Pumace As A Time Witness (Archaeology)

A chemist of Vienna University of Technology demonstrates how chemical fingerprints of volcanic eruptions and numerous pumice lump finds from archaeological excavations illustrate relations between individual advanced civilisations in the Eastern Mediterranean. Thanks to his tests and to the provenancing of the respective pumice samples to partially far-reaching volcanic eruptions, it became possible to redefine a piece of cultural history from the second millenium B.C. Vienna (TU). During the Bronze Age, between the years 3000 and 1000 B.C., the Mediterranean was already intensely populated. Each individual culture, whether it may be the Egyptian one, the Syrian one, or the Minoan culture from Santorini, has in most cases its own well-researched, chronological history. However, the connection between these individual cultures and locations is often missing for the most part because more often than not, there is no correspondence or similar exchange that has taken place, has been preserved, or is comprehensible. It is so much more difficult to synchronize the individual cultures among themselves.

An international research program of the Austrian Science Fund (FWF) called "SCIEM2000" is now opening new perspectives in this field. A research team of the Atomic Institute of the Austrian Universities under the leadership of Professor Max Bichler is engaged in identifying volcanic rocks from archaeological excavations. Georg Steinhauser, Project Assistant and Chemist at the Department of Radiation Physical Analysis and Radiochemistry of the Atomic Institute says: "Pumice is a foamy volcanic rock. Today, we know the rock that is floating on water mainly as a cosmetic remedy for instance for sole callus." Pumice was also often used in ancient times as an abrasive and is repeatedly found in archaeological excavations in the Mediterranean Sea. Since volcanoes are not found everywhere, however, intense commercial activities related to this product were unleashed. "In Egypt, pumice was found in ancient workshops. In some of the excavations, there was even rock that still presented the right abrasion traces. They were used to polish sculptures, constructions, bronze objects, and so forth. Chemical tests enable us to trace back from which volcanoes the samples came," explains Georg Steinhauser. Pumice in particular, just like the fine-grained volcano ashes, has a specific chemical composition, a characteristic "cocktail" on trace elements. Based on this, the researchers can generate a chemical fingerprint and can compare it to the data base the way it is done in criminology. Hence, pumices out of the Mediterranean volcanic centres as well as from archaeologically relevant pumice finds are being analysed. If the fingerprint of the find matches that of a rock type in the data base, then the origin can be undoubtedly determined.

So there is the immediate assumption that the Egyptians have surely ordered pumice from Greece. The researchers were able to determine these commercial relations by means of the instrumental neutron-activation analysis (INAA) by which the pumice samples in the research reactor are being irradiated with neutrons and subsequently measured with a gamma spectrometer. This way, the chemical fingerprint is generated with 25 characteristic main and trace elements. "We were able to discover that pumice as a commodity (presumably seaborne) covered distances of up to 2,000 km in the Mediterranean Sea. The eruption of the volcanic island Santorini, about 1,600 B.C., represents a particular time indicator. It was so powerful, that the entire Minoan culture was obliterated. When we find today this layer of ashes respectively pumice in various archaeological excavations, this offers immediately a time marker and enables us to synchronize different cultures. This also enables us to determine which rulers were in power in different locations at a certain time," states Steinhauser. When a pumice lump from Santorini is found in an excavation, we can at least say that the Santorini volcano must have already erupted, and the time of the eruption corresponds consequently to the maximum age of the excavation discovery place.

· join list or digest · view topics · view or post blog · bookmark · post a topic ·
	Gods Graves Glyphs	Thanks Blam. The eruption of the volcanic island Santorini, about 1,600 B.C., represents a particular time indicator. It was so powerful, that the entire Minoan culture was obliterated. When we find today this layer of ashes respectively pumice in various archaeological excavations, this offers immediately a time marker and enables us to synchronize different cultures. This also enables us to determine which rulers were in power in different locations at a certain time," states Steinhauser. When a pumice lump from Santorini is found in an excavation, we can at least say that the Santorini volcano must have already erupted, and the time of the eruption corresponds consequently to the maximum age of the excavation discovery place. That's fascinating. The ash layer generally attributed to the Santorini eruption averages just millimeters in thickness in eastern Crete, and the only place where ashfall can be measured in feet is, AFAIK, on tiny Santorini itself. There's literally no connection between the decline in Minoan civilization and any kind of natural disaster (the sites were burned, decades after the supposed eruption, when the Mycenaeans took over). Sturt Manning, a strong advocate of a supereruption on Thera in the 17th century BC, wrote (in 2000, in a revision), "The Tell el-Dab'a3 samples have now been identified as related to the Kos volcano (Peltz et al. 1999)." Tell el-Dab'a is the Egyptian site where artifacts made of pumice were assumed by everyone (since no one had bothered to check) to have come from the alleged supereruption of Thera. I'd also note that the Kos eruption so referred to took place 10s of 1000s of years ago, and so one has to wonder why anyone would write that the Greeks had an exclusive supply of pumice at all. :') To all -- please ping me to other topics which are appropriate for the GGG list. GGG managers are Blam, StayAt HomeMother, and Ernest_at_the_Beach
· Google · Archaeologica · ArchaeoBlog · Archaeology magazine · Biblical Archaeology Society · · Mirabilis · Texas AM Anthropology News · Yahoo Anthro & Archaeo · · History or Science & Nature Podcasts · Excerpt, or Link only? · cgk's list of ping lists ·

I read an interesting analysis on the impact of Thera on the demise of the Minoan civilization.

According to this theory, the initial eruption would have caused a significant tsunami (there was a recent PBS story on research on Crete showing significant tsunami damage at the right age). This would have destroyed the port area, as well as killing many of the skilled workers who would have been near the shipyards. The ships at sea would have been able to survive and make it home OK, but there would have been few skilled workers to maintain them and build replacements for any lost, or as they deteriorated. Thus after about a hundred years, the Minoans would no longer have been the major seapower as their ships rotted away, and the Myceneans would have been able to successfully conquer them.

AFAIC, it’s not new research, it’s just another part of the supereruption mythos. The supposed tsunami knocked down a single house. There’s no sign of rapid decline in Minoan sites, just everything going along as if nothing is wrong, then the Minoan sites were sacked by the Mycenaean Greeks. Where the Minoans had been running trade routes, the Mycenaeans took over. This is (at best) difficult to explain with a caldera collapse-induced tsunami, as the side that’s gone points right toward the Greek mainland and most of the major Mycenaean ports. :’)

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.




· join · view topics · view or post blog · bookmark · post new topic ·