Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Islam versus Democracy Commentary from the National Anxiety Center ^ | June 20, 2003 | Alan Caruba

Posted on 06/20/2003 8:32:22 AM PDT by Stand Watch Listen

The United States may get the electricity going in Iraq and repair its water and sewage systems, but whether it can get Iraqis to adopt a constitutionally based democratic government will prove a difficult, if not impossible, task.

In its 5,000-year history, Iraqis have never played any role in the governance of their nation, and the past three decades of ruthless and barbaric rule by Saddam Hussein have not prepared them for this task.

Among Muslims, only the Turks have experienced any form of self-rule and that was the result of a remarkable man, Ataturk, who literally forced them to accept westernization. In doing so, he imposed a strict divide between Islam and the governing of Turkey. This has been maintained only because the Turkish military has judiciously stepped in time and again to crush any Islamist party seeking to impose the Islam's system of rule.

The religion of Islam and democracy are totally incompatible. Only the separation of church and state, only the rule of civil law can grant Muslims-the vast majority of whom are good, decent people---the freedom they want and many Muslims, such as those in Iran, do want it.

The laws of Islam, considered sacred and inviolable, clash with the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), and those expressed in both the British (1688) and American Bill of Rights (1791). To cite just a few reasons why Islam and democracy are incompatible, under Islam women and non-Muslims are declared to be inferior, slavery is acceptable, punishments for various crimes include amputations, floggings, and stoning to death, a non-Muslim cannot testify against a Muslim, and conversion from Islam carries with it the death penalty.

There is no separation of church and state under Islam and there never can be for any Muslim who accepts the Koran and the Hadith as the sacred rule of law. To suggest otherwise imperils their belief in the Koran as the word of Allah as passed to them by Muhammad, his self-appointed "final" prophet.

In Muslim nations where so-called secular, i.e. socialist governments such as the former Baath Party of Iraq and the current one in Syria exist, the reality is that these nations are run by despots and their governments are mere rubber stamps. In others, such as Saudi Arabia, a self-declared royal family rules. In nations such as Iran, where a secular government is allowed to function, a supreme council of ayatollahs can and does routinely overrule any legislative act, thus rendering democratic rule moot.

Ibn Warraq, the author of a scholarly study of Islam, notes that "Islam continually manifests hostility towards human reason, rationality, and critical discussion without which democracy and scientific and moral progress are not possible. The notion of an individual---a moral person who is capable of making rational decisions and accepting moral responsibility for his free acts---is lacking in Islam. Ethics is reduced to obeying orders."

Freedom is about individual rights granted a citizen that governments may not trespass, nor deprive. As Ibn Warraq points out, "Individualism is not a recognizable feature of Islam; instead, the collective will of the Muslim people is constantly emphasized. There is certainly no notion of individual rights, which only developed in the West, especially during the eighteenth century."

If one's first allegiance, after Islam, is to one's family and tribe, the notion of allegiance to a national entity, is stymied by Islam that allows only for the interpretation of the Koran and the Hadith by mullahs and imams. "Islam never allows the possibility of alternatives," says Warraq. Thus, the concept of debating political issues is foreign to Islamic thought.

The long-term hope is that greater access to information and knowledge will work its way on the inherent intolerance of Islam, that its educational systems will teach the values of democratic rule, that the mosques will be separated from governance, and that the rule of secular, civil law will succeed. The short-term hope is that the worldwide network of Islamic terrorists will be defeated.

Lastly, let it be said that George W. Bush did the right thing to invade Afghanistan and Iraq, and to threaten the despots who rule Iran and Syria. His obligation, his duty to protect the United States of America, is directly tied to the use of American power to transform the Middle East by any means necessary. The greatest threat to America, the West, and to those Islamic nations struggling to achieve democracy and freedom is Islam.

(Alan Caruba writes "Warning Signs," a weekly column posted at the Internet site of The National Anxiety Center.)

