And then someone would make a judgment about the state of their soul
You made a very clear statement that the born again's "spirit" can't sin, only their soul sins.
MHG made a very clear statement that their body sins, but their spirit does not sin.
Ravi Z by all accounts did sin - even if it was not the things he was accused of (I'm not convinced by the stories about him) - but you are saying that his body and his soul sinned but his spirit did not sin - so does that mean Ravi sinned or didn't sin?