Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Is 'white' the only color of success?
Christian Science Monitor ^ | October 31, 2005 | Marilyn Gardner

Posted on 10/31/2005 2:11:10 PM PST by Graybeard58

Minorities can have their careers derailed by their tone of voice or hairstyle, a new study shows.

During her years as an attorney for one of the top international law firms in the United States, Angela Williams looked forward to defending clients. But sometimes she was not given the chance.

"When it came time for an opportunity to represent Fortune 500 companies on huge cases, even though I might have had trial experience over and above my white male colleagues, they were chosen," says Ms. Williams, who is African-American.

In an age of diversity, when many companies point with pride to their multicultural workforce, a sobering reality remains: Minority professionals often find their career ambitions thwarted by hidden bias - what workplace experts call the new face of discrimination. "Acting white," they say, can be the price of promotion in a business world where white men account for 98 percent of CEOs and 95 percent of top earners in Fortune 500 companies. Diversity does not always extend to the executive suite.

"Minorities are getting stuck in the early stretches of career structures," says economist Sylvia Ann Hewlett, whose study of minority professionals appears in the November Harvard Business Review. "They are not getting promoted and advanced at a rate commensurate with their weight in the talent pool."

In a survey of more than 1,600 minority professionals, Dr. Hewlett and Princeton professor Cornel West found that sterling credentials can be overshadowed by personal and cultural traits. Everything from cornrows, ethnic jewelry, animated hand gestures, and certain manicures can leave colleagues thinking, "You're different."

Forty years ago, it was very easy to see prejudice, Hewlett notes. "People wore it on their sleeve and enshrined it in law. Today, it's much more subtle, but it's pervasive. Whether it's a tone of voice or hairstyle or accent, the cumulative impact can be brutal and can derail a career."

The study comes just weeks after Neil French, the creative director of WPP Group, reportedly explained the small ranks of female advertising directors by saying that "they don't deserve to make it to the top" because of their family obligations. He resigned over the flap.

While the proverbial glass ceiling remains one obstacle for women and minorities, Hewlett identifies another barrier - a "Jell-O floor" that keeps them mired in negative stereotypes.

Over 40 percent of minority professional women in large corporations say they feel excluded and constrained by "style compliance" - the need to blend into a corporate culture dominated by white men. More than a third of minority men feel the same way.

"The pressure is added for minority professionals because we don't necessarily come from the same background as those in leadership positions, and we haven't had the same experiences," says Williams, a vice president of Sears in Chicago.

A quarter of minority businesswomen worry that they are perceived as "affirmative action" hires. In addition, nearly a third of minority female executives are concerned that their speaking style labels them as lacking leadership potential.

"Asian women executives were convinced that they weren't commanding enough in their tone of voice, and were not assertive," says Hewlett. "African-American managers were quite sure they spoke too loudly, were too threatening."

One woman, a native of India who works as an IT executive at a Fortune 500 company, learned that colleagues regarded her as quiet. "There are people who talk just to be talking," says the woman, who asks not to be identified to protect her job. "That's not my style. People said, 'She's quiet.' Management perceived that I didn't have leadership quality. Eventually people said, 'But when she says something, it's valuable.' The last few years, I haven't heard them talk about this 'quiet' thing."

Both whites and minorities must adapt, she says. "People like me coming to Western society and working here have to figure out that there are certain things you have to do, that you have to project certain things. That becomes part of the norm of being a successful professional leader."

Referring to Americans' views of professionals from India, she says, "There's a stereotype that they're very good technically, you can rely on them, but they're not really the leaders of tomorrow." Yet she is encouraged by changes at her firm. "They're looking for diversity candidates like me who can grow."

Invisibility - not being heard or seen - remains an issue for women of color, says Ella Bell, an associate professor of business at Dartmouth. "If a woman of color speaks up to make her point, it will just plop. A white male will pick it up and all of a sudden it's bells and whistles." White women might have similar experiences, she adds, but not to the same degree.

Professor Bell also notes a reverse challenge: "You become visible when they need an affirmative action poster child to show that they're making a good attempt to connect to minority communities. That kind of visibility doesn't contribute to the bottom line, so it doesn't help when it comes to promotions."

Another form of invisibility occurs outside the office. To a much greater degree than their white peers, minority professionals spend off-hours doing charitable work. One-quarter are religious leaders. Nearly 30 percent are mentors to needy young people. Forty percent engage in a variety of social outreach activities. Yet many remain silent at work about this service.

"The work they do in minority communities, which is leadership, is very important, but their corporate managers never know about it," Bell says. "It doesn't get counted. Meanwhile, John Doe, who happens to be Caucasian, is on the United Way board or the arts council. It's a big deal."

Hewlett tells of a young woman who formed Girl Scout troops at homeless shelters in Washington, D.C. She received an award at the White House for her work but had not told her boss about it.

"She was afraid to," Hewlett says. "She thought it would imply that a homeless shelter was the kind of background she came from, and she didn't want to be stuck with that label."

Being open about outside activities can bring rewards. When Sears hired Williams as chief compliance and ethics officer, she was told that part of the reason she was hired was because she was both a successful lawyer and an ordained Baptist minister. "The general counsel said to me, 'Who better to be the conscience of the company than a lawyer and a minister in one person?' If people really felt free to let corporate America know the things they are involved with outside their 9-to-5 jobs, that can be an enhancement to their performance on the job."

Williams, who counts fewer than five minority CEOs of Fortune 500 companies, sees progress. But, she adds, "We still have a long way to go."

Eral Burks, CEO of Minority Executive Search in Cleveland, also finds bias camouflaged.

"Companies talk about bringing on more minority board members and senior executive staff, but they're always finding excuses why they won't hire a prospective candidate," he says. "They weren't really interested in hiring, but it looks good that they brought people in. A lot of companies don't think there are qualified minority candidates."

Some firms are designing strategies to combat hidden bias. These include benefits that serve extended families.

Pointing out that minorities have spending power, Mr. Burks says, "They're going to be buying your product or service. They're starting to look at companies and say, 'Why should we spend our money here if your senior staff looks a totally different color?' "

Some CEOs, he adds, "are becoming aware that it makes good business sense to get senior-level staff on their team. They're very positive about wanting to hire more executive minorities and women candidates."


TOPICS: Business/Economy; Culture/Society
KEYWORDS: aa; affirmativeaction; diversity; racism; workplace
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 281-290 next last
To: Terabitten
"In fairness, though, I've seen the same thing happen with white males who have thick southern accents. They'd be very professional, but when they spoke to certain people they'd suddenly go completely redneck. I'm sure it was every bit as career-stopping as my former manager's behavior."

They may not even be conscious of it. My wife noted that whenever I "go home" to the South and start talking with old friends, that I immediately "revert" to "Southern-speak".

Problem was, I had no idea that I was doing so---it was totally subconscious.

61 posted on 10/31/2005 2:47:10 PM PST by Wonder Warthog (The Hog of Steel)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]

To: Smogger
That and people whining about reverse discrimination

I want you to show me where I was "whining about reverse discrimination".

62 posted on 10/31/2005 2:47:33 PM PST by gaijin
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 51 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58

The truth is that minorities are unfairly given opportunities they do not deserve, because of affirmative action. If they want to correct the situation, then eliminate affirmative action and all minority set asides. When there is fair acceptance, then people will know you got the job legitimately, and not because your only qualification was skin color. The minorities should do what white males do, when they are discriminated against, they start there own companies.

Also, why do these cry pieces never mention, Oprah Winfrey, or Bill Cosby, or the sport figures who are some of the richest people in the country. They have seemed to do just fine and did not need affirmative action.


63 posted on 10/31/2005 2:47:37 PM PST by Exton1
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58
While the proverbial glass ceiling remains one obstacle for women and minorities, Hewlett identifies another barrier - a "Jell-O floor" that keeps them mired in negative stereotypes.

Negative stereotypes, like 'women are more likely to sue for sexual harassment'?

