Skip to comments.
New book says Christians suffered most
The Guardian UK ^
| 6/04/02
| Rory Carroll in Rome
Posted on 06/03/2002 6:55:44 PM PDT by LarryLied
A new book which claims that Christians are the victims of worldwide persecution has stirred controversy in Italy amid accusations that it minimises the Holocaust and demonises Islam.
The author, Antonio Socci, claims the untold story of the 20th century is the murder of 45 million Christians, mostly at the hands of communist and Islamic regimes, and that massacres continue to this day.
The New Persecuted, Inquiries into Anti-Christian Intolerance in the New Century of Martyrs, has angered some scholars by depicting Christians as beleaguered victims of rampaging Muslims.
Some reviewers have hailed the publication as a wake-up call to Christians in the west who have not realised, even in the wake of September 11, that they are under attack by a hostile rival religion.
Others said Mr Socci was part of a rightwing revisionist effort to distort history and promote a hawkish response to perceived threats.
Drawing heavily from the World Christian Encyclopedia, published last year by the Oxford University Press, Mr Socci traces the persecution of Christians through the centuries, from the crucifixion of Jesus to the lions at Circus Maximus, the assassination of Thomas Becket and the execution of Thomas More, the Boxer rebellion in China, Mexico's revolution and the Turkish massacres in Armenia. He calculates that in the past 2,000 years some 70 million Christians have been killed, two-thirds in the past 100 years alone, a bloodbath blamed mostly on the Soviet Union as well as communist China and Nazi Germany.
Mr Socci supports Israel and does not dispute the number of Jews killed in the Holocaust but by framing the genocide in such a context he had minimised its significance, said Alberto Melloni, an author and religious historian.
"The statistics he cites are largely meaningless but the effect is to make the Shoah [Holocaust] just one detail in a century of massacres. It is part of an effort by some in the Catholic church to stop the Shoah being the most important event in the 20th century."
Mr Socci, 43, a columnist with conservative Italian newspapers, claims that an average of 160,000 Christians have been killed every year since 1990, the vast majority in the third world. Critics said the figure included Christians killed in conflicts which had little to do with religion.
Chronicling attacks, pogroms and wars in East Timor, Indonesia, Sudan, Egypt, Pakistan, India, and even Rwanda and Latin America, Mr Socci identifies Islamic extremism as the main danger.
He complains that secular western governments, intellectuals and media organisations have played down the bloodbath because the persecution of Jews and Muslims, whether in the former Soviet Union or former Yugoslavia, was considered more newsworthy. "This global persecution of Christianity is still in progress but in most cases is ignored by the mass media and Christians in the west."
Tommaso Debenedetti, a cultural commentator, said the book was part of an attempt by Italy's right to deflect accusations of intolerance against immigrants and other minorities by casting itself as the victim of non-Christian and liberal forces. "The right is reversing the argument."
Breaking ranks with positive reviews which called the book "extraordinary", the Turin daily La Stampa said it was a provocation with questionable statistics and a flawed definition of martyr which included those killed for political reasons.
TOPICS: Culture/Society; Foreign Affairs; News/Current Events
KEYWORDS: catholiclist; christianpersecutio
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 101-120, 121-140, 141-160, 161-164 next last
To: Antoninus
I wasn't writting a doctorial paper when I wrote what I wrote. What I wrote is correct in fact and in spirit if not put in the correct Latin theological wording.
141
posted on
06/05/2002 10:47:10 AM PDT
by
Spar
To: LarryLied
"There is no reason for the writer of this article to have mentioned the Holocaust." I agree. I also think it's disappointing that the Holocaust has become THE standard by which all other atrocities must be judged.
To: JMJ333
I understand quite well that Protestants don't believe in purgatory. I do, because I believe that we go through a cleansing process before entering heaven. So, when I say the ommitance of punishment for already forgiven sin, I am saying it in context of purgatory. Regards. Pergatory is not biblical and militates against the sufficiency of Christ's atonement. If Christ's death is sufficient - AND IT IS! - then pergatory is a falsehood and a lie. Either Christ's FINISHED WORK on the corss and his atoning death is sufficient or it isn't...which is it? If you believe in pergatory you cannot also believe in the sufficiency of the atonement without falling into hopeless self-contradiction. Show me pergatory in the bible. If it was real and important don't you think it would at least be mentioned?
To: redhead
Well, most of us don't want to HAVE to give it all up, but if one is a true BELIEVER, it's probable that they would. The martyrs of Rome had no problem dying for their faith. It was simply what was done. Christians (and Jews) have died willingly for their faith all down through the ages. American Christians do not resemble roman Christians. American Christians are affluent, Roman christians were mostly dirt poor (but not in spirit!). But you are right - the TRUE believers would lay it all on the line, I only question the devotion of most Americans who call themselves Christians. Money is king here for most people.
To: exmarine
...I believe that we go through a cleansing process before entering heaven... I think you should crack your bible to the book of Hebrews - The blood of Christ cleanses beleivers FROM ALL SIN. Period. There is no more cleansing to be done once you are white as snow in Christ.
To: sheltonmac
I remember the A-Bomb drills in elementary school. That is the history I would like to know about. Who our enemy was and what they were up to. Lots of new information came out with the fall of the Berlin Wall but you have to search to find it. History on TV is Nazi Germany. Over and over. Rarely a mention of the gulags, of Christians killed. But anyday of the week, sometime during the day, a cable channel will tell us about Nazi atrocities. AND THERE ARE NO NAZIS IN POWER TODAY. But there are murdering socialists in power. There are former Soviet concentration camps commandants running loose. Nobody is making a stink about bringing them to justice. Poland and Lithuania get called names when they try.
