Replies

Consider that the Prophecies all ready occurred.

If they already occurred, where are the history books that detail all of the following happening in 70AD:

When was the Gospel preached to all the nations?
Who was the Antichrist?
When and how was the Mark of the Beast implemented? What technology existed in 70AD that would enable one man to number every single person on the face of the earth? What technology existed in 70AD to enable one man to know who had his Mark and who didn't?
Where is the record written anywhere that China had a 200 million man army in 70AD?
Where is it recorded that 100 pound hailstones fell from the sky in 70AD?
Where is it recorded that the Euphrates River was dried up in 70AD and what technology was used to accomplish that?
Why did we have the rebirth if Israel in 1948 if all of the prophecies that pointed to the literal return of Christ already happened?
If Jerusalem was forever removed from being the burdensome stone, why has it now returned to that status?
Where is it recorded that a seven-year peace treaty was confirmed by one man between the nation of Israel and the nations of the world?
Where is it recorded that 25% of the entire world, not just the known world at that time, died by famine, plague, and being put to death by the Antichrist in 70AD?
Where is it recorded that there was a great earthquake on the earth; the sun turned black and the moon turned to blood in 70AD?
Where is it recorded that hail and fire mixed with blood was hurled down upon the entire earth. Where is it recorded that a third of the earth was burned up, a third of the trees were burned up, and all the green grass was burned up in 70AD?

I could go on, but you're going to have enough problems enough finding evidence for your claim that all of that has already occurred without me adding more.

Many of today's Fortune Tellers have been wrong in predicting the Rapture. How many times can a “Prophet” get it wrong before he is a False Prophet? Is there a three strike rule or something?

Because there have been foolish people down through the years who disobeyed God by attempting to predict when the Rapture would occur does not negate the absolute truth of the God-written prophetic Scriptures.

Nor does the fact that we have arrogant, foolish people today who deny those prophetic Scriptures and, when denying the prophetic Scriptures doesn't make them go away, and when the denying doesn't stop the ongoing, daily fulfillment of those prophetic Scriptures in our day, then the name-calling starts.

It's all the Bible-deniers have since God's Own words nuke their stupid, man-created belief systems.

So please do me a favor and refrain from attacking those who are pointing out what is actually written.

Do me a favor and spend some time trying to come up with anything that would prove your assertion that God is either lying or He screwed up when He didn't tell us that His prophecies for Christ's return already happened in the ancient past.

Do me a favor and try to find anything in Scripture that would support your claims.

And when you can't come up with that proof, scroll past threads which involve discussion of end-time prophecies that are being fulfilled on a daily, if not hourly, basis. Like I said before, the prophecy train left the station a long time ago. Don't let too many people know that you missed it.

I understand the position of the post-millennialist, and as a "realized millennialist" I recognize that I can have some interpretational issues that could just as easily have me join their camp - at least the partial preterist division. Ten years ago, I was sanctified out of Dispensationalism, and on a daily basis I find yet more and more reasons to write it off as the apostasy it is.

I know that libraries of books have been written on the subject, and some time on the internet will cover most of the arguments. Speaking of libraries of books, I mostly read 15th through 19th century theological works and I find it interesting, yet not surprising, that the popularity of certain millennial views vary along-side contemporary culture. For example, during the Great Awakening, the great theologians were predominately post-millennial since empirically it appeared to be the trend. The Church at large (worldwide), for the past few thousand years has been primarily amillennial with certain notable groups holding to what is now called "Classical Premillennialism" The Darby/Scofield variety of Premillennialism, appears to be a rather young creature, an outgrowth of the American Religion (Big-Box Churchianity) and slick marketing campaigns designed for wealthy western culture enamored with our own narcissism and a general attitude of treating our LORD as our Cosmic Concierge.

Before I answer a few of "GiovannaNicoletta's" open questions to "Mark was here", I have a few of my own.

Our LORD only speaks of two ages, the Present Age, and the Age to Come. By whose authority do Dispensationalists come up with 4,7 or even 8 different "Dispensations".
What is this obsession with an earthly temple and the resumption of temple sacrifices? Was our LORD's death and resurrection insufficient? Was it not actually finished, but now we must revert to the system of temple sacrifice? What does it say about Christians who are encouraging Jews to continue to reject Jesus Christ and in fact blaspheme the cross by aiding them in recreating the Temple in Jerusalem and goading them into making animal sacrifices? Furthermore, how can God honor any people who reject His Son and favor a resumption of the types rather than the fullfillment.?
1 Corinthians 2:14 says that the natural man cannot understand the things of God since those things are spiritually discerned. Furthermore we have in Revelation 22:7 "Blessed is he who keeps the words of the prophecy of this book." If the way the Dispensationalists handle Revelation is correct, are any of you planning to be here for the Tribulation? Would it be fair to say that those who are "left behind" are not Believers? If so, how do the reprobate receive a blessing, let alone understand any of Revelation since Scripture says that it is "foolishness to them"? From the Dispensationalist's point of view, most of it after Chapter 3 is irrelevant to all of the Church througout her entire history since it only speaks allegedly to those who will suffer the various, seals, bowls and trumpets after all of the Believer's have been "raptured".

When was the Gospel preached to all the nations?
Romans 10:18 - But I say, have they not heard? Yes indeed: "Their sound has gone out to all the earth, And their words to the ends of the world."
Colossians 1:5-6 - "..in the word of the truth of the gospel which has come to you, as it has also in all the world, and is bringing fruit..."
Colossians 1:23 - "if indeed you continue in the faith, grounded and steadfast, and are not moved away from the hope of the gospel which you heard, which was preached to every creature under heaven, of which I, Paul, became a minister."

