I think that was pretty much the argument your church used to try and kill any Christians that refused to submit to it.
I think that was pretty much the argument your church used to try and kill any Christians that refused to submit to it.
YUP.
You mean “Christians” like the Cathar who were Gnostics or Paulicians?
The Baptist movement grew out of English Puritanism/Separatism These Separatists shared the Anabaptist conviction that the true church would restore the doctrine and government of the New Testament, which, it appeared, the Anglicans had no intention of doing. Separatists sought to establish free churches with a congregational form of government, but, unlike the Anabaptists, most of them retained the Protestant/Calvinist view of salvation, and all of them practiced infant baptism (Baptist Successionism, pp. 124-5)
Norman Cohns book, The Pursuit of the Millennium, subtitled Revolutionary Millenarians and Mystical Anarchists of the Middle Ages, describes what happened when the town of Munster, Germany, fell to Anabaptist "prophets" from the Netherlands:During February 1534, the power of the Anabaptists in Munster increased rapidly From Antwerp a scholar could write to Erasmus of Rotterdam: We in these parts are living in wretched anxiety because of the way the revolt of the Anabaptists has flared up. For it really did spring up like fire. There is, I think, scarcely a village or town where the torch is not glowing in secret. They preach community of goods, with the result that all those who have nothing come flocking. How seriously the authorities took the threat is shown by the repressive measures which they adopted. Anabaptism was made a capital offense not only throughout the diocese of Munster but in the neighboring principalities During the months of the siege countless men and women in the towns were beheaded, drowned, burnt or broken on the wheel. By then end of March Matthys had established an absolute dictatorship; but a few days later he was dead This event gave an opening to Matthyss young disciple, Jan Bockelson, who so far had played no great part but who was in every was fitted to seize such a chance and use it to the full Bockelsons first important act was characteristically at once a religious and a political one. Early in May he ran naked through the town in a frenzy and then fell into a silent ecstasy which lasted three days. When speech returned to him he called the population together and announced that God had revealed to him that the old constitution of the town, being the work of men, must be replaced by a new one which would be the work of God. The burgomasters and Council were deprived of their functions. In their place Bockelson set himself and on the model of Ancient Israel twelve Elders This new government was given authority in all matters, public and private, spiritual and material, and power of life and death over all inhabitants of the town. A new legal code was drawn up, aimed partly at carrying still further the process of socialization and partly at imposing a severely puritanical morality. A strict direction of labour was introduced At the same time the new code made capital offenses not only of murder and theft but also of lying, slander, avarice and quarreling. But above all it was an absolutely authoritarian code; death was to be the punishment of every kind of insubordination of the young against their parents, of a wife against her husband, of anyone against God and Gods representative, the government of Munster (The Pursuit of the Millennium, Chap. 13)McGoldrick states, a large majority of Anabaptists were quite unorthodox in their perceptions of the Incarnation, citing as examples Thomas Muntzer, Melchior Hoffman and a leader of the Munster Anabaptists who also denied that Christ received His human flesh from Mary. This false teaching was a revival of the ancient Monophysite heresy that Christ had only one nature:Bernard Rothman (c. 1495-1535), an Anabaptist prominent in the ill-fated attempt to build New Jerusalem at Munster in Westphalia, wrote: If it had been Marys flesh [that is, Christ born of Mary] that died for us, my God, what comfort and courage could we derive from that? That would be like paying for one sin with another and to wash and cleanse one uncleanness with another. (Baptist Successionism, p. 102)Another Anabaptist leader who taught Monophysitism was Menno Simons, a disciple of Melchior Hoffman and the founder of the Mennonites. Menno Simons view of the Incarnation is described in Harold O.J. Browns book,HeresiesIn August, 1532, radical Protestants under the leadership of the former Lutheran priest Bernt Rothmann and the cloth merchant and magistrate Hermann Knipperdoling took control of all of Münster's churches, with the exception of the Bishop's cathedral. By late 1533, these radicals had effective control of the entire town. By this time, they had also been converted to the Anabaptist ideas of Melchior Hoffman. In 1534 the Anabaptists (specifically the Melchiorites), led by Jan Matthys (or Matthijs) and Jan Beukels (often referred to as John of Leiden), took power openly in the Münster Rebellion and founded a "New Jerusalem." They claimed all property, burned all books except the Bible, and expelled or executed dissenters. John of Leiden believed he would lead the elect from Münster to capture the entire world and purify it of evil with the sword in preparation of Jesus's Second Coming and the beginnings of a New AgeFor Christ Jesus, as to his origin, is no earthly man, that is, fruit of the flesh and blood of Adam. He is a heavenly fruit or man. For his beginning or origin is of the Father [John 16:28], like unto the first Adam, sin excepted. [ff. Menno Simons, Complete Writings, ed. Harold S. Bender, 1956) p. 863]Article IV of the 1632 Dutch Mennonite Confession to which David Cloud refers incorporates the Monophysite heresy, that Jesus was conceived in Mary, rather than of Mary: We believe and confess further, that when the time of the promise, for which all the pious forefathers had so much longed and waited, had come and was fulfilled, this previously promised Messiah, Redeemer, and Savior, proceeded from God, was sent, and, according to the prediction of the prophets, and the testimony of the evangelists, came into the world, yea, into the flesh, was made manifest, and the Word, Himself became flesh and man; that He was conceived in the virgin Mary (Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia)In contrast, Luke 1:31 states specifically that Mary herself conceived Jesus, and was not merely a vessel through which Jesus heavenly flesh was conceived by some other agency:And the angel said unto her, Fear not, Mary: for thou hast found favour with God. And, behold, thou shalt conceive in thy womb, and bring forth a son, and shalt call his name JESUS. (Luke 1:30-31 KJV)The heresy which Menno Simons taught the Anabaptist and Mennonite congregations was explicitly and frequently stated in his works: I have shown and confessed to you the firm foundation of. the incarnation of the Lord, that he did not become flesh of Mary, but that he became flesh in Mary Thus Christ Jesus remains the precious, blessed fruit of the womb of Mary, according to the words of Elizabeth, which was conceived not of her womb but in her womb wrought by the Holy Spirit through faith, of God the omnipotent Father, from high heaven, as we have frequently shown They say and teach, without any Scripture, That the Word has put on a whole man of Marys flesh and seed; and we say and teach, according to the plain testimony of John, That the Word was made flesh, not of Mary, but in Mary. They teach, That there are two different persons and sons, one divine, the other human, in the one Christ, without Scripture; and we say that there is but one undivided person and Son, according to the Scriptures. (The Complete Writings of Menno Simons: Book 2, pp. 332-3, 397) (See also: The Confutation: Part Third)The heavenly flesh doctrine was not a new revelation to the Anabaptists and Mennonites, but a major heresy that had been refuted in every particular over a millennium earlier, at the Council of Chalcedon (451 AD).We confess, therefore, our Lord Jesus Christ, the Only Begotten Son of God, perfect God, and perfect Man of a reasonable soul and flesh consisting; begotten before the ages of the Father according to his Divinity, and in the last days, for us and for our salvation, of Mary the Virgin according to his humanity, of the same substance with his Father according to his Divinity, and of the same substance with us according to his humanity; for there became a union of two natures. Wherefore we confess one Christ, one Son, one Lord. According to this understanding of this unmixed union, we confess the holy Virgin to be Mother of God; because God the Word was incarnate and became Man, and from this conception he united the temple taken from her with himself.(Council of Chalcedon Confession)