Posted on 12/04/2024 2:48:34 PM PST by DFG
Thank God for people like Samuel Alito, unafraid to tell the truth at all costs.
Today, the Supreme Court is hearing arguments regarding Tennessee's ban on transgender surgeries for kids, and the ACLU sent Chase Strangio, a woman with a beard, to argue that even two-year-olds should be castrated.
(No word yet on whether Chase Strangio is still breathing after that encounter with logic.)
Civil rights laws and the Constitution prohibit discrimination of people based on immutable, unchangeable characteristics. You can't discriminate against black people because they were born with more melanated skin, for example.
Alito simply points out that trans ideology invents a new category called "gender" that is, by their expressed definition, "fluid."The wokies say it can be changed, sometimes by the minute! It's the exact opposite of immutable.
Here's the audio (nothing will prepare you for the trans lawyer's helium voice).
(Excerpt) Read more at notthebee.com ...
When your whole argument is BS then logic tends to trip you up.
They are just making it up as they go along
Brilliant and concise by Justice Alito. No long-winded argument. More words don’t necessarily make for a better debate or discussion.
Had to Google it to be sure. From Cambridge:
not changing, or unable to be changed: an immutable law. Some people regard grammar as an immutable set of rules.
Probably many voters were turned off by the gender stuff. Amazing that a tiny percent of people influence millions to accommodate them. Gay, trans and others are a small number.
Sad stories like the little boy in maybe 2nd grade who told his parents the teacher forced him and the others to imagine if they were a girl and to act like it for a day in class and how it feels to be a girl. Soooooooo sick.
And an article I read in Ms Magazine. A progressive feminist mother recalled putting the boy type toys at the bottom of the toy chest and getting her little son to play with dolls and so on like a girl.
“But he kept digging down into the toy chest after she left the room and getting the ball and working on his catching skills anyway.”
lgBtq gives it away right out of the box
They’ll now alter the definition of immutable the way they did tried to do with vaccine.
Subjectivism is the most cruel form of absolutism.
Me too :)
Now it makes sense.
I wonder what the other judges had to say?
Dang it. I probably have to peruse the other posts to find out.
I remember when bearded women were sideshow freaks at the circus. Now they are appearing before the Supreme Court. We’ve come a long way.
My question to the attorney:
“Should a child be allowed to get a big tattoo on their face?”
Why not?
There is the reason not to mutilate their gender chemically or otherwise.
One brilliant mind on a Biden committee....said gender has no bounds...woof woof...moo moo...cluck cluck...
He was going a little easy, but he could see that this lawyer’s not all there
“Had to Google it to be sure.”
Or attend Theology class in seminary. One of the attributes of God.
We are living in the days of Lot. The only way a two-year-old boy would think he is a girl, is if the parents told him so.
Logic is anathema to leftists.
It is a pity that it takes a SCOTUS judge to argue this point.
Two year olds dob’t know much of anything yet.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.