Posted on 04/16/2014 9:08:34 PM PDT by dangus
No, Putin isn't re-building the third Reich: Chamberlain isn't a historic villain because he did nothing after Hitler seized neighboring German-speaking territories. He's a historic villain because he did nothing after Hitler blamed Christianity for poisoning Europe with weakness, swore to destroy the Jews, build a master race, set fire to the Reichstag, seized all police powers, built concentration camps and THEN invaded German-speaking lands.
No, Putin isn't re-building the Soviet Union: He has implemented a flat, low tax rate, struck the authority of local commissars to impose taxes, decriminalized tax disputes, decentralized agriculture and industry, seen the numbers of abortions decrease 83%, and championed Christianity in the public square.
No, Putin isn't building Aleksandr Dugan's Eurasia, a concept that sounds almost as if it were written by the C.I.A. to justify paranoia and panic. Dugin has been called a trusted advisor to Putin. In fact, Dugin and his allies have been enemies of Putin since before the fall of Gorbachev. Dugin is to Putin what Pat Buchanan is to Barrack Obama, what Rev. Wright is to George W. Bush. Dugin's Eurasia is a communist-Islamicist alliance, whereas Putin has been deeply ingratiating himself as a devout Orthodox Christian.
One thing everyone who has met him, whether Bush supposedly seeing into his soul, or Clinton's loathing the sight of him, is that Putin is a pragmatist, not a crazed ideologue like Hitler, Stalin, Dugan or Zhirinovski. Even his Christianity is pragmatic: He's no like King Henry IV of France, who feigned Catholicism because one mass was a small price to pay for Paris. No, he believes in Christianity because he believes it works. While this sounds grating to the Protestant ear, bear in mind the Orthodox revere Emperor Constantine as a great saint. Western Catholics and Enlightenment-era Protestants might even call it "Natural Law." And the re-Christianization of Russia is progressing rapidly. (If you're such the believer that works and justice have nothing to do with Christianity, it's at least the re-Orthodoxidation?)
In 1991, only 30% of Russians considered themselves Christian. In 2001, that number increased to 51%. Today, the same poll says 73% do. Another poll says 82% of Russians consider themselves Christian. Millions of Muslims have converted. (2 million had by 2005, and reports say the rate of conversions has increased.)
Christian morality is coming back, and Putin's government is leading the char gem crusading against abortion, childlessness, divorce, and alcoholism. As I mentioned, abortion is down an astounding 83%. But parenting is also up more than 50%. And life expectancy has risen 5 years in just the last 8 calendar years.
Putin cannot achieve his goals largely by military annexation. He needs to keep a Duma that supports him, and the leftists coalition of socialist, communists, pensioners and Eurasianists have closed the gap on his right-wing alliance. He can't afford more opponents, politically, economically or militarily. In fact, Russia so far has declined to annex South Ossetia, Transdneiper, Nagorno-Karabakh or Abkhazia; Crimea was an exception because it had been so long Russian and was so dominated by Russian people. He also must seduce allies to his side, and one is seldom seduced by another who has been seen raping a third. If the Donbas region of the Ukraine (Donetsk, Luhansk, etc.) becomes part of Russia, Putin must be able to convince Russophiles that they did so willingly. Any further intrusions into the Ukraine will come years later, should other oblasts (counties) decide that annexation has profited the Donbas.
Putin has defended Christians in the Middle East while the West has sided with Islamicist radicals. Putin will continue to seek a constructive relationship with Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Israel and Egypt. (Yes, Israel is turning away from America as a fickle ally who punishes her friends and coddles her enemies.)
The Eurasian Economic Community consists of Russia, Belarus, and Kazakhstan, and will likely soon include Armenia, Georgia, Kyrgystan, Moldova and Tajikistan. Kyrgystan, Tajikistan and Kazakhstan are majority-Muslim nations with sizable Christian minorities, like Syria, Lebanon and Egypt. Putin's involvement in Egypt, Israel and Syria demonstrates that the Christian communities in these nations will have a defender. Russia may well be Christianity's best shot for maintaining a foothold in the Islamic world.
