Judging non-Catholics

OSV.com ^ | 08-17-16 | Msgr. Charles Pope

[daniel1212]

I disagree with your analysis. And you disagree with a principal Catholic doctrine that has passed down through the Catholic faith that was established by Jesus Christ. So I accept the words of Jesus and not your comments.

Which is more or mere argument by question-begging assertion, which is the very things that was refuted, and remains so despite your cultic, self-comforting soliloquy.

[Elsie]

But you had no problem castigating me over a post that wasn't directed at *you*...

That's what we do on FR.

Point out things that might have been missed while looking in the mirror.

---

#149. Please show me the Official Catholic teaching for this. Or are you projecting *your* beliefs as those of the Roman Catholic Church? (You probably shouldn't answer, as you'll only make a fool of yourself)

[ADSUM]

They weren’t refuted.

Just your rambling opinion.

[af_vet_1981]

Indeed, as there is no contention that this was addressed to believers, but who can fall away, (Gal. 5:1-4; Heb. 3:12; 10:38) and only location condition of any unfaithful servant is with the lost, with the latter two dealing with the degree of punishment. It is up to you to prove that this refers to purgatory. Just accept that this text does not teach that.

Neither is the word believers in the text. This is about servants, friends, and a flock. It is up to me to believe His teaching and obey it. The teaching clearly admits different levels of reward and punishment among His servants and friends. The Apostle Peter proceeds to admit us into the room, as it were, with his question. Proof texts are not the issue; after all these centuries there should be no divisions if proof texts were the solution. Obedience is the issue; this is something each one of us must do; may we have a perpetual fear and love of His Holy Name.

[Elsie]

But the FULLNESS OF THE TRUTH. is found only in the RCC.

This is as an inaccurate a statement as the one that the SLC brand of MormonISM makes - found on this plaque in Temple Square:

 

 

 

[Elsie]

This IS a fine kettle of fish!

[Elsie]

All I need to do is believe and obey everything the Messiah said according to the teachings of the Roman Catholic Church to the best of my understanding.

[Elsie]

If arrogance or pride or ignorance or inability to grasp or pure evil, whatever, God will judge.

HMMMmmm...

You seem to have left out COMMON SENSE in your list.

[Elsie]

And an echo still ripples later on...

[Elsie]

Please read my original post.

What post?

All I see are your current tagline repeated over and over.

[Elsie]

Verses 28 and 29?

[Elsie]

There are only the ecumenical councils which teachings on faith and morals ratified by Pope and two Ex Cathedra statements which constitute infallible teachings.

"One indeed is the universal Church of the faithful, outside which no one at all is saved, in which the priest himself is the sacrifice, Jesus Christ, whose body and blood are truly contained in the sacrament of the altar under the species of bread and wine; the bread (changed) into His body by the divine power of transubstantiation, and the wine into the blood, so that to accomplish the mystery of unity we ourselves receive from His (nature) what He Himself received from ours."

--Pope Innocent III and Lateran Council IV (A.D. 1215

---

Lots of misunderstandings on FR.

There is a lot of understanding; too!

[Resettozero]

They weren’t refuted. Just your rambling opinion.

What is the way God has prepared for man to be saved?

Secondly, is there are way for a non-Catholic sinner to know that he or she has been permanently reconciled to God that does not entail joining only the Roman Catholic church and giving alms to it?

Sincere questions for you or any Catholic reading this thread.

R2z

[Elsie]

Your Old Testament quotes have no bearing.

I'll bet you'd NOT say this to Jesus!!

Or His mom; either!!

[Elsie]

A miraculous change occurs ...

No; it does not.

All the hoping, wishing and incorrect teaching will never change this fact.

[Elsie]

And you disagree with a principal Catholic doctrine that has passed down through the Catholic faith that was established by Jesus Christ.

You guys keep saying this; and yet are SILENT on the FACT; that if this WERE true; then you've got some 'splaining to do Lucy; about the seven FAILED Catholic churches in Asia that the angel told John to write to.

[MHGinTN]

Without Magic Thinking, Rome would have no power.

[Elsie]

I applaud muscular Catholicism....,they kept Islam at bay and preserved traditions and knowledge and history....hat tip for that

"Who else WAS there?" as they are wont to say over and over again.

They'd best be putting on their big boy pants once again; instead of going around sniffing the Koran.

(Did that last statement please those that say we was NOT kissing it?)

[infool7]

Why don’t you run and hide under the mods skirt, I’ll call a waaambulance for you.

[Elsie]

TMS!!!!

Too many sillybulls!