Alan Caruba

TOPICS: Editorial; Foreign Affairs
KEYWORDS: caruba; islam
Related Articles:

The Decline and Fall of Islam; Published: June 06, 2003; Author: Alan Caruba

Jihad, Suicide, Murder & Lies
Source:; Published: May 21, 2003; Author: Alan Caruba

The Tip of a Dangerous Iceberg: The threat of militant Islam on American campuses
Source:; Published: April 8, 2003; Author: David Horowitz

Our Enemy is in the Sand
Source: Toogood Reports; Published: 19 March 2003; Author: Nicholas Stix

Islam's Unholy War Commentary from the National Anxiety Center; Published: March 10, 2003; Author:Alan Caruba

Islam As Sedition
Source: Chronicles Magazine; Published: Feb 3, 2003; Author: Srdja Trifkovic

The Dark Side of the Muslim Mind
Source: National Anxiety Center; Published: February 05, 2003; Author: Alan Caruba

Wake Up! Islam Is About More Than Hate Crimes
Source: Toogood Reports; Published: January 29, 2003; Author: Paul M. Weyrich

How the Saudis betrayed Islam (Book Review)
Source: Globebooks; Published: January 25, 2003; Author: Paul William Roberts

London Muslim Cleric Urges Boys to Be Martyrs
Source: Fox News; Published: January 23, 2003, Author: AP

THE KORAN AND THE KAFIR (Chapter 9) Islam In Action
Source: ; Author: A. GHOSH

Fatwa: Coming to a Country Near You--Islamic death bounties ain't hard to find
Source:; Published: December 6, 2002; Author: David Harsanyi

Al-Qaeda's Global Jihad
Source:IDF; Published: December 3, 2002

Why we are losing the war
Source: Guardian Unlimited; Published : December 1, 2002

Islam - Green Wall Of Silence - III
Source: PakToday : Published: November 25, 2002; Author: Tashbh Sayyed

Black Muslims Create 'Explosive Mix' in Terror War, Says Author
Source:; Published: November 14, 2002; Author: Marc Morano

Of course, the great majority of Muslims are peaceful -- so what?
Source: Jewish World Review; Published: November 5, 2002; Author: Dennis Prager

Ramadan: A Month of Peace?
Source: Toogood Reports; Published: November 4, 2002; Author:| Alan Caruba

The Seamless Garment Of Hate: The Beltway Sniper Shootings And Islam/Nation of Islam
Source: Toogood Reports; Published:| November 1, 2002; Author: Nicholas Stix

Barbara Stanley: American Jihadist Terrorism - Conversion And Recruitment
Source: Toogood Reports; Published: October 28, 2002; Author: Barbara Stanley

Jihadis in the Hood: Race, Urban Islam and the War on Terror
Source: Middle East Report; Published: Fall 2002; Author: Hisham Aidi

The Radical Islamic Mind (lengthy exposé from Christian perspective)
Source:Spiritual Counterfeits Project; Published: Sept 2002; Author: Aleesha Khan

Naming The Evildoers: Militant Islam Reaches America
Source: New York Times BOOK REVIEW; Published:| September 29, 2002; Author: Judith Miller

Source: WINSTON MID EAST ANALYSIS & Published: September 13, 2002; Author: Emanuel A. Winston

A Hatred Beyond Understanding
Source: Sierra Times; Published: September 9, 2002; Author: Alan Caruba

Saving Islam from bin Laden [Christopher Hitchens]
Source:The Age (Melbourne); Published: September 5 2002; Author: Christopher Hitchens

Muslim leaders pledge to 'transform West': 'If Islamic state rises, we will be its army'
Source:; Published: August 13, 2002; Author: Jon Dougherty

WHAT went wrong with the Arab world?
Source: Economist; Published: July 10, 2002

Today's Criminal Will Become Tomorrow's Islamic Terrorist
Source:; Published: June 25, 2002; Author: C.T. Rossi

David Horowitz: Know The Enemy (And What He Believes)
Source: FrontPage magazine; Published: June 24, 2002; Author: David Horowitz

Four Myths About Muslims
Source:; Published: June 13, 2002; Author: C.T. Rossi

Trying To Find A `Moderate' Islam Is A Quixotic Quest
Source:; Published: May 20, 2002; Author: C.T. Rossi

The Islaming of Europe
Source:; Published: May 20, 2002; Author: Alan Caruba

Why Islam Can't Join the Modern World
Source:; Published: May 16, 2002; Author: Jamie Glazov

It's The Attitude, Stupid [re: Palestinians]
Source: Toogood Reports; Published: May 14, 2002; Author: Philip Safran

