Skip to comments.
How Popular is Astrology? (Do Intelligent And Rational People Believe That Crap?)
Astrology Now ^
| Astrology Now
Posted on 10/11/2002 11:44:44 AM PDT by jstone78
How popular is astrology?
Your belief in astrology is part of a popular trend. Are you the kind of person who sneaks a look at the daily horoscope when no one's looking? Who secretly buys an Astrology magazine when you're traveling by yourself? Who pretends you're just kidding when you ask what somebody's sign is? Do you roll your eyes when people start talking about charts and ascendants, retrogrades, and rising suns, but secretly hang on every word?
If you've done any of the above. Don't worry. YOU ARE NOT ALONE!
There is this view in our culture that you are either an air head or mentally deficient if you have some belief that there is more to Astrology than a pick-up line in a bar.
But it's a view that is CONTRADICTED by every poll, statistic and fact about Americans and their relationship to Astrology . . .
9 out of 10 Americans know there sign. No big deal. Doesn't mean much.
But did you know . . .
that more people believe in Astrology than in any single religious denomination?
or that Astrology is the number one . . . the most popular area within the Lifestyles Channel of America Online!
or that a recent Gallup poll found that over 50% of Americans believe in Astrology. That's about 125 million people! And that's a cross section of all Americans . . . University presidents, CEO's, lawyers, teachers, mechanics, cooks, waitresses . . . all of us.
(Excerpt) Read more at astrologynow.com ...
TOPICS: Constitution/Conservatism; Culture/Society
KEYWORDS: astrology; ignorance; morons
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-63 next last
I am sorry if this offends anyone.
But I think that people who believe in astrology are stupid, and are certifiable idiots and morons. It does not matter how rich or educated they are. The idea that one can claim to tell the future by looking at the stars, palm reading, analysing charts or tarot cards, defines all common sense. It is a real shame that 50 percent of the population believe such garbage.
America's Founding Fathers tried to limit the number of such idiots on the voters' rolls, by imposing stringent qualifications on the franchise. When qualifications on the franchise were removed, the quality of elected leaders declined.
1
posted on
10/11/2002 11:44:44 AM PDT
by
jstone78
To: jstone78
9 out of 10 Americans know there sign9 out 10 Americans who believe in astrology don't know the difference between "there" and "their."
2
posted on
10/11/2002 11:47:10 AM PDT
by
Dog Gone
To: jstone78
There is this view in our culture that you are either an air head or mentally deficient if you have some belief that there is more to Astrology than a pick-up line in a bar. But it's a view that is CONTRADICTED by every poll
The democrats have won. Mental deficiency is now determined by polls.
3
posted on
10/11/2002 11:49:04 AM PDT
by
Physicist
To: jstone78
by imposing stringent qualifications on the franchise
Do that and you'll face the wrath of Nancy Reagan.
4
posted on
10/11/2002 11:50:14 AM PDT
by
lelio
To: jstone78
How many planets or stars didn't even "exist" until the discovery of the telescope? It is such a human failing to assume that nothing exists until we can prove it exists. A rather ironic example, since the accuracy of the horoscope presumably depends upon the positions of the unknown planets.
5
posted on
10/11/2002 11:51:18 AM PDT
by
Physicist
To: jstone78
I think most people who even claim to believe astrology or their horoscopes are doing it for fun and nothing more, and that perhaps you are being a grump!
To: jstone78
If you don't believe in astrology you must be a virgo or a
libra...
To: jstone78
"Crap"???
Psh! Typical Libra.
Dan
PS -- THE ABOVE IS A JOKE, REPEAT, JOKE
8
posted on
10/11/2002 12:04:45 PM PDT
by
BibChr
To: jstone78
The only horoscope I follow religiously is that written by By Lloyd Schumner Sr., Retired Machinist and A.A.P.B.-Certified Astrologer for The Onion.
Leo: (July 23Aug. 22)
You have very little say in your fate or what will
eventually befall you, but don't let that keep you from
voting.
To: jstone78
Best proof Astrology is less than scientific? Take the base concept that the 'zodiacal' stars/planets permanently influence the baby at birth. Should not two babies born in the same hospital at the same time have identical astrological characteristics?