64 posted on 10/31/2005 2:47:47 PM PST by randog (What the....?!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: RHINO369
have no idea what it is but alot of minorities i meet at college, are loud, and they don't speak proper english. It's not like they can't speak english, they just don't. I don't why everything thinks people, or society shouldn't make you do anything, but thats all life ever is.

I know many of these folks personally, and all of them found out the hard way that you can't act like an "NWA" if you want to get ahead in the white collar world. A female friend of mine was frustrated by this at first, but learned to adjust.

65 posted on 10/31/2005 2:48:03 PM PST by Clemenza (In League with the Freemasons, The Bilderbergers, and the Learned Elders of Zion)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 26 | View Replies]

To: gaijin

That comment wasn't directed at you.


66 posted on 10/31/2005 2:48:34 PM PST by Smogger
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 62 | View Replies]

To: Smogger
That and people whining about reverse discrimination, which as find as annoying as baseless claims of discrimination.

Why not just say you find all claims of discrimation annoying.
67 posted on 10/31/2005 2:49:39 PM PST by darbymcgill
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 51 | View Replies]

To: Wonder Warthog
They may not even be conscious of it. My wife noted that whenever I "go home" to the South and start talking with old friends, that I immediately "revert" to "Southern-speak".

I catch myself doing that too, then I just tell myself, "well, I must be bilingual"

68 posted on 10/31/2005 2:50:11 PM PST by Graybeard58 (Remember and pray for Sgt. Matt Maupin - MIA/POW- Iraq since 04/09/04)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 61 | View Replies]

To: Terabitten
"I worked for a black woman at a Fortune 500 company. She was a manager, but I guarantee she will never go any higher because of her tendency to go "ghetto" when she was talking with other black women. I'd come up to her with a question, and she would be very businesslike and professional. If she was speaking to another black woman, though, she would immediately go into ghetto-speak. In fairness, though, I've seen the same thing happen with white males who have thick southern accents. They'd be very professional, but when they spoke to certain people they'd suddenly go completely redneck. I'm sure it was every bit as career-stopping as my former manager's behavior." Exactly - this isn't a race issue it's a class issue.
69 posted on 10/31/2005 2:52:51 PM PST by bluetone006 (Peace - or I guess war if given no other option)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 18 | View Replies]

To: gaijin

"I'm dying to know what "acting white" is..."

It means being educated and competant.


70 posted on 10/31/2005 2:52:58 PM PST by BadAndy (Unnecessarily harsh)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 2 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58

"In a survey of more than 1,600 minority professionals, Dr. Hewlett and Princeton professor Cornel West found that sterling credentials can be overshadowed by personal and cultural traits. Everything from cornrows, ethnic jewelry, animated hand gestures, and certain manicures can leave colleagues thinking, "You're different." "



Lemme see if I understand this.

Minorities come to work with baggy low-riding pants, corn rows, T-shirts that say "Kill the Honkeys", and/or jewelry that make them stand out as different ... and then complain that people view them as different and don't take them seriously. Duhh!

Women come to work wearing short skirts, low cut blouses, lots of perfume ... and then complain that men keep hitting on them and don't take them seriously. Duhh!

And I as a consumer, before I buy that loaf of bread, or jar of peanut butter, or that can of beans, or bicycle, or automobile, or ... I always look up the company to find out if its executives have people of my ethnicity in its corporate management or board of directors. Yeah, right. This is just race pimp rhetoric.

Many years ago, I bought went to a grocery store and a young black male in a suit bagged my groceries. I asked him why he was wearing a suit ... and he said that his mother had emphasized that he needed to look professional at all times. He was well spoken, and sounded intelligent. I found out he was an engineering student, with good grades, working as a bagger to help pay his way through college. As far as I was concerned, white or black or brown, he had qualities that I thought would be valuable wherever he went. So ...

The next day, I brought him an application to go to work at the Aerospace company where I worked. I pointed out that if he was hired, they would pay for his tuition in engineering, he would gain experience in engineering (which would help his academic work), and he might even get a pay raise. And it appeared that my company would gain a valuable employee.

Long story short -- he submitted the application for an engineering aid job, was hired, graduated as an Engineer, and began a success-filled engineering career at the company.

Was he "acting white"??

