Posted on 08/22/2011 7:47:51 AM PDT by markomalley
The rector of the Cathedral of Sts. Simon and Jude in Phoenix has decided [3]to only allow boys to be altar servers at Mass. The Rev. John Lankeit said the decision was his alone, not that of Bishop Thomas Olmsted. Lankeit cited the historic connection between altar boys and vocations.
The decision is regrettable from every angle. There may be an historic connection between boys being altar servers and some of those boys going on to be priests. Hard to tell. There was also an historical connection between maleness and, say, the American founding. There was, until recently, a connection between being male and running for President. The rector may not have noticed but women do lots of things they did not do previously and it is a misplaced concern for gender differenciation to want to hold on to yesteryear's ways.
The decision also runs the risk of bringing back the "boys club" mentality that has caused great damage to the Church. Altar servers bond. While other boys and girls sleep in or play soccer on a Sunday morning, they get together to help out at Mass. Restricting that activity by gender helps create the wrong kind of gender differentiation, the kind that leads adolescents to grow up to be uncomfortable with women in Church, but any future pastor will likely rely on women to run all sorts of activities in his parish. Boys who are uncomfortable around girls will be inclined to see being an altar boy as a chance to escape their uncomfortability. I would submit that this is not necessarily a good thing to discern, still less to cultivate, in future clerics.
But, there is a deeper concern. Those altar girls who are now barred are baptized. Serving as an altar boy does not have to do with holy orders - and it never has. Yes, in seminary, future priests were installed officially as acolytes and as lectors, but most parishes never had officially installed acolytes. Rev. Lankeit has focused on the wrong sacrament in this decision. One wonders if he has even read the documents of Vatican II which place such a heavy emphasis on the dignity of the baptized.
Bishop Olmsted has not been shy about making controversial decisions. And, generally, most of us think that allowing pastors more say in their parishes is a good thing: micro-managing bishops can be a disaster. But, this is not just any parish. Officially, Olmsted is the pastor of this parish. He should step in and overturn the decision.
Could you send me those standards in a FReepmail?
Yeah ... I bet "Michael Sean Winters" is uncomfortable around girls.
Jus' sayin' ...
I saw last night a woman doing the second reading, from Romans. The Gospel and the Psalm, a man or seminarian. First reader was a guy. This is last night.
I had watched the encore presentation of the closing mass of the WYD 2011 on EWTN.
So they used to have girls, but are reverting to all boys? I wonder how that’ll go over with the parents of girls who are currently serving.
One factual error - Arlington also had only boys as diocesan policy until a few years ago, when Bishop Loverde said it was up to the pastors. Our parish has girls, but at least they’re not in the same cassocks as the boys. I do wish they’d quit playing with their hair.
I attended mass in Toledo. What they do in Madrid is much like what happens in Los Angeles except it’s in Spanish.
I prefer the Tridentine Mass.
Aww The Fishwrap is upset. Bonus.
Fascinatng. What standards could boys fulfill, and girls not? Must have had something to do with upper-body strngth. Lifting the altar and relocating it smack up against the back wall?
Shouldn’t be be posting another one of your inaccurate, long winded vanities?
You mean telling the truth? Your right, there are no liberal social justice priests in the Catholic church.
Pray for America
once you start mixing with girls at that age, the boys see being an alter server is a “girly” thing and you end up with all girls.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.