Reports of Moderate Islam's Existence Have Been Greatly Exaggerated
Source:; Published: April 22, 2002; Author: C.T. Rossi

It's time to snap out of Arab fantasy land {Steyn}
Source: National Post; Published: April 19 2002; Author: Mark Steyn

Source: News and; Published; April 10, 2002; Author: David Horowitz

Arafat Must Go!
Source:; Published: April 10, 2002; Author: Alan Caruba

Netanyahu speaks before US Senators
Source:; Published: April 10, 2002; Author: Benjamin Netanyahu

20 Suppressed Facts About Israel, Islam
Source: Koenig's International News; Published: April 9, 2002; Author: Jim Bramlett

They Live to Die (Islam Martyrdom)
Source: Wall Street Journal; Published: April 7, 2002; Author: Reuel Marc Gerecht

Moral Fortitude Vs. Vacillation
Source: ; Published: April 01, 2002; Author: Alan Caruba

Terror's Homebase, All Over The Map -- Jihad: The Trail of Political Islam
Source: Wall Street Journal-- Book Review; Published: | March 29, 2002; Author: Adrian Karatnycky

Islam Vs. The World
Source: Toogood Reports; Published: December 2, 2001; Author: Alan Caruba

Arab World Poverty -- Whose Fault?
Source: Capitalism Magazine; Published: November 18, 2001; Author: Larry Elder

Understanding Islam And Its Radicals
Source:; Published: November 11, 2001; Author: Ana Barrett

Will the Real Islam Please Stand Up!
Source:Van Jenerette Editorial Comment, Various Publications; Published: October 14, 2001; Author: Van Jenerette

Civilization Envy
Source: National Review Online; Published: September 28, 2001; Author: Jonah Goldberg

What We Are Up Against: Islamic Jihad Factories
Source: New York Times Magazine; Published: July 25, 2000; Author: Jeffrey Goldberg

1 posted on 06/20/2003 8:32:22 AM PDT by Stand Watch Listen
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | View Replies]

To: Stand Watch Listen
Good research SWL. Bookmarked.
2 posted on 06/20/2003 8:45:50 AM PDT by Calpernia (Remember the three R's: Respect for self; Respect for others; Responsibility for all your actions.)
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Stand Watch Listen
Iraq is not ready for a majority rules system of govt.
3 posted on 06/20/2003 8:52:04 AM PDT by tkathy
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Stand Watch Listen
4 posted on 06/20/2003 9:31:02 AM PDT by GoLightly
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: tkathy
Iraq is not ready for a majority rules system of govt.

I think you are correct. We should be focusing on seetting up "new schools" and working with youngsters in IRAQ. It's going to take a generation to heal them out.

5 posted on 06/20/2003 10:02:19 AM PDT by RISU
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 3 | View Replies]

To: martianagent
6 posted on 06/20/2003 10:05:59 AM PDT by martianagent
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Stand Watch Listen
There are lots of things to complain about when it comes to Islamic clerics and their excesses. They make great targets whenever we want to take time out from living the beliefs of our own religions and simply attack the beliefs of others. 

But seriously folks, we can’t honestly say that ‘Iraq will never see democracy because of its religion’. The largest nation where the majority of citizens are Moslem is Indonesia, which has a democratic government. The country that has the second largest bunch of Moslems is India. Turkey is not alone as an Islamic democracy. Most Moslem countries are despotic just as most countries of any religion are run by despots; but on balance, most Moslems are already democrats.
7 posted on 06/20/2003 10:06:59 AM PDT by expat_panama
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: Stand Watch Listen
"In its 5,000-year history, Iraqis have never played any role in the governance of their nation, and the past three decades of ruthless and barbaric rule by Saddam Hussein have not prepared them for this task."

So? After the Japanese surrendered in World War II we learned that the Japanese people worshipped their emperor as a god. The Japanese were not accustomed to governing themselves either. The United States had to occupy Japan for 8 years to teach them how to run their government. Look at the Japanese now!

8 posted on 06/20/2003 10:14:52 AM PDT by Destructor
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 1 | View Replies]

To: expat_panama
Pick a country & do a search for info from the perspective of a religious minority living in the country.
9 posted on 06/20/2003 10:52:55 AM PDT by GoLightly
[ Post Reply | Private Reply | To 7 | View Replies]

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794 is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson