Posted on 06/10/2009 4:24:14 PM PDT by cdchik123
Salon’s Joan Walsh, on Wednesday night’s "Hardball," cited "conservatives" like Rush Limbaugh, Michelle Malkin and Bill O’Reilly for "whipping up" a climate that sparks the likes of alleged Holocaust Museum shooter James Von Brunn and "Hardball" host Chris Matthews wondered if access to guns were to blame as he cried, "It’s easier to get your hands on a gun than to get somebody to make you a waffle."
The following exchanges were aired on the June 10 edition of "Hardball":
CHRIS MATTHEWS: Joan Walsh this is a political action today by a far right extremist. I just wonder what's in the water, what's in the air as we speak?
JOAN WALSH, SALON: Well I wonder too, especially in the wake of the murder of Dr. George Tiller who performed abortions, another, another really unhinged right wing nut job. And, and I want to be very careful here Chris. The only people responsible are the people who pulled the triggers. Unless we find out that these guys had help, that may be a different story. But from what we know now the people responsible are the killers. However I don't think you can deny that there is a rising climate of right wing hate, a lot of it directed at Obama. You and I go way back to the beginning of the campaign and the level of craziness. He's a secret Muslim. He hates America. He wasn't born here. Now this guy, Von Brunn, he's, he, he was one of the birthers. He didn't believe in Obama's birth certificate and he was constantly online agitating about that. There is a very disturbing and disturbed element of political discourse. And I would, I would throw in Rush Limbaugh.
(Excerpt) Read more at newsbusters.org ...
...
WALSH: Chris can I make a point-
MATTHEWS: Sure.
WALSH: -about the DHS report too, that I think is relevant. Susan [Page] hits the high points. It also says that, you know, the single biggest danger, in their view, are lone wolves and that looks prescient today too. But what, if you look back at the way Janet Napolitano, who didn't even write it, it was commissioned by the Bush, by the Bush White House, if you look back at the way she was vilified, at Rush Limbaugh, and Michelle Malkin and that whole right wing echo chamber acting as though it was now open season on conservatives, they have this incredible capacity-
MATTHEWS: Yeah.
WALSH: -to be shrill, to polarize. And I don't know what happened to that report? It got shelved until today. Susan and I read it. You know I hadn't read it, when it came out. It's very calm.
MATTHEWS: Well let me ask you Sue, we live in a country where it's easier to get your hands on a gun than to get somebody to make you a waffle. It's easy! It is totally easy in this country. We believe in the First Amendment. Our Constitution is protected. The right to bear arms is an individual right, as recently reviewed by the Supreme Court. It's a fact of life. You put together the, the prevalence of guns in this country. The easiness with which someone can engage in gunplay and gun smoke, in this case, where people can be killed it doesn't surprise me. I wonder whether if in a free society violence is always gonna be part of it, if guns are available and people are allowed to walk into places like the Holocaust Museum?
...
A little later in the program Matthews asks if "conservatives" need to tone down their rhetoric to which USA Today’s Susan Page more reasonably points out that she didn’t think it was fair "to conflate being a conservative with fringe groups," that engage in violence. And for her part Walsh tried to walk back her position as she said she didn’t blame "conservatives" or "mainstream Republicans" for the shooting but nevertheless went on to continue to cite their "rhetoric," as a cause for the shooting.
MATTHEWS: Susan you first. You know we've grown up in a country where there's been an extreme, generally on the right, sometimes on the left. Lee Harvey Oswald clearly was fascinated and in love with, infatuated with, with Fidel Castro when he killed Kennedy. This thing here where you have a person who claims to be or is actually anti-Semitic, anti-black, anti-Catholic, I guess on the periphery, which is the big three of the KKK historically. What do we do with this? Are we gonna hear from conservatives who are gonna start saying, "Well let's stop some of this black helicopter talk. Let's stop this villainization of the government, of the establishment." Which way do you think the tone of the debate is gonna go now?