Now take two prominent astrologers of your choice, have them each interview each adult independently. If Astrology was a science, there should be at least some common characteristics. Astrology is not a science, it is not falsifiable and its' hypotheses are inconsistent through its belief community.
10
posted on
10/11/2002 12:23:35 PM PDT
by
SES1066
To: jstone78
I agree that no one can predict the future, and that newspaper horoscopes are ridiculous.
However, I will say that if you were ever to have a full-blown astrological analysis done by an experienced astrologer, you would be amazed at how uncannily accurate it can be with respect to describing personalities and life issues.
My wife has a professional counseling practice (she has a Masters in counseling psychology), and has also been an avid student of astrology for the past dozen years. She frequently uses astrological analyses in her practice, and the insights yielded by this techique are consistently amazing. The more I have seen of astrology as an analytical tool -- especially in couples counseling -- the more difficulty I have in dismissing it as entirely bogus.
Feel free to flame me on this (but be warned that if you make any disparaging comments about my wife, I will be forced to challenge you to a duel).
Meanwhile, just remember that Nancy Reagan was no dummy.
11
posted on
10/11/2002 12:28:23 PM PDT
by
Maceman
To: SES1066
You mean like the many cases of twins that were separated shortly after birth and went on to lead remarkably similar lives - not even knowing they had a twin somewhere until they were adults?
To: SES1066
Should not two babies born in the same hospital at the same time have identical astrological characteristics?They will be pretty similar, although obviously environmental influences will also play a large role in the development of their personalities.
13
posted on
10/11/2002 12:30:10 PM PDT
by
Maceman
To: jstone78
It is a real shame that 50 percent of the population believe such garbage. I have strong doubts about this percentage. It strikes me to be on the same level as the 100,000 Australians claiming to be Jedi believers in the last Australian Census. A more-or-less harmless diversion that causes me to just shrug and relect on Ted Sturgeon's immortal commnet "90% of everything is excrement"!
14
posted on
10/11/2002 12:33:02 PM PDT
by
SES1066
To: Maceman
The classic anti-astrology demo is done by famous skeptic Amazing Randi when he speaks before classes of students; doesn't reveal who he is, asked for birth date and location data, gives each student their "personalized" horoscope, students gasp in awe at how accurate their horoscope is, Randi spends a few minutes asking the students how accurate their horoscope is and they all gush in amazement at the accuracy...
Then Randi asks everyone to hand their horoscope to the person sitting behind them....
EVERYONE got the same horoscope.
The basis of astrology is cleverly designing "readings" that SEEM specific, but which apply to everyone and their opinion of themselves. Even quite intelligent people can be fooled by this.
15
posted on
10/11/2002 12:34:23 PM PDT
by
John H K
To: Physicist
More like elections are determined by mental deficiency.
16
posted on
10/11/2002 12:35:10 PM PDT
by
js1138
To: John H K
The Amazing Randi is a cool guy.
17
posted on
10/11/2002 12:37:13 PM PDT
by
BikerNYC
To: jstone78
Reminds me of my favorite quote about economics from a Standford professor twenty or so years ago, "The only purpose served by economic forecasting is to lend credibility to astrology."
To: jstone78
This isn't just in the US. I'm amazed that people I've met from all over the world believe in astrology at the same rate Americans too. Belief in this garbage is universal regardless of country.
19
posted on
10/11/2002 12:37:55 PM PDT
by
caa26
To: John H K
The classic anti-astrology demo is done by famous skeptic Amazing Randi when he speaks before classes of students; doesn't reveal who he is, asked for birth date and location data, gives each student their "personalized" horoscope, students gasp in awe at how accurate their horoscope is, Randi spends a few minutes asking the students how accurate their horoscope is and they all gush in amazement at the accuracy... Then Randi asks everyone to hand their horoscope to the person sitting behind them.... EVERYONE got the same horoscope. The basis of astrology is cleverly designing "readings" that SEEM specific, but which apply to everyone and their opinion of themselves. Even quite intelligent people can be fooled by this.I have not seen Randi do this, nor have I seen the "readings" he hands out.
But I can tell you that the analyses I have seen done by my wife about real people are not interchangeable.
20
posted on
10/11/2002 12:38:22 PM PDT
by
Maceman
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-63 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson