Posted on 11/16/2018 4:00:44 AM PST by thefactor
As a police officer and soldier I was relatively embarrassed when I thought of posting this question/thread, but I told myself to get over it and ask for help from people who know.
Bottom Line Up Front: I want a 9mm "pistol" utilizing the AR platform. Commonly referred to as an AR-9. My question is, should I buy one or should I undertake the task of building one?
Although I have significant experience with many types of firearms, I have no experience "building" a firearm by ordering parts from different companies and assembling them. I have done a significant amount of research on this subject via the internet as well as seeking out and speaking to experts. The problem is, everyone has different advice that seems to contradict what others have said. So I'm coming here.
Should I just spend the few extra hundred bucks and get a complete weapon that fits all my expectations, or should I undertake the task of building one?
I am looking for a short-barreled (around a 5" barrel) 9mm "pistol" that takes Glock mags.
I get the sarcasm, but the longer barrels of these firearms do increase the pressures and create more lift and twist. When this is the case, I would rather just have a rifle and a rifle round at that point and keep the handgun rounds in handguns that can be holstered.
Amen
PSA sells 9mm AR-15 pistols & rifles at a price that would be difficult to beat buying individual parts. You can also buy a 9mm lower and complete upper from PSA and save a little over cost of a complete firearm (less tax).
9mm ARs use recoil rather than gas to cycle the action so you need to have right weight buffer.
I have a PSA 9mm pistol. It’s worked well with no issues. I see it as mostly a range toy - a 556 pistol is much more effective for self defense.
“It wont be loud, it wont be inaccurate and it will be a fun toy.”
Fun toy I can understand, but I don’t know why I would need one of these if I already have a rife and a sidearm.
I bought an ar pistol, and I’m really glad i did. it’s now my home defense weapon because it handles so well in tight spaces.
Call it a prejudice, but I believe in the .45 ACP.
This isn’t what you are looking for but if i were you, I’d go with a Ruger PC carbine 9mm. It can accept most Ruger and Glock magazines, is about 1/3 the cost of what you pictured and doesn’t have that scary military look.
As do I.
When it comes to feral dogs, most of which are pitbulls, I would never carry anything less. Dogs don’t understand the “BANG” like humans do, and they don’t understand that they should drop when they catch a bullet. They keep charging. Need a bullet that literally severs tendons and muscle tissue and physically shuts them down.
I carry .40 now, but I carried .45 specifically for the reason it was invented : drug-fueled natives who didn’t stop when they were shot.
Had a black bear in our neighborhood a few weeks ago.
Worse, I’ve been seeing Mexicans with obvious military training around town with increasing frequency.
I don't know jack about AR's myself, but now that this thread is up to 80+ replies and almost all of it good opinions, may I ax:
In a weapon of this type, why not a 10mm? Just axin'.
I was going to suggest the same
PC 9 Carbine,,,
I have yet to Shoot one but the
Heft of the Rifle dictates
A fine piece of Ruger Engineering!
I get 9mm ammo for free.
Well that’s a sweet deal.
A small 9mm pistol for EDC, a full size, maybe, 9mm pistol for home defense along with a Ruger PC 9 carbine and one would be set. I had thought of going that route but as you may be able to tell by my name, I went with .38 Special.
I had similar questions.
Why would a Vet/LEO need to throw this out there, here? Not that there arent extremely knowledgeable people here; Surely such a person would at least know fellow members of his/her professional community to ask, not to mention the professional armorers of said profession.
.38/.357,,,
A lot of flexabity there,
Snub nose,
Six inch Magnum and
A Lever Action Winchester.
It’s my favorite round.
Build it. Get one of the AAOrd 80% uppers, already set up for the Glock magazines. My sweetie likes the Glock platform, which doesn't fit my hand well, so she went with a 7" barrel AR on an AAOI lower.
easy build! And the last roiund holdopen is already installed: AAO Glock lower.
The Factor’s a long-time Freeper who’s completely trustworthy.
Sometime’s a cigar is just a cigar.
Ed
You’d be surprised.
I went to a shooting range in Bay Ridge, Brooklyn and you’d’ve thought you were in one of the free states!
People treating guns as tools, not a horrid, evil device...so, there ARE New Yorkers who aren’t part of the commie mindset.
Ed
A friend of mine just moved from the Gold Coast, L.I. to a small town in Tennessee...he LOVES living in a free state!
Good luck to you in your retirement!
Ed
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.