Who was the Antichrist?
Who needs an Antichrist? The only mention of such a character is in 1 John, and that person is characterized as one who is a deceiver and denies that Jesus is the Christ and denies the Father and the Son. (1 John 2:18-23). In fact, it seems to me that Dispensationlism is trying to make anti-christs by urging the Jews to deny Jesus Christ by building yet another temple in which they can blaspheme our LORD's finished work on the cross by sacrificing critters rather than rely on the Blood of our Savior. Seriously. Why do some Christians want to make a new red heffer, raise money to build another temple, and rebuild the furniture sans the Ark and the contents therein? Isn't that like driving the getaway car to a bank robbery or holding the flashlight while another cracks the safe? Do you sincerely think God will bless that?

Why did we have the rebirth if Israel in 1948 if all of the prophecies that pointed to the literal return of Christ already happened?
There is a secular nation called Israel, two-thirds who are ethnic Jews, who occupy a fragment of the Middle East, So what? In Joshua 21:43, the promise the LORD had sworn to Abraham concerning the Land of Israel was fulfilled. There is no need for a future Israel, that promise was already kept thousands of years ago. If there is a physical nation of Israel or not fulfills no specific orthodox Biblical prophecy. Besides, isn't it more than a generation of time since 1948? Wasn't this the reason why one of the modern day Prophets declared the LORD's return in 1988? There is no Temple Mount, unless our LORD lied in Mark 13:2, Matthew 24:2 or Luke 21:6. The Masjid Qubbat As-Sakhrah (Dome of the Rock) sits on what was formerly the plaza of Fort Antonia where the Roman garrison stayed. The actual temple was immediately to its south, and is no more, because, as our LORD clearly stated, "not one stone will be left upon another". When our LORD makes statements like that, they are meant to be kept, hence no stone will be left upon another to this day and until the End of the Age. I submit that Islam is here to make sure that promise stands.

Where is the record written anywhere that China had a 200 million man army in 70AD?
Where in all of Scripture does it even make reference to China, let alone a 200 million man standing army? This is part of the problem in your questions, all of these questions are based on the fallacy of the Dispensational hermeneutic that all things must convey some hybrid of literalism and selective imagery randomly grabbed from unrelated places in Scripture and universally projected to be in our future. For example, Hal Lindsey taking liberties in calling the clearly symbolic locusts of Rev 9:3 and transforming them into actual US made Apache Helicopters. Are you going to then ask, "Where did the Apache Helicopters with Hellfire missles that took down the Jerusalem Temple in 70AD come from?" Similarly, Hal Lindsey also made up the 200 million Chinese Army by taking some Scripture from Rev 9:15-16 and gratuitously merging it with Rev 16:12. It is a fraud, and the rank and file Dispensationalists are gullible consumers of this dreck.
Let's examine this 200 Million Man March on Jerusalem. That is one-fifth of China's population. China's current military according to wikipedia is presently 2.3 million active, 1.2 reserve. That is a tiny fraction of 200 million. I will grant that those available for military service (age 16-49) is 654 million, three times more than Hal Lindesy says is needed. The present military budget is $80B, or 1.5%% of China's GDP. What do you suppose it would be to handle 100 times that? Remember, the 200 Million is the number who descend upon Jerusalem, that does not include all of those in the supply lines, traingin, communications, logistics, intelligence, command, etc.. Then there is the issue of supply and transport. The Persian Gulf War of 1990-91 included the transport of 500,000 men and their equipment to the region and it took the US with all of its transportation capabilities six months to execute that move. Now amp that up by 400 times for an emerging industrial nation who still buys its navy from the Russians. Then consider the route through or around the Himalayas. The Lindesy Prophecy says that this army will be crossing the Euphrates river by land. Extrapolating the US experience in getting a military fielded in the Middle east, we are talking about 200 years to pull this off. Exactly how is the Chinese budget going to pull that off? Do you have any idea how much fuel and food that is required? And while 200,000,000 men are marching, who is working the fields and factories? Where do the officers come from? How do you conscript, train, assign, house, clothe, feed, march, coordinate these sort of numbers? Furthermore, in anyone's wildest imagination, what sort of military operation has as its only solution decimating its industry to field this kind of military? Its insanity like this that ought to tell the Dispensationalist that maybe this 150 year experiment in anti-orthodox eschatology might be wrong.

GiovannaNicoletta, I simply ask that you take a look at what many generations of devout Christians believed before this largely American fanaticism of Dispensational Premillennialism was invented. There are numerous serious doctrinal problems with Dispensationalism: the most obvious, the dividing of the People of God, the reinstitutionalizing of temple sacrifice, narcissism over humility before God, the reckless profaning of Scripture to sensationalize and sell books and Prophecy Conferences, etc. Its not an easy road to go down. Dispensationalism is sexy because it has violence, and freaks of nature, intrigue and mystery. Fortunately, God didn't isn't trying to compete with Vince Flynn and Brad Thor. Revelation is, as the letter begins, the Revelation of Jesus Christ, not the Antichrist and a continous pattern of cryptic catastrophes. It is about "things which must shortly take place...for the time is near" not thousands and thousands of years later. It was written to the seven churches so that they should "keep those things that are written in it" not for a world full of God hating reprobates who are wondering why planes are crashing to the ground.