Posted on 02/16/2006 8:43:59 AM PST by NYer
PARIS (Reuters) - Encouraged by Pope Benedict's encyclical on love, a Roman Catholic bishop and a group of Christian intellectuals in France are urging the Vatican to reopen the debate on its ban on artificial birth control.
Bishop Francis Deniau told the Catholic magazine Le Pelerin this week that Benedict's first encyclical "Deus Caritas Est" (God is Love), which was widely praised for the positive way it spoke about sexual love, was a hopeful sign for possible change.
Sociologist Catherine Gremion noted the encyclical -- the highest form of papal writing -- did not condemn Catholic couples "who do not manage to live out their love in strict respect for Church teachings".
"That's an important sign," said Gremion, one of the co-authors of a book by Christian intellectuals entitled "The Church and Contraception -- the Urgent Need to Change".
Benedict made clear last November he was not considering any change in the contraception ban and that family planning was only allowed by the "rhythm method" of abstinence from sex during a woman's fertile period.
Pope Paul VI banned contraception in the 1968 encyclical Humanae Vitae, arguing that sexual intercourse was meant for procreation and any artificial method to block a pregnancy went against the nature of the act.
That encyclical prompted Catholics to leave the Church in droves and undercut papal authority. Many practicing Catholics now simply ignore the ban and some say it weakens the Church's message on other moral issues such as abortion and bioethics.
In his encyclical last month, Benedict wrote that the Church was long seen as being "opposed to the body" but it actually believed that erotic love and selfless love were both important aspects of the same phenomenon.
The document was widely praised for its positive tone, which was somewhat surprising because of the stern conservative stand the pope took in his previous post as top Vatican doctrinal expert.
Deniau, bishop of Nevers in eastern France, noted that a papal commission had advised in 1966 to allow it, but Pope Paul ignored their recommendation after consulting several cardinals, including the future Pope John Paul.
"The analyses made by the first commission in 1966, which did not condemn contraception, are worth being reviewed and debated," Deniau said. He said many Catholics found they could not follow the "rhythm method" of family planning.
"It's important that these things are not seen in a rigid fashion," he said.
Coming from a Bishop in France, where the Catholic population has shriveled up. I'm utterly bewildered.
Oh man this will go over like a lead balloon!
What's to debate? There's either faith in God, or faith in science and innovation.
The implication being that only since 1968 has contraception been banned by the Church. This is actually a distortion of history, as far as I understand it. It was actually the Anglican Church, back in the 1930's I believe, that first opened the floodgates to allowing contraception. Since then, every other Protestant Church has followed suit, and now the Catholic Church is the only one still prohibiting it.
For centuries before it was always prohibited. This historical fact alone has changed my view of the ban. I used to be under the impression it was a new, albeit draconian, measure instituted by the Church. Thus, since I felt it was an invention, not reflective of Christian tradition, I didn't think it was valid.
It's amazing when one researches history, how much we think has changed has really remained the same.
A '60s liberal resurfacing for one last outburst, before he enters his dotage.
I guess he's pining for the Islamic takeover to come sooner.
What!?! Pope Paul VI didn't let people vote on what is sin and what isn't?
...they could not follow the "rhythm method" of family planning. "It's important that these things are not seen in a rigid fashion," he said.
Then try Natural Family Planning http://familydoctor.org/126.xml
Bishop Francis Deniau will be 70 this year. Wouldn't it be great to have actual Catholics as Catholic Bishops?
What's interesting is that the individual who reportedly wrote most of Humanae Vitae for Pope Paul VI went on to become Pope John Paul II. I would say that's a strong endorsement from the Holy Ghost.
How so? "Be fruitful and multiply".
Read the book "The Bible and Birth Control"; I believe the author's name is Charles Provan, and I believe he's a Baptist. And I believe you'll find he makes a case that the commandment is not "extra-biblical" at all, but entirely Biblical.
Bishop Deniau completely missed the point of Deus Caritas Est...
NYer, once again you Easterners are off the hook. Only us Romans are idiots for extra-biblical commandments. I think it all started with that worshipping together on Sundays thing. Any good sabbatarian will correctly point out that's not in Scripture.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.