To: LarryLied
[some flack writes]: "The statistics he cites are largely meaningless but the effect is to make the Shoah [Holocaust] just one detail in a century of massacres. It is part of an effort by some in the Catholic church to stop the Shoah being the most important event in the 20th century."
Here we have the crux of the matter, protecting the inanely tedious sacred cow of the Jewish Holocaust.
Hate to tell 'em this but it wasn't the most important event in the 20th century. It wasn't even close. I still think the "six million" was somewhat inflated. Maybe four to five million is closer.
The Holocaust is just irrelevant to most people now, especially Gentile young people, and that's what has the Holocaust industry scared.
To: exmarine
With all do respect--and I do appreciate your graciousness on this thread--my beliefs stem from the church founded by Christ himself, and the concept of purgatory has been around a lot longer than any protestant denomination. I respect your beliefs, but I do not share them. And I am done on this thread. Regards and best to you.
148
posted on
06/05/2002 6:01:25 PM PDT
by
JMJ333
To: JMJ333; ex-marine
JMJ: ...my beliefs stem from the church founded by Christ himself...
No. Your ideas are merely the religious ideas of men and some self-serving traditions that eventually developed because the Bishop of Rome became so powerful over the centuries. You believe in the traditions of men. We believe in the Word of God.
...and the concept of purgatory has been around a lot longer than any protestant denomination.
The mythical purgatory was invented by Origen. He also cut off his testes for religious reasons. Not exactly a strong testimony to the soundness of his thinking. Although Origen has always been rightfully suspected of devious theology and strange readings, he still holds a place in the history of the Roman chruch, largely because to finally repudiate him would cast serious doubts upon his invention of Purgatory.
But Purgatory, combined with indulgences, was a fantastic fundraising machine for the Roman hierarchy for many centuries. Slick marketing, a steady revenue stream and far more profitable than licensing monks to practice sodomy in the summer months.
Hey, ex-, always love to read your stuff...
To: George W. Bush
I love how you come on the thread to sneer your disdain for me and my religion. You're one of those people who like to ram your beliefs down the throats of others revelling in your haughty "correctnees." I'm sure you'll convert many with that charming attitude. Regards.
150
posted on
06/05/2002 6:44:55 PM PDT
by
JMJ333
To: George W. Bush
Hate to tell 'em this but it wasn't the most important event in the 20th century.The Bolshevik Revolution was. The left finally had the opportunity to do what they had dreamed of doing for decades. And they did it with a vengeance. We feel the effects today.
To: JMJ333
I love how you come on the thread to sneer your disdain for me and my religion.
Well, glad to be of service. I will remark in passing that I discussed the church of Rome. I don't know you and don't think I insulted you, regardless of your little claim.
I notice that you didn't bother to dispute my historical representation. It seems that you are at least reasonably well-informed about the rather sordid history of your religious institution.
Love the iconography though. A classic Roman distraction technique.
To: LarryLied
Agreed.
I'd somehow like to broaden it to something more general to encompass the entire international Left instead of only the Bolshevik revolution but, if we narrow it to just one single event, that one can fairly be represented as the most tragic in many centuries.
To: George W. Bush
Correct, it was more than that even (Bela Kun in Hungary and the commies in Germany and in China and in....everwhere. Even here). Getting back to the Church. I'm as far theologically as one can be from Catholicism (I'm Unitarian). But the Church does a heck of a lot of good. There is no international organization of its size which is standing up to the likes of George Soros, Maurice Strong, Ted Turner, the UN and hundreds of socialist NGOs. The current Pope helped bring down the evil empire. Pope Leo XIII warned where socialist were going 35 years before Lenin and Trotsky gained power and started killing.
I much prefer people be involved in their church than look to the state for all answers. Everyone who desires liberty loses if the Catholic church is weakened.
To: LarryLied
But the Church does a heck of a lot of good. There is no international organization of its size which is standing up to the likes of George Soros, Maurice Strong, Ted Turner, the UN and hundreds of socialist NGOs.
Absolutely. On those issues, like the pro-life issue, I support the stance of the Roman church. Without their sheer numbers, we would be overrun. I've often written here at FR of my admiration for the aggressive stance of the bishops in my own state. They are considerably more conservative than the rest of the American hierarchy.
I much prefer people be involved in their church than look to the state for all answers. Everyone who desires liberty loses if the Catholic church is weakened.
I agree with the first sentence, very reminiscent of Eisenhower's remarks to the same effect. But, historically, I would take issue with the second statement from both a secular and religious viewpoint. Nevertheless, the church of Rome has made a few important contributions to modern liberty, sometimes inadvertently. Their current effort in battling the social engineering plans of the global socialists at the U.N. is one that I applaud and support. I often pass along the alerts of the Vatican mission to the U.N. to my representatives and within my own personal circle.
To: George W. Bush
Those the Church is fighting must have known for decades the extent of the problem in the Church. I wonder how much they encouraged it. When a priest is a part owner in a gay resort, you know the entire gay community knows about it.
To: LarryLied
What killing Christians is a bad thing? (sarcasm)
Christians better wake up soon.
Comment #158 Removed by Moderator
Comment #159 Removed by Moderator
To: JMJ333, George W. Bush
You're one of those people who like to ram your beliefs down the throats of others revelling in your haughty "correctnees."GWB... a Baptist?? "Forcing" his beliefs on others??
As it happens, the roster of heroic martyrs tortured and slaughtered for their beliefs by the ruthless fire and stake of Baptist Inquisitors and their grim-faced Armies of steel-clad Baptist Crusaders is, um...
....not a terribly long list. ;-)
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 101-120, 121-140, 141-160, 161-164 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson