[Grizzled Bear]

insist she is the mother, ergo preceding source, of God?

Very strange conclusion -- do you think YOUR mother is your preceding source, your creator?

Are you suggesting that God did not exist until Jesus was born of Mary? You seem to be using circular logic in order to confound the conversation.

God was God before Mary.

[aruanan]

God was God before Mary.

Yes, but Mary was, nevertheless, the mother of the God of Israel, as attested to by her cousin, Elizabeth, wife of a Jewish priest: "Blessed are you among women, and blessed is the child you will bear! But why am I so favored, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?"

[Cronos]

GB, GB, GB, did you READ what CVengr said? Here for your edification is the conversation repeated

Cvengr: insist she is the mother, ergo preceding source, of God?

me : Very strange conclusion -- do you think YOUR mother is your preceding source, your creator?

Do you notice this "?" at the end? it meant i was asking Cvengr if Cvengr believed that Cvengr's mother was her preceding source, Cvengr's creator.

[Cronos]

GB, you do know that Mother <> Creator, correct?

You, do know that The Church teaches that Mary was created by God, right?

You, GB, do know that JEsus Christ was/is God, right?

You, GB, do know that Mary, was the mother of God, Jesus Christ, (not his creator), right?

You do know that Cvengr's equation of "mother, ergo preceding source," is wrong because it seems to suggest that Cvengr's mother was Cvengr's preceding source (which is a stupid, illogical point)