SUSAN PAGE, USA TODAY: Well I don't think it's really fair to conflate being a conservative with these fringe groups that engage in this, in this kind of violence. I mean that's, you can be a critic of the Obama administration without endorsing these, these kind of views and certainly these, these actions. But I do, yeah I do think this sparks a kind of debate and concern about, about what's happening with politics.
...
WALSH: And I will say, you know, I do hope that some conservatives do stand up. I don't blame them, I don't blame mainstream Republicans by any means for this. I want to be clear. But they could help in ratcheting down some of the rhetoric. When Bill O'Reilly goes on TV every night and calls Dr. Tiller a baby-killer and a Nazi and a Mengele and shows where he works I, why do we put up with that? Why is that entertainment in our culture? Demonizing a private citizen for doing a lawful job. Why, why, why, why are people doing that? Why is that acceptable? I would like to see a debate about that.
Incidentally while Walsh slammed O’Reilly for "demonizing a private citizen," it was Matthews, earlier on Wednesday night’s show during a segment on the future of the GOP, who actually compared Newt Gingrich to the devil:
MATTHEWS: Doug it’s not too cartoonish to describe Rush Limbaugh as sort of a walrus under water. That’s what he talks like. Whu, whu, whu. He’s like a drowning walrus the way he talks. And then you’ve got Newt Gingrich who’s clearly a, well he looks like a Mephistopheles. And then this guy, well, well Cheney is a troll. So you got a troll, a walrus and the devil as your cartoon characters. Can’t you guys find more attractive figures that the right might rally too?
Gee I thought Rush supported Israel and opposed the Holocaust. silly me.
It would arguably be an even more justifiable to posit in the public discussions on the matter that it was Obama’s apparent willingness to throw Israel under the bus coupled with Rev Wrights comments about Jews thwarting Obama that served as just the sort of green light James Von Brunn needed to act on his hatred for Jews.
So, if you think that confiscating guns is gonna work, go back to getting leg-tingles while fantasizing about your dream-boat of a 'president'.
Rush’s fault!!!
Crissy had to take a dig at gun ownership as well!!!
Elitist snob won't even make his own waffles!
Wrong. He was part of a left wing group.
The man was a white supremest. He was a NAZI - a supporter the National Socialists Party. Socialists are left wing.
This seriously needs to be corrected by the media.
The guy hated and ranted about Israel, Bush, ‘neocons’, and Zionism.... sounds a lot more like Chrissy Matthews than Rush.
Oh, yeah. Doesn't fit the agenda. Never happened.
Leni
So when it comes out this 89-year old WWII veteran has dementia, will the media report it? Sure...and in the same breath blame Rush, Michelle and O’Reilly for agitating the mentally unstable. They’ll turn the shooter into a victim.
Right wing Christians and most Conservatives support Israel. The left hates Israel.
I still don't understand why the media would call someone from the National Socialist Party a right winger. We're the ones trying to fight Socialism. He comes from one of their socialist fringe groups.
Poor Chrissy - can’t train his wife to make him a waffle when he wants one?
Sorry, ladies, I had to say it. Does that make me a bad person?
Palin? Naaaaa... she's a slut
What will the “useful idiots” like Matthews do when this runs its course?
If the commie’s win, he will no longer be useful, and we know what happens then.
If we defeat them, I hope we have a new Black List.
coulda swore it was Pee Wee Herman, oops, flubbsies.
Perhaps he was listening to Achdamindejad the president of Iran, who actually spouts that line daily.
From her own written bio:
“I’ve written for everyone from the Los Angeles Times and Washington Post to Vogue and the Nation. I love baseball, Bruce Springsteen, Stephen Colbert and long walks on the beach. I live in San Francisco with my daughter, Nora, the best teenager ever.
Ah yes, one of the “long walks on the beach” type females. In other words, too unattractive to get asked out
Ever wonder what Letterman might say about Nora, Joan?
Why? The Oboma administration isn't exactly drumming up love for Israel. Oboma is sucking up to the Muslims while condemning Israel for trying to defend itself.
This guy was on Obomas side.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.