Was it racist of me to select him for my attention? Because I admit that if that same person had bagged my groceries wearing baggy pants, jewelry, sporting corn-rows, and speaking ebonics ... I don't think I would have recognized his potential and wouldn't have made the effort to help him (and my company).

Each person selects his clothing and demeaner to project a specific set of qualities to the outside world. One should not then complain if they are judged based on those qualities.


71 posted on 10/31/2005 2:52:59 PM PST by Mack the knife
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58

racism is a word used by some to try and take advantage of other people-those that pretend not to be racist are in state of confusion-charles rangel is the perfect example-if i don't want to do certain things does it make me evil-hell no-it makes the person or group trying to force me to do what they want arrogant-if GOD had of intended us to be the same he would have made us that way-don't never let groups such as churches, clubs, gov'ts tell you what you must do not to be racist-because if they do they are the racist not you-communisn in the form of democracy is evil


72 posted on 10/31/2005 2:53:11 PM PST by catmanblack. (he is the great I AM-)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: MeanWestTexan

See, now, that's what I want to do . . . the question is where the market exists for someone with my skill set to be used as a consultant.


73 posted on 10/31/2005 2:53:20 PM PST by Xenalyte (I dare you to make less sense.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 30 | View Replies]

Comment #74 Removed by Moderator

To: Clock King

Believe it or not, when not before cameras Bush speaks much more sharply and with almost no discernible regional accent.


75 posted on 10/31/2005 2:54:40 PM PST by Xenalyte (I dare you to make less sense.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 42 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58

Total manure.

When you have "educated" lawyers who still use slang and mispronunciations like "aks" for ask or pronouce the "t" in often like an illiterate, of course those will be picked up.

It has nothing to do with skin color, it has everything to do with proper english.


76 posted on 10/31/2005 2:55:13 PM PST by longtermmemmory (VOTE!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58
Everything from cornrows, ethnic jewelry, animated hand gestures, and certain manicures can leave colleagues thinking, "You're different."

I don't think you'll see many white professionals rising to high positions while sporting complicated hairdos (whether cornrows or mounds of artificial curls), large/loud jewelry (whether of a "minority ethnic" style or the stuff WASPy and Jewish grandmothers are notorious for), or "certain manicures" that obviously interfere with the use of the hands and advertise that the wearer is very determined that people focus attention on her fingernails. And "animated had gestures" are for people who have trouble expressing themselves orally -- also a career-killer for for anyone of any racial or economic background.

77 posted on 10/31/2005 2:57:10 PM PST by GovernmentShrinker
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Mack the knife

I would SO buy a t-shirt that said "Kill the Honkeys."


78 posted on 10/31/2005 2:57:22 PM PST by Xenalyte (I dare you to make less sense.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 71 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58
Gee, where to start?

This has far more to do with socioeconomic class than it has to do with ethnic group.

What is apparently invisible to the ethnic minorities quoted herein and, seemingly, the authoress, is that the very same thing happens to working class and middle class whites in upper crust law firms, corporations, and brokerages. And it has always been that way.

There are all sorts of little cultural cues that people give off which, if one is not a member of the particular "inside" class or caste are all but invisible, but if one is, are all but impossible to miss. These are not taught, but they are learned. They have to do with clothing choices, eyeglass frames, jewelry (more accurately, the lack of jewelry), verbal syntax, accent, conversational topics, interests, body language, and on and on and on. It is another form of education, and it begins very shortly after birth.

That lack is what the authoress, and her subjects, are missing but do not realize that they are missing. And at this point in their lives they are highly unlikely to be able to learn enough to be able to "pass", even in the allegedly classless American society. This, too, has always been this way. There may be tutors who are able to convey and teach theses cultural cues available - think about the character of Professor Higgins in "My Fair Lady" and you get close to the mark - but I doubt that there are very many.

79 posted on 10/31/2005 2:59:48 PM PST by surely_you_jest
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Graybeard58

where's the projectile vomit alert?


80 posted on 10/31/2005 3:01:04 PM PST by wardaddy (It's Manana Again in America!)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20 ... 41-6061-8081-100 ... 281-290 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson