Posted on 06/27/2003 11:20:52 AM PDT by SJackson
ZOA Condemns Powell's Remark on Terror
June 26, 2003 Contact: (212) 481-1500
Attn: NEWS EDITOR
ZOA CONDEMNS POWELL FOR IMPLYING ISRAELI SELF-DEFENSE IS "THE SAME THING" AS PALESTINIAN ARAB TERRORISM
NEW YORK- The Zionist Organization of America (ZOA) has condemned the statement by Secretary of State Colin Powell strongly implying that Israeli self-defense actions are "the same thing" as Palestinian Arab terrorism.
Interviewed on the Arabic television station Al-Jazeera on June 23, 2003, Powell was asked, "Can you explain the difference you see between legitimate resistance and terrorism in the Middle East?" Powell replied by saying that the recent Palestinian Arab drive-by shooting in which a 7 year-old girl was murdered "is terrorism." He then added: "The same thing happens on the other side when the response comes and innocent people lose their lives, young people on the Palestinian side."
ZOA National President Morton A. Klein said:
"Secretary Powell's remark could certainly be interpreted as meaning that since both Israeli and Arab civilians have died, the Israeli and Arab actions which caused those deaths are 'the same thing.' This is false and outrageous. There is no equivalency between Palestinian Arab terror, which deliberately targets innocent civilians, and Israeli self-defense actions, which never target innocent civilians."
"How and why someone dies is important. To say that Israeli and Arab casualties are 'the same thing' is like saying that casualties caused by U.S. forces in Afghanistan are 'the same thing' as the thousands of Americans murdered in the 9/11 attacks."
Powell Should Be Telling the Arabs That Their Violence is Morally Wrong, Not Just "Ineffective"
Asked by Al-Jazeera Television "Is there any legitimate resistance?," Powell refused to state that all Palestinian Arab violence is illegitimate. Instead, he argued that Palestinian Arab violence was not effective: "What has this kind of resistance achieved for Palestinian people, whether you describe it as legitimate or illegitimate, whether it is terrorism or resistance, whatever you call it, let me ask the question this way, what has it achieved for the Palestinian people?"
ZOA president Klein commented: "The Secretary of State should be telling the Arab world, loud and clear, in no uncertain terms, that all Arab violence against Israelis is illegitimate and immoral and must stop immediately, whether or not it 'achieves' anything."
Powell's Repeated "Cycle of Violence" Remarks Implies Moral Equivalency Between Terrorists & Israel
In his remarks to Al Jazeera Television, Powell repeatedly referred to Palestinian Arab terrorism and Israeli self-defense action as "the cycle," as if the two are morally equivalent. Similarly, Powell said on June 22, 2003: "I regret that we continue to find ourselves trapped in this action and counteraction, provocation and reaction to provocation."
ZOA president Klein said: "The term 'cycle of violence' implies a moral equivalency between Arab terrorism and Israeli self-defense. Would Secretary Powell describe America's fight with Al Qaeda as a 'cycle of violence'? Would he say that the only thing wrong with Al Qaeda terrorism is that it has not 'achieved' very much for Al Qaeda's cause?"
Another U.S. Official Spoke of Arabs' "Legitimate Resistance"
The ZOA notes that Deputy Undersecretary of State David Satterfield, who has been sent to Israel as one of the leaders of the U.S. team monitoring implementation of the Road Map, has made statements describing some Arab terrorism as legitimate "resistance." While touring southern Lebanon in December 1998. He was asked by reporters about attacks launched by Hezbollah against Israel. (Hezbollah is on the U.S. list of terrorist groups; its attacks include the 1983 car-bomb massacre of 241 Marines in Lebanon.) According to the Arab newspaper Al-Nahar (Dec. 4, 1998), he replied: "We make a distinction between resistance and terror. We don't think that this resistance is terrorism." When a correspondent for the Journal of Counterterrorism asked the State Department for its response, a spokesman "refused to answer whether Satterfield's comments were in line with State Department policy or not." He did not deny that Satterfield made the statement. (Vol.6, No.2, p.26)
=============================
Clearly Secretary Powell sings to an Arab drummer when he's on Al Jazeera.
The moral equivalence that you're placing on both sides is appalling in that it's no different than those who condemn both the arsonist and the fire fighter.
The palis fight not to gain freedom and statehood, which have been repeatedly offered to them, but to attempt to annihilate the Jews. In other words, they do not *have* to fight for survival -- and that's why your analogy is fatally flawed.
Another major flaw is that your examples, for the most part, don't explicitly target civilians, as the palis do. If you can't see the difference between ambushing soldiers and blowing up buses full of schoolkids and grandparents, then that's really quite sad.
But it's very big of you to not condone acts of terror.
I apologize if I didn't engage in ad hominems or any other type of personal attack which would have given you reason to shrug and complain that your opponents are irrational and engage in nastiness and personal attacks, but you just ain't worth it.
Prepare yourselves - the wrath of God will befall America like never in our history if Bush continues to send spies (Powell) into the camp of Israel.
The santioning of homosexuality by the highest legal authority in the land (USSC) has opened wide the gates of hell against America.
Have you noticed the increase of floods, tornadoes, droughts, plagues, pestilences coming on America?
If America keeps up the taking away of covenent lands from Israel - ALL HELL WILL BREAK LOOSE!
Laugh if you must, but it won't be funny.
Filthy words. *Wrong* words. Grr, how I hate the moral-equivalenciers.
At one time I really liked Powell. Over the years I have come to see a completely different side of the man. He is unfit to hold the office of Secretary of State.
Does he also seek to equate collateral damage during our military efforts to be terrorism? Mr. Powell, place you resignation on the desk by morning.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.