Posted on 03/25/2008 5:58:52 AM PDT by silent_jonny
I disagree with the judges. I thought David C. was fantastic and Syesha hit it out of the park.
Let’s just hope he does not break out into “Tessie” in some future show. I would hate to soil the carpet.
“David A. is not the bomb.”
You’re right. Paula’s bombed!
I agree-Simon is spot on with his assessments so far.
I love how she gave negative criticism to a song he didn’t sing.
Simon appears to be the only one that doesnt have a tin ear, or be on mood altering drugs..
I agree with Simon the vast majority of the time....and Im not even a Brit ;-)
Paula just proved to the world that this show is SCRIPTED and very likely rigged.
She’s so drunk she read off the script a critique of Jason’s second song before he even sung it!
Simon is the only judge I really pay attention to his remarks. Paula is a complete waste, and Randy knows only “dog”.
She's wearing a slinky purple dress tonight.
She sings "Hello". A very simple performance, but beautiful. The best so far tonight.
Now we hear the judges, but they have to give a very fast group judgement (what?). It's like they're reading a grocery list. Very sloppy and confusing. This wasn't thought out very well at all.
Paula get's confused--she thinks Cook has already performed twice, lol
Seacrest: You're seeing into the future.
Paula: This is hard!
Simon: (to the singers) You're all lucky you get to do two songs tonight. You're the top five. You've got to raise the bar. (I agree) Archuleta, amateurish. David Cook, just barely above average. Brooke, a nightmare.
Hey everyone - sorry I’m late - got rid of my “gas guzzling” pc-incorrect 4Runner today - got a fire engine red Camry - and love it.....that being said - I LOVE NEIL DIAMOND - have seen him over 20 times in my short (??!!??) lifetime - in fact going to DC and Houston in Aug to see him in concert....and quite frankly NONE of these five did any justice to my Neil’s songs in the first round!!!
She's wearing a slinky purple dress tonight.
She sings "Hello". A very simple performance, but beautiful. The best so far tonight.
Now we hear the judges, but they have to give a very fast group judgement (what?). It's like they're reading a grocery list. Very sloppy and confusing. This wasn't thought out very well at all.
Paula get's confused--she thinks Cook has already performed twice, lol
Seacrest: You're seeing into the future.
Paula: This is hard!
Simon: (to the singers) You're all lucky you get to do two songs tonight. You're the top five. You've got to raise the bar. (I agree) Archuleta, amateurish. David Cook, just barely above average. Brooke, a nightmare.
DAWG....and BOMB
I love the Brits. Ever since I saw “Love, Actually” I’ve wanted to go to London for Christmas.
That was such a fabulous red dress.
Toke boy... BORING!!!!!
ROTFLMAO!!! OMG. That is awesome.
Oh, Dreads, Dreads, Dreads...this is so not you!
They all look bored tonight.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.