I’m sure a big part is cultural. I also believe some concerns for idolatry are valid. Not in the USA, perhaps. But in the Philippines? I’ve got family from there. And I’ve heard that if I wanted my prayers answered, then as a military guy, surely I know to follow the chain of command...
Not saying that is good Catholic theology. But I can see where the Reformation wanted to make some changes.
For the church in question, I’d have told the “artist” his art is poor and needs to be removed if only for that reason. I’m not real good at subtlety. All the local leaders needed to say was that the large majority of the members wanted a different look. We’re trying to get enough money to change the carpet in our sanctuary. It isn’t worn out. Completely. But a number of members just want new carpet. Nothing wrong with that. No reason needs to be given other than, “We wanted...”
Good point there. No need to “theologize” taste. “We don’t want that statue because we’re going for a different look” -— that’s all they’d have needed to say.
This is interesting.
Just WHAT does this chain look like?
Can you post an organizational chart?