "Everything about that was wrong". That was unnecessary] You're such a beautiful girl, but you picked the Police!? Nobody goes near the songs. So overdone. I had such high hopes for you.
Paula: Picking that song ... there was no connection ... your phrasing was weird [LOL! that coming from Paula]
Simon: The singing was just atrocious. You could not have picked a worse song. Karaoke. You get one massive opportunity and you threw it away.
Sheesh, Casey's mom tries to take over the show. "You rocked the stage!" she says loudly. "Vote for Casey!"
Seacrest: Well maybe she'll get another chance next week.
No, not the way Idol has screwed this up.
Typo, but a fitting one.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.