Posted on 11/22/2016 10:04:54 AM PST by SeekAndFind
I believe in a soul, but his theory is not science. This is gobbly gook “new age” type magical thinking posing as science.
Depends on who “you” are. A bag of bones? Or the conscious experiencer of that bag, who can live independently of it?
Can you prove that one lives and still has experiences after their body dies?
Hearsay or religious stories are not proofs.
Saying the bible is proof is like saying comic books prove Superman,Spiderman and Batman are real beings that are alive.
“You cannot realize ANYTHING once you die.”
There is only one way you can prove this is proof.
“things behave quite differently depending on whether we are observing them or not.”
The “interference” of OBSERVING is a physical event and of course has consequences. Also “observing” requires a sentient being to do so.( or at least an item made by someone for measuring an event)) The actual event, say the collision of atoms occurs whether ‘observed’, OR NOT..
I do not remember a thing before I was born.
I did not exist then. When things die they cease to exist.
You want to know what happens after death? Go look at some dead things. They decompose and it’s the carbon cycle.
It is impossible to know anything before existence and after existence. WHY? because you must be self aware and traveling through time forward as we experience everything as past, even the now. Science has proven that even light hitting your eyes takes about 2 thousandths of a second for your brain to register it and form a picture of it.
It is logical therefore you cannot experience your own death, so all you will ever possibly know is your own existence and to you as with any sentient creature will not experience death, ever, as that is impossible.
“The actual event, say the collision of atoms occurs whether observed, OR NOT..”
Not necessarily, or the double-slit experiment would be elementary to explain.
That's why spiritual experience is so powerful. It's why trillions of people over time have pursued a spiritual path. There's something there. To one who has experienced the soul or divinity, it's as obvious as the sun. To one who has not, it's incomprehensible.
We're dealing with infinite Reality here. Your pronouncements on what does or does not exist, based on the tiny slice of Reality you currently perceive, are laughable. The parable of the blind men and the elephant comes to mind.
“so all you will ever possibly know is your own existence”
Well of course that is obvious if you are right but no so obvious if you are not right. Not much point in debating the point, death will come enough.
The Bible that I believe says that flesh and blood will not inherit the Kingdom of God. I also believe that this planet is obviously without hope and therefore doomed and salvation is only through Christ’s sacrifice and his resurrection.
Gentlemen songsters off on a spree, dammed from here to eternity, God have mercy on such as me
“Baa!Baa!Baa!
“We’re dealing with infinite Reality here. Your pronouncements on what does or does not exist, based on the tiny slice of Reality you currently perceive, are laughable. The parable of the blind men and the elephant comes to mind.”
You have an extremely huge ego. Your perceptions seem delusional, and you offer no proof whatsoever.
“That’s why spiritual experience is so powerful. It’s why trillions of people over time have pursued a spiritual path. There’s something there. To one who has experienced the soul or divinity, it’s as obvious as the sun. To one who has not, it’s incomprehensible.”
Spirituality is another term for delusional make-believe. It’s basically masturbation of the mind. Have you submitted to Odin as there is proof to him. He said he killed all the ice giants. Seen any of them around?
“You can’t prove one doesn’t live after death. Look, our sense-based empiric methods of ‘proving’ things are useless to deal with energy outside what our senses perceive.”
You can’t prove anybody does!
ANYTHING beyond the senses is totally irrelevant. All you could do is speculate. It could be argued that since we cannot possibly know of or experience objective reality, is this conversation as well as the known universe taking place in a slice of a laboratory rats brain that the scientist accidentally left out and applied low voltage to over a long weekend?
I’ve seen dead people and animals. They all dissolve away and I have never seen them alive or aware after that.
“The Bible that I believe says that flesh and blood will not inherit the Kingdom of God. I also believe that this planet is obviously without hope and therefore doomed and salvation is only through Christs sacrifice and his resurrection.”
The bible also says that snakes and donkeys talk and you can change goat genetics by having them look at striped sticks!
If this planet is doomed and without hope it would be the blame of the creator for messing it up! Seems he can’t get anything right.
