Live Replay of SCOTUS Oral Arguments in DC v. Heller (2A case)

C-SPAN ^ | March 18, 2007 | C-SPAN

[NinoFan]

http://www.cspan.org/watch/cs_cspan_wm.asp?Cat=TV&Code=CS

[The KG9 Kid]

That argument died right there on the SCOTUS floor, from what I heard of the justices’ response.

[Virginia Ridgerunner]

I’m listening to Mayor Fenty respond right now. As usual, he’s full of crap!

[the gillman@blacklagoon.com]

Sounded great for the good guys, but I didn’t become a cynical pessimist from endless good times and loyalty of the government to the Constitution.

[BulletBobCo]

[kinsman redeemer]

Fenty - “the majority of citizens...” (he means the “victims”.)

[Domandred]

I’m at 8-1 for Heller, Ginsburg sole dissent. Lowest I see is 6-3 with Ginsburg, Souter and Stevens dissenting, that’s worse case scenario that I see right now.

[Domandred]

Lanier is an idiot too.

[BCR #226]

think Ginsburg will dissent? I don’t know about that.

[Domandred]

Thanks Tivoing that

[Virginia Ridgerunner]

Dellinger’s talking right now. He’s a moron outside of court as well as in.

[Domandred]

That’s the trick. I think dissenting opinion is still going to be sort of on our side in the form of licenses or State Militia membership, but no bannings.

[steve86]

Clarence Thomas is loud, overbearing, and dominating. Wish he would have given someone else a chance to speak.

[RetiredArmy]

If the 2d Amendment wins, it will be a 5-4 on vote. Period. The liberals seek our guns. If by law, theft, or threat. They want them and intend to get them. If ANY one of the Bill of Rights are unConstitutional according to this bunch, such as defeating and taking away our right to possess, then the other Bills are no good either. Freedom of speech, press, religion should go out the window also. Of course, the left would love to control all of those also.

[Domandred]

LOL and I was hoping he would make history by shutting his pie hole for once.

[beltfed308]

Dellenger comes off as brighter :>)

[BCR #226]

My opinion on how the court will rule:

1. DC lost. Lower court ruling will be upheld.
2. The decision will be broad enough to encompass Federal Laws.
3. 2nd will be incorporated.
4. I suspect that several other national statues will go down in flames within this decision.

[Mr. Brightside]

Don’t tell me.

You still think Alan Keyes or Ron Paul will have a chance to appoint a Supreme Court justice.

[beltfed308]

I agree. Confidence is high Houston!

[BCR #226]

Henigan is living in a dream world. You lost buddy.

[lepton]

Did I just hear Clement state that machineguns are more valid under Miller than handguns?????

Under that ruling, they most certainly are.