[Maceman]

I guess we don't know that yet, do we. Let's see how it plays out.

[harpseal]

Since he claimed American citizenship even though he "lost" his passport, the treason stands.

Stay well - Staysafe - stay armed - Yorktown

[Christian B]

Amen - I think Liberal Socialists are cowards because they don't have the courage to go to Canada or England where they would fit in better. Rather, they choose to stay here with the hope of making America "a better place" for my children.

[Pete]

I was listening to Rush go through the Newsweek story today and had the exact same thought you outlined above. The guy should be treated as an enemy but I felt kind of proud in a weird sort of way when they describe how he acted during the CIA interview. No whining baby, there!

[RedBloodedAmerican]

Dan Rather, take note.

[opbuzz]

Just like the suicide bombers! Only he didn't quite make the Darwin award list.

[wheezer]

Is there any chance whatsoever that this guy was an American plant/infiltrator from day one?

[Semper]

Johnny came right out and went to Afghanistan and openly fought with the side he felt was right.

Not quite accurate. He went to that area before 9-ll, just to assimilate islam. It appears as though he then kind of drifted into the Taliban, again before 9-11. He is young, misguided, weird and not worth all the attention he is getting.

[Cicero]

This is kind of like admiring a murderer more than someone who hates people but refrains from killing them. Call it hypocrisy, if you like, but not killing people and not taking up arms against your own country are good things. Sometimes hypocrisy and cowardice prevent people from committing crimes, and frankly that's all to the good.

[primeval patriot]

More like daddy's money.

[stainlessbanner]

Walker should be dressed in a pig suit and tied up deep in a Florida Swamp. The gators will do the rest, y'hear?

[Always Right]

First, how can it be treason when he is no longer a citizen.

He still is an American citizen.

You got guts Johnny, and you did stand up for your beliefs, so I respect ya.

The same could be said of Hitler.

[Billthedrill]

While having the courage of one's convictions may be an admirable trait, I think it's offset by the cowardliness of openly supporting the deliberate murder of 4000 innocents in the WTC. You admire the guy - I think he's scum.

[exmoor]

All together now...When Johnny comes marching home again..NO WAY, NO WAY...When Johnny comes marching home again..NO WAY, NO WAY. I'm too tired to sing the rest.

[DoughtyOne]

Nope!

[wtc911]

So young....so dumb....Do you also respect the Rosenbergs? They fried for their convictions. Would you have the same sentiment if he had trained as a pilot and flew on 9/11? What makes you believe that his silence right before our CIA man's murder is somehow heroic, not just an awareness of what was about to happen? The sociopathic little bastard was just as likely too scared to speak. What if he wasn't captured and used his American status to re-enter the country and bring with him a little vial that happened to be used in your hometown?

Why not hop on your scooter and spend Christmas at what's left of the WTC, now known as a grave for over three thousand innocents. Get in touch with their spirits, believe me, you can feel them. Then pray and re-think the values which you find worthy of respect.

[A Navy Vet]

Why are you wasting words on this pond scum? Unless he renounced his US citizenship, he's a f****** traitor. And if he didn't, he's the f****** Taliban.

Repect? Not from me.

[Liberal Classic]

Well, I will admit he has more gumption than that guy who couldn't afford a plane ticket to Afganistan because he was on welfare, but that's not saying a whole lot.

If he is a Talib fighter, then he was giving aid an comfort to our enemies. It doesn't matter if he joined up before the terrorist attack. He was still there when our boys captured him. He was inside that prison when it rioted. He may have been involved in the first U.S. casualty. It was no big secret they attacked the United States. They were proud of it and they trumpeted their victory over the great Satan. The Talibs may not have told their people all the details, but they celebrated their strike against us. There's no way he could not have known that his country had been attacked. If he was still there of his own accord, helping them, then that's a clear case of treason than I've ever heard.

I may be more liberal that you on some things, but in this case I'd sooner put a bullet in his head than give him a glass of water.

[my_pointy_head_is_sharp]

Walker lied and said he hadn't seen any American agents, yet Walker was interviewed by Mike Spann just moments before Spann was killed in the jail uprising.

[Saundra Duffy]

He did look pretty pitiful, all dirty and scroungy. But . . . it's time to pay the piper. For victory & freedom!!!