You haven’t actually thought through the Jesus story.
If he was the almighty and came back from the dead,what exactly did he sacrifice? Nothing.
Salvation? from what ? there again. “You’d better believe in me or i’ll fry you in hell, so help me,me.” LMAO!
Your idea of 'proof' has no bearing in the experience beyond your current senses. Just because something is beyond our current empirical sensors, doesn't mean it's not real. For example, imagine you didn't have an olfactory sense. You would have no idea what 'smell' feels like, and if someone said they 'smelled' something, you would say they are crazy and there's no proof.
But smell exists, whether you feel it or not. And a rose smells different than a marigold.
In the world of spirit, your own experience is the only proof there is. There are masters and guides to help you navigate that world, but ultimately, you need to feel something yourself. And when you do, you don't need anymore proof.
Quit asking for proof in your small-minded paradigm. You have to do it yourself. Go practice a mystical path, yoga, or give yourself to Christ. If you are sincere, you will have an experience that will make you laugh at your old self. You will realize you are dot of sand on the shore of a vast ocean of knowledge and experience. Or don't even try, seek security in your limited viewpoint, and call everyone who delights in spirit delusional.
So, do you accept Thor as your personal savior then?
If not, why? Odin will be furious at you!
Just because you haven’t had a vision of Valhalla does not mean it does not exist!
Do you see how insane and delusional those statements are?
WHAT DIFFERENCE IS THERE FROM WHAT YOU WROTE?
You don’t have any proof as that would deny needing any faith.
If you think you need the supposed death of a supposed innocent in your place to go to a place you must first admit you don’t deserve to go to,to begin with, while eating the victim and drinking his blood and wearing a Jesus skin suit to fool the idiot god who fails even at recognizing his own supposed son you must have worse morals than satan himself.
You have an ability to discern truth from untruth, to experience more than what you allow yourself now, but you will need to use a different part of yourself than your empirically verifiable senses. I recommend you try.
But, you can do what you wish. Good luck.
All you need to do is wish Thor into your heart. He cares for you and if you are a true believer a stuffed animal will appear like magic. If not you aren’t believing enough. Have faith in Thor, you can’t see him with your senses you must just use your imagination.
Good luck is not needed as Thor promised to protect me from Ragnarök. Odin is not so idiotic as to leave my own well being up to me, unlike your jealous,frustrated and angry deity. Odin is more believable.
Salvation? from what ? there again. Youd better believe in me or ill fry you in hell, so help me,me. LMAO!
Since you scoff at the Christian belief in Christ’s resurrection and a new life after death, are you implying that Trump should annul and divorce himself from Mike Pence, Ben Carson and all those deplorable evangelicals that supported and voted for him?
Sorry that you disdain the Biblical account of Balaam’s talking jackass but really I have over the years met with many talking jackasses, in fact a lot them can also write on pubic forums on the web!
Exit polls show white evangelical voters voted in high numbers for Donald Trump, 81-16 percent, according to exit poll results. Thats the most they have voted for a Republican presidential candidate since 2004, when they overwhelmingly chose President George W. Bush by a margin of 78-21 percent. Their support for Trump will likely be seen as part of the reason the GOP candidate performed unexpectedly well in Tuesdays election, according to Five Thirty Eight.?
Washington Post.com
RINO Bush played those evangelicals like the superstitious morons they are. You think because I am an atheist I’m a democrat? I don’t believe or support a thing the left says or does. Their god is government.
I support Trump because he’s bright and not a politician.
What his religious beliefs are in his personal life is irrelevant as he has proven he knows how to deal and make money and controlled a huge corporation. Even on his worst day he will be more effective than all the presidents combined since even Carter.
Of course I scoff at christians and muslims as the fundamentalists of both groups are deranged.
The fundamental ones have actually read their holy books are are applying their interpretations of them since they are so vague.
Plato’s allegory of the cave. That’s you.
I am more educated than you are. You haven’t bothered to even read your bible even once through.
Just read it. If you refuse to become atheist after reading it there is no hope for you.
well, bye.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.