[ClearCase_guy]

I've enjoyed your previous reviews, and I completely understand why you're stopping. On the whole, I've thought that Rowling did a petty good job with the books and I thought that she was making at least some attempt (not always successful) to get across a decent moral message.

I was deeply unhappy with the Dumbledore announcement. So uncessary. Such a poke in the eye. So disappointing.

[Antoninus]

I was deeply unhappy with the Dumbledore announcement. So uncessary. Such a poke in the eye. So disappointing.

But hey, the 'experts' are already calling it a "teachable moment" and the "Dumbledore is gay" thing will be discussed by young children all over the world. The Culture of Death got an early Winter Solstice present from Rowling.

[SF Republican]

So unnecessary. Such a poke in the eye. So disappointing.
I think it was a set-up question. Why would a 5 year old kid give a hoot if some old grandpa found true love? Would a kid really ask such a question (on his own)?