Posted on 06/07/2024 9:22:56 AM PDT by SeekAndFind
California has the highest income tax rate in the country (top tier of 14.4 percent). It has the highest statewide sales tax rate (7.25 percent, plus local sales taxes). It has the highest gas tax rate ($0.78 per gallon). Yet, it ranks third to last in the country in terms of road quality.
The old joke is that California would tax the air we breathe if it could. Well, California’s latest tax proposal comes close. The state is recruiting drivers for a pilot program to track and tax the miles they drive.
The plan is borne from the fact that Californians have switched to electric and hybrid vehicles at a faster rate than other states, spurred on by large state, as well as federal, subsidies. As a result, gas consumption has declined, in turn reducing the state’s gas tax receipts. One might think this could be rectified by simply shifting money from the general fund to make up for it. But the state faces up to a $55 billion deficit this year, causing it to consider a host of additional taxes, including a wealth tax.
California has long relied upon the gas tax to take care of its roads. It was a good idea at first. The gas tax was initially used in lieu of toll roads, which made a lot of sense. Pricing the cost of road maintenance into the price of gas was a good way of taxing people based upon usage. Toll roads do the same, but they are cumbersome, requiring toll booths, workers, cash, and long lines. However, California ultimately succumbed to the need for more money and added some toll roads in addition to the gas tax.
But thanks to the state’s green initiative, it has convinced Californians to switch from gas to hybrid or electric vehicles. While electric vehicles are more expensive, Californians were enticed to buy them by the subsidies and by the savings they would enjoy by no longer having to buy gas. But like most government programs, this was not well thought out. California has lost millions in tax revenue due to this scheme and now needs to make that up. From the myriad of options available to it, it has chosen a plan to begin tracking drivers with GPS monitors.
Buyers of electric cars may not have been aware of the new tax-by-the-mile plan before they made the decision to purchase their vehicle. Had they known about the potential added cost, they may have made a different decision. But regardless, California law mandates that all new car sales be electric by 2035.
Under the new plan, according to Caltrans, mileage could be tracked by plugging an electronic device into a vehicle or using the vehicle’s tracking system. There was a time when many Californians were civil libertarians and would have vehemently opposed such a government intrusion into their personal lives. But many today put their undying trust in the government, believing it to be infallible and capable of curing all societal ills. We saw during the pandemic how most Californians had no problem trusting the government to interfere in virtually all elements of private life, mandating when we could leave our homes, who we could invite into our homes, and that we inject an unproven vaccine. Allowing the government to track our every move is right in line with such mandates.
There is no telling what the government may use this new information for. The main page of the Caltrans website for the program, entitled “California Road Charge,” presents the tagline, “Funding transportation in an equitable way.” There’s that word again. Government-imposed “equity” can take any number of forms. On the next page it states that the charge is, “Fair. Transparent. Sustainable.”
We already know California is trying to increase the cost of fossil fuels to drive people to electric cars and green energy like wind and solar. The state has even sued the oil companies for causing climate change, in order to make it “more expensive to be dirty than clean,” according to state Attorney General Rob Bonta. By charging an exorbitant fee per mile, it could effectively reduce the number of cars on the road to reduce climate change. It could also easily charge varying fees based on driver income to impose “equity.” It could also charge varying fees based upon miles driven, penalizing those who the government determines drive too much. It could also add a tax for homeless housing, as Los Angeles recently did on all retail sales.
One thing we know, the tax is unlikely to do is actually improve the roads. California has ranked toward the bottom of all states in road quality for a long time, pre-dating the impact of electric cars. In 2016, Reason Foundation’s Annual Highway Report listed California 43rd among states in road quality. It has since gotten worse, dropping in 2019 to 45th and in 2020 to 47th. Perhaps these drops are starting to reflect the impact of the reduced gas tax revenue, but 43rd was not a good starting point, especially for a state with great weather which does not have to deal with the impact of snow, ice, and salt.
The truth is, California has greater priorities than roads. Road upkeep is a basic, old-school obligation of government. It’s not sexy. State politicians are more focused on changing the earth’s temperature, rectifying the scourge of slavery, and building housing for all. In California, basic needs like roads, schools, and safety take a back seat.
Next they’ll be taxing air by the breath.
California has high speed rail so you don’t have to drive.
They’ve spent billions.
Just take the train, right? Right? Oh.
Article:
“Building housing for all”
In California?
That is high comedy—worst homeless nightmares in the country in the large cities.
and it has the added benefit of tracking your travel
Leftists love this. There will be an “Exempt” coding in the computers for the bureaucracy aristocrats and their friends.
Judges, officials, NGO’s, political class, etc.....all free to come and go, sans fees.
Unintended consequence of EVs that don’t buy gas but crash the electric grid?
What happens when semi’s go electric? Ha ha ha , the glut of diesel should make it real cheap in states with some common sense.
don’t they already do this with a tax on a gallon of gas?
who votes these people in?
maroons
Do they think illegals will pay?
CA has fired so many shots into its foot, I’m surprised it’s still standing. Fuel cost in CA are some of the highest in the country. One reason is (I think the law is still in effect) that each county has the right to determine the “blend” of fuels sold in its county. Last I heard, there we 32 blends and, hence, no economies of scale for refineries. State and Federal gas taxes add about a dollar to the price. Do you think this new tax will replace those taxes already on the books? No, this will be added to those existing taxes. If CA is stupid enough to add a wealth tax on top of everything else, the state is doomed.
No! There will be banks of diesel generators to charge the trucks. /s-sort of.
They’re already charging between $5.90-$6.40 a gallon gas
Ohhh! :) Good idea for tourism. Yeah. They really know how to make the ol’ California swing!
“don’t they already do this with a tax on a gallon of gas?”
EV’s don’t use gas.
Unfortunately this is one time I'm not being sarcastic.
People are already being taxed by the mile. Every gallon of gas is estimated to give x-miles to the gallon, dependent on the size of the vehicle and load it carries. Adding per-mile charges equates to charging more per gallon of fuel. I’s just a stealthy way of hiding what they’re doing. Charging tolls is another way of making people pay more for the roads which they’re already paying with the fuel taxes.
But, people can be lied to when they can’t see the forest for the trees.
no one, statistically, drives EVs
Finally getting off this sinking ship. I
I am actually sad i am leaving. Was out at the lake with the jet skis yesterday. Water was beautiful. Weather was perfect. Last night the delta breeze reached us and the night was spectacular. I really wish there was a way northern CA could break away from this nightmare govt.
That's so 20th century. Toll roads have gone boothless with RFID decals on the windshields and photos of the license plates that are registered with the state.
Drivers open up "FastPass" or "EZPass" accounts and load minimum amounts from credit cards that are automatically deducted when driving through an automated toll station.
This way, drivers don't need to provide GPS data, odometer readings, won't be charged for out-of-state driving, etc.
-PJ
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.