Posted on 09/27/2021 3:21:20 PM PDT by zaxtres
Those lawyers learn to be gods in law school.
Ignore the judge.
The dems would.
Judge Katherine Cooper is the former Governor Jan Brewer appointee. The only derogatory thing I could find about her was about a sex offender, and her boyfriend at the time, being arrested in her home. She disavowed all knowledge of knowing he was a sex offender as the warrant was from NY and not from AZ. Most lawyers on both sides have praised her rulings. She received praise and anger from Brwer within a 6-month time span. Cooper has adjudicated over a lot of the hottest political cases in AZ since 2015..
What is unconstitutional is forcing someone to wear them. Evil communist Judge was put in place for a reason.
The courts will not save us.
Period.
Perhaps I’m mistaken.
Check Judge Katherine Cooper’s bank accounts for any new, large sum deposits.
Masks do not do xshit. No masks better for you.
Whenever there are so many negatives in a headline I get confused but ‘mask mandate’ ‘ban’ followed by ‘unconstitutional’ and I had no idea which way it went till I read the article. Is that just me?
Isn’t that legislating from the bench?
State Legislatures set up the laws, and the court makes sure
people abide by them.
It can enter into the discussion if civil rights are being
abridged, but this is not that sort of matter.
What they passed or were seeking to pass, was in their
wheel-house. It’s really not his call.
Masks are worthless. Not only that but childhood is a good time to catch the China Virus. In their case it rarely is an issue and getting over it would give them life long immunity better than any jab.
Totally agree- protest and protest loudly outside their homes...fight fire with fire by using left wing tactics.
Satan is waging all out war on America. His minions are firmly embedded in positions of influence, authority, and power. What better way to rule the country than through the husk of a demented, career liar, pliagiarist, crook, pedophile, and rapist. Biden’s hollow, black, beady eyes are no accident.
THE FOLLOWING IS THE REASON THE JUDGE SAYS THE MEASURES ARE UNCONSTITUTIONAL:
Section 13
Text of Section 13:
Subject and Title of Bills
“ Every act shall embrace but one subject and matters properly connected therewith, which subject shall be expressed in the title; but if any subject shall be embraced in an act which shall not be expressed in the title, such act shall be void only as to so much thereof as shall not be embraced in the title.[1][2] ”
Exactly.
The same judge that thinks banning mask mandates is unconstitutional probably believes mandating the jab is okay.
Nope, I’m on the same page. Bit confusing.
As an actual lawyer for 30 years, this is gobbledygook. The “Article this, statute that, subsection this” legal language is intentionally done to obscure what is really going on.
Law is logical [for the most part] and this isn’t complicated. The judge here is saying the legislature, which governs the school system, is ‘powerless’ to stop schools from compelling masks. Same legislature that has full and unquestioned authority to require vaccines, require attendance, sets grad reqm’ts, student eligibility, etc. Judge is saying a Legislature that has authority to REQUIRE vaccines can’t prohibit the same. Complete garbage opinion written with an outcome in mind and searching for a ‘hook’ to make it sound legal. Sad to say I see this often in court.
This law did not “ban masks”. Judge is saying schooling can be denied UNLESS you wear a mask. This law prevents compelled masking / vax to attend school - a constitutionally protected activity. Anyone can wear a mask if they want. Language matters and this ruling is garbage.
Masks are also fomites.
And there other bugs in addition to CoupFlu put there.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.