If he's really ambitious, Putin may hope that the whole of the Orthodox world may be attracted to Russia, and to expand the Russian-led customs union to Greece, Romania, Serbia, etc. But military aggression would be deadly to such ambitions.
Russia abolished serfdom before Lincoln issued the Emancipation Proclamation, so don't misread me. But what Putin wants is a modern Russian Empire. And if his methods aren't evil, I'm pretty sure that's not a bad thing.
Interesting article. It has been every Russian Tsars dream to control the Bosphorus and the Dardenelles I wonder if Erdogan in Turkey is a bit nervous. Will a RussiN atyets sing the mass in a restored Haigha Sophia?
bttt - thanks for posting.
bttt - thanks for posting.
“rebuilding his country”
Yeah, by annexing parts of another sovereign country, jailing opponents (if not killed outright), all while scooping in millions of rubles for himself.
Like someone said earlier, this Putin-love on FR has become revolting.
You lost confidence in the US? No one is preventing you from finding a place more suitable to your tastes.
Else, you’re just an old man yelling at clouds.
So it seems. I think some of it comes from the fact that he is such a nemesis for President Barack O'Stinkburger. Personally, I would like to see both of them locked up in the same room.
Yeah, but in this case “the enemy of your enemy” is still just your enemy.
The ironic thing is, during the Reagan years, we used to tell the Soviet loving Left to “love the US or leave it”. Now, I find myself saying that to so-called “conservatives”.
Useful idiots indeed.
Yeah because the Russian Empire Was such a great deal and beloved by all the ethnic minorities it enslaved. Why it was called the Prison of Nations LONG before it was Sovietized. No thanks. Non Russians want nothing to do with it.
Because Israel is smart enough not to antagonize Russia when it’s in aggressive mode, and the US is the worlds worst strategic partner right now. See my tag.
Amen Brother ......tell it like it is.
His job is to save Mother Russia. Salvation is hard work.
The job is even more difficult when the men are alcoholic and the women cease bearing kids and there is no manufacturing base besides arm to create jobs
Why shouldn’t he?
because Ukraine isn’t HIS country.
I know you Russians need Ukraine to survive, and I know you will make every effort to make it happen. But it is sure as hell a disgusting role you’ve carved out for yourself.
And now you morons are equating Putin with Reagan?
Holy crap.
All but a handful of Russians who ever committed any atrocities in the name of communism are dead. Kind of like blaming living Americans for slavery and witchcraft trials.
Nah, the Soviets, they’re all still there, and rebuilding.
Americans don’t go around advocating for slavery.
Russians are actively advocating another Soviet union.
“And now you morons are equating Putin with Reagan?”
LOLOLOLOLOLOL! OH, your reading comprehension is sooooo bad.
Exactly.
I find it ironic that the same people that applaud Reagan’s dismantling of the Soviet Union are the same people that don’t understand that Putin is rebuilding HIS country. Why shouldn’t he?
***********
Among the many ills that spring from malice, one is pettiness. There is a certain kind of person who relishes seeing others in a down position, and nothing makes them seethe like seeing those others get back up on their feet and carry on.
Your data is old.
The number of abortions has been cut in half again since 2008, while the number of live births is up 40%.
Russia has even prohibited abortion after 12 weeks.
That’s it: Change the topic.
No, I fact-checked myself before publishing. The Russian serfs were liberated in 1861. The Emancipation Proclamation was in 1863.
Erdogan has been acting very strangely. While the Islamicist-Communist Eurasianists aren’t in control in Russia, they have a surprising popularity in Turkey, which I cannot explain. And I can’t relate it to this surprising fact:
After Russia seized Crimea, Erdogan suggested that abuse of the Tatars (a largely Muslim ethnic group in Crimea that is related to Turks) could result in Turkey closing the straits of Bosphorus and the Dardenelles to Russia. The problem is that Russia long ago secured a guaranteed right-of-way through the straits, signed by virtually every world power. So doing so would justify Russian warships securing those rights.
As you probably realize, the Blue Mosque/ Hagia Sophia just out into the Straits on a tiny spit of land.
Do note the remarkable progress made on all of those fronts.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.