Posted on 03/14/2018 12:26:25 PM PDT by Simon Green
After four years of waiting, a video of a controversial courtroom shooting will be released. The decision came on the same day that a judge ruled against Siale Angilau's family, who sued the U.S. marshal who shot and killed him in 2014. The family said they plan on appealing the decision.
Witnesses in the courtroom on April 21, 2014 said a man was testifying about the Tongan Crip Gang when Angilau, the defendant, grabbed a pen and ran toward the witness box. A female U.S. marshal shot Angilau four times, fatally wounding him.
"Why did they have to shoot him like that? He's not an animal. If they shot him once, he would have stopped. But they shot him four times," said Otufangavalu Angilau, Siale's mother.
She said Siale was close to completing his prison sentence for charges of federal racketeering associated with his ties to a Tongan crip gang. She said he wanted to turn his life around, but he never got that chance.
"I remember the last day he called me. It was Mother's Day 2014 and he sent me a scarf. He said, 'Mom. I'll be home soon,'" said Otufangavalu Angilau.
The civil lawsuit filed by the parents of Siale Angilau claimed that marshal was negligent and used excessive force. Siale's sister, Tolina Katoa said she believes race was a factor in how everything played out.
"They wouldn't have shot him if he was a white man. If he was white, they would have tackled him, tased, or use that special training that I know they are trained with," said Katoa.
Otufangavalu Angilau said there's still so many questions in her son's death that it feels like her family doesn't deserve answers.
"As a brown person, it feels like they think, 'Oh, they're dumb. They're poor. They cannot do anything,'" said Siale's mother.
Angilau's family said they felt like the media portrayed Siale as a monster. They want the public to know that he was a good person.
"Honestly, Siale would give his shirt to anybody if they needed. He was that type. His stature was big, but that's just because he had a big heart," said Katoa.
"He's a good boy. No matter what people think, he's a good boy," said Siale's mother.
On Friday, the court ruled to release the courtroom video to the media, the same day it ruled against the Angilau's family lawsuit.
"It was a motion for summary judgment brought by the federal government against my clients saying, 'There's no triable issue here,'" said Robert Sykes, Angilau family's attorney. "The general rule is that deadly force cannot be used unless the officer or some other person is in immediate danger of death or serious bodily injury. The witness that Siale was attacking had slipped out the back of the witness box. He wasn't at risk. The deputy wasn't at risk. There were lots of other people. He didn't need to be killed. I think that was excessive force."
Sykes said he finds it suspicious that it took approximately three years to obtain the courtroom video of the shooting.
"I think they're hiding something. Now I don't know that for sure. I put out, I think it was 23 inquiries. I asked the federal court in SLC, I asked the FBI, I asked the U.S. marshal service, I asked the Department of Justice, and I sent out FOIA requests," said Sykes. "The only response I ever had was, 'We're working on your request.' That's it. It's the only response I ever had. They never gave me anything until the court compelled them to. Still to this day, we have not seen any written reports of this."
Sykes said he and the family have 30 days to decide if they will appeal the judge's decision. Angilau's family said they plan on appealing it.
Katoa said the lawsuit is not about money, but bringing closure for her parents.
"All our mom and dad want is an apology, face-to-face," said Katoa.
Katoa said they will not stop until they can bring justice to Siale.
"We're going to keep fighting. We're going to make sure that marshal's brought to justice," said Katoa
Live by the sword, die by the sword. Just another dead thug.
Yes, obviously in this case, he just wanted to hand the witness a pencil so that they could exchange phone numbers and be friends.
Mamma should be happy and proud!
For the first time in his otherwise worthless life, her son served some purpose on this earth - target practice.
Who in the world was able to gun down the defendant’s entire family?
No security? I thought they had metal detectors and the like.
Who is left to appeal?
Live by the sword, die by the sword. Just another dead thug.
Live by the pen, die by the female Marshal. Fixed it for you.
The pen was not mightier that day.
Whoever wrote the headline should not be allowed to live by the pen.
“””She said Siale was close to completing his prison sentence for charges of federal racketeering associated with his ties to a Tongan crip gang. She said he wanted to turn his life around, but he never got that chance. “”””””””
I have heard that before somewhere.
........Gee, where have we heard that before? I suppose he wanted to turn his life around AFTER he attacked the witness with an ink pen................
This looks like a classic case of excessive force by a female LEO. I seriously doubt most male marshals would have put 4 rounds in him while he was face down and armed only with a pen.
Another din do nuffin award winner here. The video is worth watching, IMO.
Whenever someone says it's not about the money, it's about the money.
“He’s a good boy. He’s a very good boy,” said his mother.
Hmmm, must have been a case of mistaken identity, as he was also a Tongan Crip gangbanger who was already serving time for some of his previous legal errors. The U.S. Marshall eliminated the threat, efficiently and without regard to skin tone or ethnicity. She reacted, appropriately, to the circumstances the deceased created immediately before he became deceased. Well done.
“he was a good boy...”
Until he wasn’t...
Or, "the bullet is mightier than the pen."
I must admit, I am VERY impressed how well Tongan mothers have adapted to the U.S. zeitgeist:
If there is less than zero chance to win on appeal that’s the chance I would give them.
ive by the sword, die by the sword. Just another dead thug.
It’s not.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.